Section Image

Nancy Baker

Responds Quickly
5.0stars, 41 Reviews
Engel & Volkers Real Estate Advisors
47 Closed Sales
$20.3M Total Value
$232K - $1M Price Range
$432K Average Price
Prior 5 years

About Nancy

Nancy Baker is the Principal Broker of Engel & Völkers Real Estate Advisors and a top-producing REALTOR® serving Columbus, Ohio. Ranked among the top 4% of real estate professionals in the Columbus market out of nearly 10,000 licensed agents, Nancy specializes in luxury, historic, and move-up homes throughout Columbus' most sought-after neighborhoods, including Upper Arlington, German Village, Grandview Heights, Clintonville, Italian Village, and Victorian Village.

As one of fewer than 600 licensed brokers in Central Ohio and one of the youngest brokers in the Columbus market, Nancy combines broker-level expertise with hands-on buyer and seller representation, an uncommon combination in today's real estate industry. Licensed since 2020, she has facilitated more than 70 successful home sales and nearly $30 million in career sales volume while consistently ranking among the top-producing advisors within her brokerage. In 2025, Nancy was tied for the number one solo agent in her brokerage by units sold, reflecting both her productivity and the trust she has built with clients.

Unlike many brokerage leaders who no longer actively represent clients, Nancy has built her business independently as a solo agent through repeat and referral relationships. Her clients benefit from broker-level guidance, strategic negotiation expertise, and a highly personalized approach throughout every stage of the transaction. This commitment to service is reflected in the fact that 100% of her public client reviews across real estate platforms are five-star ratings.

Nancy's leadership, sales performance, and commitment to the profession have earned recognition from both Columbus REALTORS® and Real Producers, including Rookie of the Year, the President's Merit, Commitment, and Excellence Awards, and recognition as a 2026 Real Producers Agent on Fire. These honors reflect both her production and her contributions to the real estate industry and local community.

Born and raised in Upper Arlington, Nancy offers clients a lifelong understanding of Columbus neighborhoods, architecture, and lifestyle. She is known not only for her market expertise but also for her deep connection to the communities she serves. From historic homes in German Village to luxury residences in Upper Arlington and Grandview Heights, Nancy helps clients navigate not only the real estate market but also the lifestyle that makes each neighborhood unique.

In addition to her real estate work, Nancy serves as the volunteer chair for Engel & Völkers charitable initiatives and actively supports Special Olympics. Her combination of local roots, broker-level expertise, and relationship-driven service has made her a trusted advisor for buyers and sellers throughout Central Ohio.
Home Types: House, Townhouse, Condo, Multifamily
Years of Experience: 6

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Total Deals 10
Total Value $3,275,203
Average Sale Price $327,520
Price Range $175K - $515K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals 13
Total Value $5,709,026
Average Sale Price $439,156
Price Range $245K - $1M

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Total Deals 16
Total Value $5,859,803
Average Sale Price $366,238
Price Range $175K - $875K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals 25
Total Value $11,973,301
Average Sale Price $478,932
Price Range $225K - $1M

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Nancy's Listings and Deals

Other Experience

First Time Homebuyers, Luxury Homes

Nancy's Reviews

5.0stars, 41 Reviews

8/11/26Zakkery Root

Google Review

Nancy is an incredible real estate agent, and we’re so grateful to have had the opportunity to work with her. She helped us purchase our first home in Columbus, and we couldn’t have asked for a better person to guide us through the process.

Our living situation required a home with several specific features, and Nancy always made us feel supported and reassured that we would be able to find the right home within our budget. Throughout the process, my wife and I frequently talked about how working with Nancy felt more like working with a friend than a real estate agent. She is just as personable as she is professional.

Nancy was constantly updating our portal with properties that met our requirements and refining our search criteria to help us find the perfect first home. When we finally found “the one,” Nancy guided us through putting together an extremely competitive offer that was ultimately accepted.

When the time comes to buy our next house, there is no doubt in my mind that we will work with Nancy again. We’re incredibly grateful for everything she did to help us find our first home.

7/16/26Kaylee Luke

Google Review

We recently bought our first home with Nancy in Columbus, and the entire experience was such a breeze. You always hear about how stressful the home-buying process can be, but we never felt stressed about anything that was within Nancy’s control.

The market was incredibly competitive when we were searching, but Nancy was always quick to respond, proactive, and incredibly knowledgeable. She answered every question we had, guided us through each step of the process, and navigated the market with confidence and efficiency to help us secure our dream home.

What really set Nancy apart was how personally invested she was in helping us find the right home - it truly felt like finding our home was just as important to her as it was to us. Honestly, texting her Zillow links felt more like texting a friend than working with a realtor. She paid attention to the details we loved in each house and consistently steered us toward homes with those same qualities, making the search feel personalized from the start.

Our budget was tight and our timeline was short, but we never once felt discouraged or overwhelmed because we knew Nancy was in our corner. We started the process feeling completely clueless, and thanks to her guidance, we learned so much along the way.

We couldn’t recommend Nancy more highly. She’s professional, responsive, genuinely caring, and an absolute joy to work with. When the time comes to sell this home and buy our next one, there won’t even be a question - Nancy will be our first call.

6/17/26Jennifer Armstrong

Google Review

Nancy Baker was incredible! She made the sale of my home easy and much less stressful. We struggled to find a new home we liked and she was always patient and accommodating. The whole endeavor on both the Seller's and Buyer's sides went as seamless as possible. I don't plan on going through this process again soon, but when I do, I'll absolutely use Nancy!

Agent License: Ohio #2026000822
Agent Photo

Nancy Baker

Responds Quickly