Nancy Baker

7/15/25Jessica Dailey

Google Review

We’ve now bought and sold homes with Nancy twice in Upper Arlington, and both times have been nothing short of exceptional. The Columbus market is incredibly competitive, but Nancy guided us through it with complete confidence and clarity. She knew exactly how to position our offer to win—both times we submitted just one offer, and both times we got the house. That’s not luck—that’s a realtor who knows what she’s doing.

When it came to selling our previous home, Nancy handled every detail with a sharp eye and strategic mindset. She advised us on exactly how to stage and price it to attract strong offers without lingering on the market. Sure enough, over 50 people came through our open house and we had multiple offers within just a few hours. It was fast, smooth, and incredibly successful—all thanks to her.

To top it all off, we had a vacation planned in the middle of the buying and selling process. Nancy took over everything while we were away, managing timelines, paperwork, showings, and prep work on both ends so we could actually enjoy our time off without stress. Any time we started to feel overwhelmed, she calmly reassured us: “I’ve got it.” And she truly did.

Nancy isn’t just knowledgeable—she’s a total pro with the perfect balance of confidence, warmth, and hustle. We trust her completely and couldn’t recommend her more highly.

4/22/25Chris Petek

Google Review

Nancy helped us find our dream home in German Village. She is extremely knowledgeable of the market and helped walk us through the process. We will continue to recommend anyone looking for a house to work with her!

2/7/25Jason Morgan

Google Review

Nancy made buying a new home as painless as one can possibly hope for. She was very responsive to our needs (including nights, weekends, and holidays), patient with our indecision, and highly knowledgeable about the process and market. When we had questions she couldn't answer (which were few!) she found experts we could talk to. She also has an extensive list of partners in the mortgage and home improvement community in Central Ohio, which we could call on when needed. In the end, Nancy helped us land a dream home in a dream location. We couldn't be happier. Highly recommended. Thank you, Nancy!

12/9/24Brandon

Google Review

Nancy was very thorough in her approach and strategy to maximize the selling value of my home. Very responsive and easy to work with. Would highly recommend!

10/31/24Thomas Robinson

Google Review

Nancy helped us with our first home purchase over the summer. In a competitive environment she went above and beyond to get us in to see the properties. She was extremely knowledgeable about the market, property values, and construction of homes. She made the process easy and walked us through every step always available to answer all of our questions. We were very impressed and appreciative of her effort.

9/27/24diana mancilla

Google Review

Nancy’s support throughout the process made a world of difference. She was patient, knowledgeable, and so attentive to what we needed. We can’t thank her enough for finding our dream home. I highly recommend nancy to anyone looking for a realtor who truly cares about their clients and works tirelessly to find the right fit.

8/28/24Laura Ferullo

Google Review

Cannot recommend Nancy enough!!! She was so wonderful and responsive in the home buying process, where my fiancé was able to be there in person but I had to FaceTime in. She listened to everything we wanted to see in a house and made it happen!! We also love receiving her little gift baskets for the holidays- it makes us feel so special as clients!

8/28/24Ken

Google Review

I can't speak highly enough about Nancy's professionalism and attention to detail. I was moving back to Columbus area after many years away. She was my eyes and ears a thousand miles away and when I did come to visit she had appointments coordinated to maximize my time. After all her hard work I'm happy to report I'm one week into a great new home that she identified and made happen. Thank you Nancy!

8/12/24Natalie Horner

Google Review

Nancy made my experience with my home sale easy, smooth, and fun. She brought an incredibly high level of professionalism to the table at all times and far exceeded my expectations as my realtor and representative. I will be sure to use Nancy for future real estate needs and will happily refer her to friends and family as well. Thanks Nancy!!

8/9/24Drew Davis

Google Review

Working with Nancy to find our home was great! She made it such a breeze and was available any time of day for any questions we had. She went above and beyond in every aspect!

6/27/24Alexandra Liles

Google Review

I’m so thankful my friend referred me to Nancy! My husband and I have been looking for our first home since moving to Columbus years ago. In a matter of months after meeting Nancy we are now moved into our home and we could not have done it without her! Nancy was so supportive and encouraging throughout the process, from showings to inspections and referrals to relevant contractors along the way. She helped us with it all and was always happy to do so. I truly appreciate her attentiveness and flexibility, she made herself available to us whenever questions came up, no matter the time or day. It was obvious from the beginning that she truly cares about her clients and wanted us to find the home that was right for us and with her help we did! Thank you so much, Nancy, I will continue to refer you to anyone I know looking for a home in Columbus.

3/10/24Elsa Saelens

Google Review

If I could give Nancy more than 5 stars I would. I cannot recommend her enough to anyone entering the housing market. She is extremely hard working, very knowledgeable, and a pleasure to work with. She's always quick to respond, and we could really see the dedication she has to her job. She also has great connections throughout Columbus that not only helped us find our house off-market but made the whole buying and move in process so much easier. Thanks Nancy!

