St. Mary's Elementary School

St Marys School is a private school serving students in Middletown Township NJ.

St. Mary's Elementary School

Private Pre-K, Elementary, Middle School | Grade Pre-K-8

538 Church St, Middletown, NJ

New Monmouth Neighborhood

3.3

3.5

School Details

Students
521

Student Teacher Ratio
15:1

Religious Affiliation
Catholic

Niche Grade Details

Teachers

Student Teacher Ratio

15:1

Teachers

Full Time Teachers

Part Time Teachers

GreatSchools Rating Details

Student Diversity

Male

50.4%

Female

49.6%

White

88.2%

Hispanic

6.1%

Two or more races

3.6%

Black

1.1%

Native American

<1%

Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander

<1%

Asian

<1%

This School’s Reviews

4.0 Parent

8/17/2022

When public schools went remote for COVID we transferred to Saint Mary School which remained open 5 full days days a week. Our children thrived with small class size and incredible teachers. Having access to the staff and faculty made the transition easier on everyone. Each classroom has a door to the outside which extended the learning possibilities. We are happy with the progress.

See All Niche Reviews

1.0 parent

12/7/2024

Faculty and staff are alright but most of the good ones left the school. Everyone who is still there a terrible. The school is far behind public. No computer use at all . History teacher and security guards are the only good ones at the school . Save your money and send your kids to public . They ch...

5.0 other

9/26/2024

My review is more historical than useful, but I had a great time learning at St Mary’s in the late 1950’s through the mid 1960’s. Kindergarten back then was held in a little building in the dirt parking lot behind the old Church building across the street from the grade school.

1.0 parent

12/5/2023

There is a reason so many kids are pulling their children from this school. Just ask Middletown BOE. It’s not a coincidence that there are so many students transferring out before and during middle school when parents see what the school is truly about. What was once a wonderful institution of leani...

1.0 parent

2/28/2020

SMS is a dark place filled with lies and secrets. They take your money promising many things, but follow through with nothing. When the principal doesn’t want to deal with a situation, it’s mass suspension. Shame they claim to have catholic values, but they are the farthest from it. Bullying is ever...

See More GreatSchools Reviews

Agents Specializing Near This School

Victoria Benites

Coldwell Banker Realty

(848) 400-4916

55 Total Sales

1 Near This School

$490,000 Price

Victoria Benites
Fran Reali

Safari Realty

(347) 934-6719

102 Total Sales

1 Near This School

$390,000 Price

Fran Reali
Peter Hunt

C21/ Action Plus Realty

(855) 955-0820

88 Total Sales

3 Near This School

$85K - $790K Price Range

Peter Hunt
Jessica Matute

JM Properties

(646) 828-1068

82 Total Sales

1 Near This School

$550,000 Price

Jessica Matute
Kevin Daily

Coldwell Banker Realty

(848) 294-3778

20 Total Sales

1 Near This School

$500,000 Price

Kevin Daily
Elana Shapiro

HomeSmart First Advantage

(908) 365-0639

27 Total Sales

1 Near This School

$106,000 Price

Elana Shapiro

See All Agents

Map

Explore this Neighborhood New Monmouth

Explore New Monmouth

List Price Range

$370K - $3.4M

Homes For Sale

Average Home Value

$832,299

Median Lot Size

21,780 Sq Ft

% Renters

13%

Average Household Income

$160,077

% of College Grads

51%

Median Age

Average House Size

3,656 Sq Ft

% Commercial Property

37.7%

Homes for Sale

$649,900

3 Beds
2 Baths

807 6th St
Unit A & B
New 13 days ago

COASTAL LIVING WITH INCOME!! 2 BUILDINGS ON 1 LOT, COMPLETELY RENOVATED, MOVE IN READY. LIVE IN ONE - RENT OUT THE OTHER. PERFECT M/D SET-UP OR INVESTMENT PROP. FRONT HOUSE HAS HW FLOORS THRU-OUT, NEW KITCHEN W/GRANITE CT'S, UNDER CABINETRY LIGHTING, NEW BATHROOM, 2 BEDROOMS, LIVINGROOM W/ ELECTRIC ...

