St. Mary's Elementary School

St Marys School is a private school serving students in Middletown Township NJ.

St. Mary's Elementary School

Private Pre-K, Elementary, Middle School | Grade Pre-K-8

538 Church St, Middletown, NJ

New Monmouth Neighborhood

3.3

3.5

School Details

Students
521

Student Teacher Ratio
15:1

Religious Affiliation
Catholic

Niche Grade Details

Teachers

Student Teacher Ratio

15:1

Teachers

Full Time Teachers

Part Time Teachers

GreatSchools Rating Details

Student Diversity

White

89.4%

Hispanic

7.9%

Two or more races

1.5%

Black

1.2%

Interested in learning more about homes nearby? Reach out to Justin Calderon, an agent with experience near this school.

This School’s Reviews

5.0 Alum

5/17/2024

What a wonderful community. The staff and administrators are fantastic. They care about every student and their individual experience. It is safe, Christ focused. I cannot say enough great things about it.

See All Niche Reviews

1.0 parent

12/7/2024

Faculty and staff are alright but most of the good ones left the school. Everyone who is still there a terrible. The school is far behind public. No computer use at all . History teacher and security guards are the only good ones at the school . Save your money and send your kids to public . They ch...

5.0 other

9/26/2024

My review is more historical than useful, but I had a great time learning at St Mary’s in the late 1950’s through the mid 1960’s. Kindergarten back then was held in a little building in the dirt parking lot behind the old Church building across the street from the grade school.

1.0 parent

12/5/2023

There is a reason so many kids are pulling their children from this school. Just ask Middletown BOE. It’s not a coincidence that there are so many students transferring out before and during middle school when parents see what the school is truly about. What was once a wonderful institution of leani...

1.0 parent

2/28/2020

SMS is a dark place filled with lies and secrets. They take your money promising many things, but follow through with nothing. When the principal doesn’t want to deal with a situation, it’s mass suspension. Shame they claim to have catholic values, but they are the farthest from it. Bullying is ever...

See More GreatSchools Reviews

Agents Specializing Near This School

Justin Calderon

Fathom Realty NJ, LLC

(877) 915-5135

45 Total Sales

2 Near This School

$399K - $709K Price Range

Justin Calderon
RR

Ranie Rampersaud

C21 CHARLES SMITH AGENCY, INC

(866) 926-4205

7 Total Sales

1 Near This School

$464,000 Price

Ranie Rampersaud
Justin Bosak

RE/MAX Revolution

(848) 285-6196

116 Total Sales

2 Near This School

$405K - $470K Price Range

Justin Bosak
Dawn Ochs

KELLER WILLIAMS RLTY OCEAN LIV

(908) 883-3323

26 Total Sales

1 Near This School

$379,900 Price

Dawn Ochs
Timothy Siciliano

C21/ Solid Gold Realty

(848) 272-7602

29 Total Sales

1 Near This School

$150,000 Price

Timothy Siciliano
Lauren Orsini

Berkshire Hathaway Home Services Fox & Roach Realtors - Montclair

(973) 406-4129

467 Total Sales

1 Near This School

$1,560,000 Price

Lauren Orsini

See All Agents

Map

About New Monmouth

Learn More About New Monmouth

List Price Range

$260K - $2.8M

Homes For Sale

Average Home Value

$794,212

Median Lot Size

23,958 Sq Ft

% Renters

13%

Household Income

$158,469

% of College Grads

50.2%

Median Age

Average House Size

3,696 Sq Ft

% Commercial Property

38.5%

Homes for Sale

$709,000
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,470 Sq Ft
711 Edmunds Ave

62 Days On Market
The Homeowners Are Investing A Portion Of This Sale Into Reducing Your Interest Rate- they are putting Their Money where Your Mortgage Is!!!!***This house comes with a REDUCED RATE as low as 5.625% (APR 5.975%) as of 03/24/2025 through List & Lock. This is a seller paid rate-buydown that reduces the...

Josephine Schiffres

IMPERIAL REALTY PROPERTIES

(848) 214-9724
$799,900
- 5 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,464 Sq Ft
168 Leonardville Rd

160 Days On Market
Prepare to be amazed by this stunningly beautiful Dutch Colonial, transformed from the studs up with no expense spared! Step into the expansive first floor featuring a sunlit living room, a show-stopping gourmet kitchen with a 13'x4.5' center island, a spacious dining area, a full bath, laundry room...

Carole Kubis

EXP Realty

(848) 294-3665
$585,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
422 Maple Dr

41 Days On Market
Totally renovated ranch with beautiful Shaker white kitchen cabinets, new stove, refrigerator,dishwasher. All hard wood flooring, upgraded Caiman interior doors, newer siding and solar panels. Lot is 80x100 with detached garage, sheds and central air conditioning. No wonder Niche.com writes: ''Belf...

Ronald Raimondo

Key Agency Inc

(848) 306-0113

See All Homes

Homes for Rent

$4,300 per month
- 6 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,520 Sq Ft
12 Orchard St

Keansburg, NJ
This charming mother-daughter style home offers a rare blend of space, privacy, and comfort. With 6 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, it's an ideal layout for large families or those seeking extra room for guests or multi-generational living. The separate living areas on each floor allow for both...

Felix Santana

J.J. Elek Guarantee Sales

(848) 275-3168
$3,400 per month
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
97 Park Ave

Keansburg, NJ
Welcome to your dream home at 97 Park Ave, where modern elegance meets timeless charm! This beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers a perfect blend of style, comfort, and functionality. The home's three generously sized bedrooms provide ample space for rest and relaxation, and the tw...

yanli Zhang

EXP Realty

(848) 361-3304
$3,150 - $4,450 per month
- Colony House Apartments
- 1-2 Beds
- 1-2 Baths
- 844+ Sq Ft
122 Bodman Place

Red Bank, NJ
Enjoy the best in waterfront living in this newly renovated luxury building close to everything Red Bank has to offer. Beautiful wood floors, state of the art kitchen with stainless steel appliances, front loading washer/dryer, high end finishes, generous room sizes and secured access. With oversize...

See All Homes For Rent

Public Schools shown may be Choice Schools

Mater Dei Prep

9th to 12th
Private

A-

Baytul-Iman Academy

Pre-K to 11th
Private

Red Bank Catholic High School

9th to 12th
Private

Normandy Park

Soccer
Tennis

Poricy Park Nature Center

Picnic Area
Trails
Multi-Purpose Field

Deep Cut Gardens

Picnic Area
Trails
Botanical Gardens

Tatum Park

Picnic Area
Trails
Events

Huber Woods Park

Trails
Hiking

Dorsett Park

Tennis
Playground

Nut Swamp Road Park

Playground

Countryside Park

Playground

Tindall Park

Basketball
Tennis
Playground

Additional Neighborhoods in this Area

Fair Haven

Red Bank

Trendy waterfront community with arts and culture

Atlantic Highlands

Belford

An industrial, waterfront neighborhood with great parks

Leonardo

Little Silver

Search Nearby Neighborhoods

New Jersey Monmouth County Middletown 07748 New Monmouth

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Justin Calderon