12/18/23Skyler Knoop

Google Review

Nancy was so helpful throughout our home buying process. She truly walked us through every step of the process. Nancy was always available to answer each and every question we had. We are so excited to finally be in our new home! Thanks Nancy!

10/10/23Dan Reed

Google Review

Nancy is a great friend and client. She is smart, kind and compassionate. I would highly recommend her for all your real estate needs.

9/9/23Anderson Haxton

Google Review

Nancy did a great job for us. In addition to helping with our home search Nancy connected us with a number of additional resources who were also helpful. Highly recommend.

5/27/23Kathleen Layer

Google Review

Nancy helped us find our second home when we were moving pretty quickly for my husband's new job. Not only did she help us find our dream home in the best location (and in our budget), but she also found us a realtor to sell our first home because we were moving from out of state. What would have been a massively stressful process, Nancy made simple, clear, and enjoyable. She really does just want her clients to be happy and you can see that in every action she takes with you from first meeting to closing to even after you've moved in and beyond. Couldn't have asked for a better experience. Thank you, Nancy!

4/3/23Dede S.

Google Review

Nancy Baker is smart, hard-working, professional, and a joy to work with! I was dreading the process of selling my house, but she made it short and painless!

1/23/23Rick Lane

Google Review

Successfully sold two houses - always there when we needed her - Thanks for all your hard work.

1/19/23Tabitha Burton

Google Review

Nancy is one of the hardest working agents in central Ohio! She is very knowledgeable and will help answer any questions you might have. I would recommend Nancy!

1/19/23Morgan Whalen

Google Review

If you are looking for a motivated and dedicated Realtor look no further. I have seen first hand the dedication Nancy has for the people she is helping everyday! Very knowledgeable in Columbus and surrounding areas to make sure wherever you are looking you get a partner who can guide you to find or sell that perfect home!

10/30/22Jessica Reinhardt

Google Review

As first time home buyers, my husband and I were dreading the home buying process and all the stress that can come with it in the current market. Nancy turned our attitudes around from the start, getting us excited about the process so we could enjoy this next big life event.

Nancy made herself available at the drop of a hat, was super responsive and jumped on scheduling showings any time we wanted to see a house she passed on to us that met our needs.

The second we expressed interest in a home that was not yet on the market, she acted fast and made sure we were the first to see the house on the day it opened for showings. Nancy knew exactly what needed to be done if we were going to take a stab at getting the house of our dreams. She kept track of all questions we wanted to ask the sellers, and moved quickly on any negotiations agreed upon, with her expertise.

Anytime we started having questions late into the evening she was responsive and offered to jump on a quick call to talk through it to make sure we fully understood the process and next steps and felt fully comfortable.

With Nancy’s direction we got a competitive offer in, leading the sellers to cancel their open house scheduled for that coming weekend. Without Nancy we never even would have known what to do, how to do it, let alone the fact it COULD be done.

I’ve already HIGHLY recommended Nancy to friends and will continue to do so, not only did she make a process we were dreading seamless and smooth, she made it fun and memorable and certainly a positive ‘first home buying process’ we will never forget.

6/15/22Matthew Marsalka

Google Review

Trusted real estate advisor.

2/11/22Jacqueline Cotter

Google Review

Highly recommend Nancy - She’s responsive, professional, available, and always kept me informed throughout the sale of my condo. She made it an easy & smooth process.

2/9/22Roo Cotter

Google Review

As a first time homebuyer that was very overwhelmed and stressed, Nancy made the entire experience quick and seamless. From the first showings all the way to closing, she was on top of it all and I highly recommend seeking her out for you next home purchase or sale!

12/23/21Zach Mizer

Google Review

Nancy is the best, could not imagine having a better realtor!
Nancy is responsive, very knowledgeable, and just a genuinely nice person. She helped me buy our first home this summer. It was right in the middle of a crazy year, so it was quite the time to be looking as a first time home buyer, but she made it a far easier process.
We noticed right away that she knew her stuff on all things real estate. She quickly learned our preferences, and what we were looking for overall.
If I ever had any questions she was always quick to respond, and when I found a house that I wanted to see she quickly made it happen. I know where I will go for all future real estate needs!
I definitely recommend!

7/29/21Emily Huneck

Google Review

Nancy is an awesome Realtor! She is very responsive and easy to work with.

6/25/21Valerie lyster

Google Review

Nancy is great! Friendly, responsible and on top of all things real estate. She can help you to buy or sell and makes the process easy for you.

5/28/21Samantha Ullum

Google Review

Nancy was incredible to work with, very responsive and professional.

2/5/21Jillian Woltz

Google Review

Nancy is great to work with - super knowledgeable and my go-to for all things real estate!

2/5/21Samantha Zid

Google Review

Nancy is a pleasure to work with! She is always available for real estate advice and professional!