Josephine Schiffres

PremiumONE Realty

(732) 808-2856

$2,400,000

6 Beds
6 Baths

73 3rd Ave

Discover an extraordinary living opportunity in the heart of downtown Atlantic Highlands. This 3 family home that was once a thriving church has been transformed into 3 amazing living spaces. The main church with all its preserved character boasts an open floor plan with a sleeping loft; the 2nd uni...

Jackie Grieco

Compass New Jersey LLC

(732) 627-1275

$679,000

3 Beds
1.5 Baths
1,566 Sq Ft

901 Palmer Ave

A MUST SEE! Price REDUCED!!! Fully renovated 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home featuring a spacious living room with a fireplace, formal dining room, sunroom, and a modern kitchen with new stainless steel appliances. Includes a semi-finished basement, dual-zone HVAC systems, fully paid solar panels, and a la...

Felix Santana

J.J. Elek Guarantee Sales

(732) 551-3908

$699,000

4 Beds
2.5 Baths
1,784 Sq Ft

8 Newman St
New 11 days ago

Welcome to 8 Newman Street, where timeless character meets a complete down to the studs renovation in Hazlet. Originally built in 1921 and beautifully reimagined for modern living, this 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home offers an open concept layout with a spacious living room, dining area, and oversized kit...

Anthony Genovese

VRI Homes

(732) 860-2283

$515,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
1,422 Sq Ft

21 Anderson St
New 12 days ago

Welcome to this beautifully remodeled 3-bedroom, 2-bath Bayshore home, thoughtfully updated just six years ago! It now offers modern finishes, flexible living space, and a convenient commuter-friendly location. The updated kitchen features newer stainless-steel appliances, elegant quartz countertops...

Deborah Mara

RE/MAX Homeland Realtors

(848) 206-3469

$649,900

3 Beds
2.5 Baths
2,112 Sq Ft

602 Park Ave
Unit 7C
New 20 days ago

Get in before summer! Park Ferry at Shoal Harbor -- a stunning 3-bed, 2.5-bath Townhome where coastal calm meets city convenience. Solid oak floors, gourmet granite kitchen, and sun-drenched open living make an instant impression. The primary suite features a custom walk-in closet, dual vanities, gl...

Bradley Moore

O'Brien Realty, LLC

(848) 359-5132

$629,000

2 Beds
2 Baths
1,179 Sq Ft

3 Auburn Ct
New 15 days ago

You came, you saw, and we listened! Now it's time to revisit the beautifully transformed 3 Auburn Court. We've reimagined the space by relocating the washer and dryer out of the kitchen, creating a seamless, open layout perfect for entertaining and everyday living.This stunningly renovated Brent...

Leonora Caminiti

Compass New Jersey LLC

(732) 313-3714

$694,999

3 Beds
2 Baths
2,376 Sq Ft

637 Clark Ave
New 23 hours ago

This is a coming soon listing and may not be shown until 3/27/26. Please come see this like-new home in Union Beach offering everything you would want in new construction but without the need of an elevator or flood insurance! Built in 2001 with approx 2600 sq ft of living space, this custom colonia...

Carissa Marshall

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Fox & Roach - Holmdel

(848) 353-1302

$849,900

3 Beds
3.5 Baths
2,668 Sq Ft

48 Starr Ct

Beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 3.5-bath Chatsworth Model located in Navesink's sought after Cottage Gate community. Designed with open & inviting floor plan, the home features spacious family room with a gas fireplace for everyday living & entertaining. The chef kitchen boats granite countertops,...

Christopher Walsh

EXP Realty

(848) 253-6200

$524,999

3 Beds
2 Baths
1,648 Sq Ft

92 Ocean Ave

Charming home with 1.5 stories offers tons of potential and room to grow! This 3 bedroom, 1 bath home offers easy one-level living plus a versatile upstairs bonus room—perfect for a home office, playroom, or guest space. Behind the bonus room, you'll find generous unfinished storage with excellent p...

