Robert Kincaid

Meet Robert & Shirley – Your Trusted Real Estate Team
With decades of combined experience, Robert and Shirley deliver exceptional service, integrity, and results for every client. Both are Five Star Agents, consistently ranking in the top 7% of real estate professionals in the Indianapolis area for 13 consecutive years.

Robert began his real estate career in 1983 and quickly became a “go-to” agent known for savvy negotiations, cutting-edge marketing, and uncompromising integrity. Born and raised in Fishers, Indiana, Robert offers legendary knowledge of local communities and specializes in single-family homes, condos, new construction, investment properties, and complex transactions like short sales and 1031 exchanges. His entrepreneurial background and hands-on approach have earned him a loyal referral-based business built on trust and results.

Shirley brings a strong business foundation and Midwestern values to real estate. After earning her MBA from Marquette University and leading Fortune 500 accounts in sales and marketing, she transitioned to real estate in 1995 as co-owner and managing partner of Kincaid Realtors. Shirley is passionate about delivering a personalized, results-driven experience and handpicks her team to ensure seamless service for every client.

Together, Robert and Shirley share a philosophy rooted in service, ethics, and lasting relationships. Guided by the belief that “People don’t care how much you know until they know how much you care,” they combine deep market expertise with innovative strategies to make buying or selling your home stress-free and successful.

Beyond Real Estate: Both are committed to giving back—supporting animal rescue causes and community initiatives, and spending time with family and friends.
Ready to make your move? Robert and Shirley are here to help you achieve your goals with confidence and care.