Danielle Coyle

RE/MAX Select

(732) 355-3520

$315,000

Land
0.24 Acre Lot

103 Creek Rd

Embrace waterfront living at its finest. This rare double lot offers sweeping views of Waackaack Creek and endless possibilities to design your dream coastal retreat. A brand-new bulkhead adds both beauty and peace of mind. Enjoy a relaxed shore lifestyle just minutes from local beaches, dining, and...

Christine Morford

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Fox & Roach - Rumson

(732) 607-4639

$649,900

3 Beds
2 Baths

807 6th St
New 2 days ago

Two houses for the price of ONE! Live in one and rent out the other, great M/D set up. Both houses completely renovated. Front house has hardwood floors through out, newer kitchen with granite counter tops, under cabinet lighting, new bathroom, 2 bedrooms, large livingroom with electric fireplace, r...

Josephine Schiffres

PREMIUMONEREALTY

(848) 354-0632

See All Homes

Homes for Rent

$4,500 per month

2 Beds
1.5 Baths

73 3rd Ave
Unit B
Atlantic Highlands, NJ

A spacious 2 bedroom - 1.5 bath one-of-a-kind rental in Atlantic Highlands is ready for you. This amazing space boasts an open concept living area/dining area with a chef's kitchen, a wine refrigerator plus a center island with seating for four. Just steps away from downtown shops, restaurants, and ...

Jackie Grieco

Compass New Jersey LLC

(732) 641-4460

$5,500 per month

4 Beds
2.5 Baths

73 3rd Ave
Unit C
Atlantic Highlands, NJ

Welcome to the historic charm of this 4 bedroom - 2.5 bath rental that is part of a beautifully converted church offering a blend of historic allure and modern living. Enter this fully renovated home and be welcomed by an open floor plan offering a large living room, an open concept chef's kitchen a...

Jackie Grieco

Compass New Jersey LLC

(732) 641-8641

$7,500 per month

1 Bed
1 Bath

73 3rd Ave
Unit A
Atlantic Highlands, NJ

Experience the rare opportunity to rent a truly one-of-a-kind residence in Atlantic Highlands-a once thriving church thoughtfully converted into a stunning space with a spacious loft sleeping area. This unique home features an open-concept living and kitchen area, perfect for hosting intimate dinner...

Jackie Grieco

Compass New Jersey LLC

(732) 860-2015

$3,800 per month

3 Beds
2.5 Baths
1,384 Sq Ft

15 Griggs Ave
Port Monmouth, NJ

Welcome to your Jersey Shore retreat! This 3-bed, 2.5-bath Shore Home. The open first floor features a spacious living room, dining area, and large kitchen with stainless steel appliances, granite counter tops, and in-kitchen laundry. Hardwood floors, 9-ft ceilings, and natural light create an airy ...

Danielle Farney

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Fox & Roach - Red Bank

(848) 358-7381

$3,500 per month

3 Beds
3.5 Baths
2,256 Sq Ft

590 Beachway Ave
Keansburg, NJ

Location, Location, Location! Bright and Airy water front 3-level 3 Bed 3 .5 Bath townhouse in a quiet community forever vacation. Move-in ready beautiful unit features amazing water views from the den, Primary Bedroom and private balcony, all large rooms, hardwood floors and open floor plan. The Fi...

Josephine Schiffres

PremiumONE Realty

(848) 375-1767

$5,500 per month

4 Beds
2.5 Baths
2,712 Sq Ft

36 Main St
Port Monmouth, NJ

Welcome to your shore house in Port Monmouth - just a quick walk over to the beach OR NYC via the Belford Ferry, making it commuter friendly. Newer built 2,712 sq house with 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, a large trex deck, and a fully fenced in yard. SUN DRENCHED spacious living room featuring hardwood...

Kushal Shah

Re/Max Instyle

(848) 368-0147

$2,750 per month

3 Beds
1 Bath
1,872 Sq Ft

143 Center Ave
Unit 2
Keansburg, NJ

Welcome to this large, freshly remodeled second-floor apartment in the heart of Keansburg. This bright and spacious 3-bedroom, 1-bath unit offers modern updates while maintaining a comfortable layout ideal for everyday living. The apartment features a brand-new interior, generous room sizes, and a f...

Kevin Daily

Coldwell Banker Realty

(732) 272-0964

$2,338 - $3,650 per month

Atlantic Pointe Apartments
1 - 3 Beds
1-2 Baths
640+ Sq Ft

165 Thousand Oaks Dr
Atlantic Highlands, NJ

Enjoy the best of coastal living at Atlantic Pointe Apartments, a garden-style apartment community in scenic Atlantic Highlands, NJ. Choose from spacious one- and two-bedroom floor plans with modern finishes and enjoy community amenities designed to make daily life more convenient and relaxing. Tuc...

$2,250 per month

2 Beds
1 Bath
660 Sq Ft

78 Shore Blvd
Unit A
Keansburg, NJ

Beautiful, fully updated, 2 bedroom apartment less than one block to the beach! Available for immediate occupancy. Kitchen includes updated stainless steel appliances and a washer/dryer combo unit tucked under the kitchen counter. Fall in love with the white cabinets, granite countertops, and white ...

Brian McNamara Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty

$5,101 - $10,989 per month

The Rail at Red Bank
2 Beds
2 Baths
1,247 Sq Ft

118 Chestnut St
Red Bank, NJ

Residents are required to pay: At Application: Holding Fee($500.00/unit); Application Fee($100.00/applicant, Nonrefundable); At Move-in: Security Deposit (Refundable)($1000.00-1.5 Months Rent); One Time Amenity Fee($400.00/unit);Parking: Optional & Pricing Varies Please visit the property website f...

$2,350 per month

2 Beds
1 Bath
438 Sq Ft

51 Ocean Ave
North Middletown, NJ

Annual rental only 3 blocks away from Middletown's own Ideal Beach! Available immediately - move right in to this charming and fully renovated beach cottage. The 2023 renovation included new kitchen appliances and new flooring throughout. Includes washer/dryer combo unit tucked under the kitchen cou...

Brian McNamara Heritage House Sotheby's International Realty

$1,818 - $3,700 per month

Cove on the Bay
1 - 2 Beds
1-2 Baths
774+ Sq Ft

250 Beachway Ave
Keansburg, NJ

Discover these new and exciting luxury apartments for rent, nestled right on the pristine beaches of Keansburg. Cove on the Bay features stunning waterfront views with thoughtfully designed 1- and 2-bedroom apartments. Located in desirable Monmouth County, bordered by Middlesex, Cove on the Bay is c...

See All Homes For Rent

Mater Dei Prep

9th to 12th
Private

A-

Baytul-Iman Academy

Pre-K to 11th
Private

Middletown High School North

9th to 12th
Public

B+

Normandy Park

Soccer
Tennis

Poricy Park Nature Center

Picnic Area
Trails
Multi-Purpose Field

Deep Cut Gardens

Picnic Area
Trails
Botanical Gardens

Tatum Park

Picnic Area
Trails
Events

Huber Woods Park

Trails
Hiking

Dorsett Park

Tennis
Playground

Nut Swamp Road Park

Playground

Countryside Park

Playground

Tindall Park

Basketball
Tennis
Playground

Additional Neighborhoods in this Area

Fair Haven

Red Bank

Trendy waterfront community with arts and culture

Belford

An industrial, waterfront neighborhood with great parks

Leonardo

Small town atmosphere with marina views and access to New York City

Little Silver

Navesink

Tiny and hilly hamlet close to beaches and NYC

Search Nearby Neighborhoods

New Jersey Monmouth County Middletown 07748 New Monmouth

St. Mary's Elementary School is a private Catholic school for students in grades Pre-K-8 located at 538 Church St in Middletown, NJ. Annual tuition is $0. The school has a total enrollment of 521 and maintains a student-teacher ratio of 15:1. The average home value in this area is $832,299. Discover additional schools in the area, like Mater Dei Prep, Baytul-Iman Academy, Middletown High School North, and more. Learn more about what Middletown has to offer, and browse homes for sale and for rent near St. Mary's Elementary School.

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Victoria Benites

Nearby Homes

New Monmouth