Section Image Section Image

Explore Similar Homes Within 25 Miles of Shelter Island, NY

  • 288 Ranch Cir Unit 288, Manorville, NY 11949
    288 Ranch Cir Unit 288, Manorville, NY 11949
    288 Ranch Cir Unit 288, Manorville, NY 11949
    /17

    $412,250

    • 2 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,440 Sq Ft

    288 Ranch Cir Unit 288, Manorville, NY 11949

    Come and See this Newly Refreshed Townhouse with 5 rooms 2 beds and 2 bath located in Silver Ponds Gated Community. Large Patio space and 1 car garage. Close to shopping, transportation and major roadways.

    Agent Photo

    Mike Carroll

    RE/MAX Best

    (631) 284-8930

    288 Ranch Cir Unit 288, Manorville, NY 11949
  • 23 Fort Pond Rd, Montauk, NY 11954
    23 Fort Pond Rd, Montauk, NY 11954
    23 Fort Pond Rd, Montauk, NY 11954
    /23

    $1,350,000

    • 2 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 893 Sq Ft

    23 Fort Pond Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

    Just listed , renovated and Large two bedroom, two bath condominium situated on Fort Pond Bay with the most beautiful sunsets. This gated thirty-acre community offers many amenities which include a 32 x 70 heated gunite pool, Jacuzzi, sauna and 5 tennis courts. Enjoy relaxing on the bay beach with a 1,075 ft. fishing pier with gazebo. Grab a bite at Navy Beach Restaurant on adjacent beach or

    Agent Photo

    William Wolff

    Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    (631) 614-4958

    23 Fort Pond Rd, Montauk, NY 11954
  • 79 Meadow Ct, Manorville, NY 11949
    79 Meadow Ct, Manorville, NY 11949
    79 Meadow Ct, Manorville, NY 11949
    /25

    $635,000

    • 5 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,118 Sq Ft

    79 Meadow Ct, Manorville, NY 11949

    Fantastic home in sought after location! This home has Fresh Interior Paint, Partial flooring replacement in some areas. Discover a bright interior tied together with a neutral color palette. Step into the kitchen, complete with an eye catching stylish backsplash. You won’t want to leave the serene primary suite, the perfect space to relax. The primary bathroom features plenty of under sink

    Verria Hairston Opendoor Brokerage LLC

    79 Meadow Ct, Manorville, NY 11949
  • 625 Edwards St Unit A, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
    625 Edwards St Unit A, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
    625 Edwards St Unit A, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
    /14

    $385,000

    • 3 Beds
    • 1.5 Baths
    • 1,232 Sq Ft

    625 Edwards St Unit A, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

    Come and see this 3 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom 2-Story, semi-detached dwelling with full basement, nice outdoor yard space, and exceptional potential. Don’t miss this opportunity!

    Todd Yovino Island Advantage Realty LLC

    625 Edwards St Unit A, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
  • 112 Fairway Dr, Wading River, NY 11792
    112 Fairway Dr, Wading River, NY 11792
    112 Fairway Dr, Wading River, NY 11792
    /26

    $779,900

    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,642 Sq Ft

    112 Fairway Dr, Wading River, NY 11792

    The home of your dreams is waiting for you! Entry leads to a spacious den to relax in, eat-in kitchen to prepare all your meals, living room with a cozy fireplace, 3 bedrooms including a primary w/ full bath. Beautiful backyard to relax and enjoy all those summer nights! Don't miss your chance to own this home and make it your own! New Roof and AC!

    David Guzzetta American Way Real Estate Inc

    112 Fairway Dr, Wading River, NY 11792
  • 96 Biltmore Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
    96 Biltmore Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
    96 Biltmore Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
    /15

    $434,900

    • 3 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,148 Sq Ft

    96 Biltmore Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951

    Move right into this 3-bedroom, Ranch style home, with updated kitchen, granite counter and stainless-steel appliances, updated bathroom, updated flooring, new carpeting, fresh paint, etc. Close to local shopping, transportation, and ocean beaches. Don’t miss out on this opportunity!

    Todd Yovino Island Advantage Realty LLC

    96 Biltmore Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
  • 299 S River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933
    299 S River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933
    299 S River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933
    /18

    $519,900

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 804 Sq Ft

    299 S River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933

    Peconic Lake, Waterfront, Ranch style home, with full basement, updated kitchen w/ quartz counter and stainless-steel appliances, updated bathroom, updated/refurbished flooring, new carpeting, fresh paint, etc. Mid-block location. Close to local shopping and amenities. Don’t miss out on this opportunity!

    Todd Yovino Island Advantage Realty LLC

    299 S River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933
  • Unlisted Address
    Unlisted Address
    Unlisted Address
    /25

    $239,900

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 753 Sq Ft

    Unlisted Address

    JUST LISTED –Experience the perfect blend of style and function in this lightly lived-in, quality-built home just one year young in Glenwood Village.Welcome to luxury living in Riverhead, NY—the gateway to the North and South Forks! This new 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home is a rare find, offering modern elegance, low utilities, low taxes, and maintenance-free convenience.A Private Retreat for

    Joanne Gigantiello Kane

    Unlisted Address
  • 2468 River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933
    2468 River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933
    2468 River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933
    /20

    $525,000

    • 2 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,378 Sq Ft

    2468 River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933

    Opportunity Knocks! Gem Waiting to be Polished in Calverton. Great for Investors / Anyone Willing to get Creative! Make Your Move Today!

    Michael Kenduck Coldwell Banker American Homes

    2468 River Rd, Calverton, NY 11933
  • 62 Orchid Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
    62 Orchid Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
    62 Orchid Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
    /21

    $279,900

    • 3 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,222 Sq Ft

    62 Orchid Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951

    3 Bedroom, 1 bathroom, Expanded Ranch style home with living room, dining area, large eat-in-kitchen. Mid-block location. Close to local shopping, transportation and ocean beaches. Don't miss this opportunity!

    Todd Yovino Island Advantage Realty LLC

    62 Orchid Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
  • 5 Bayberry Ln, Remsenburg, NY 11960
    5 Bayberry Ln, Remsenburg, NY 11960
    5 Bayberry Ln, Remsenburg, NY 11960
    /8

    $2,600,000

    • Land
    • 1.00 Acre
    • $2,600,000 per Acre

    5 Bayberry Ln, Remsenburg, NY 11960

    Open Bayfront. Last of Its Kind!!! Bayview's & Sunset views Don't Get Any Better. Traditional Saltbox Home with 4 Bedrooms & 3 Baths. Located On A Quiet Cul De Sac. There is a Large Open Living Room With Fireplace, Eat-In Kitchen and a Bayside Heated Gunite Pool nestled in a Large Sprawling Lawn. This Property Is Ideal For An Expansive Renovation or Build your Bayfront Dream Home.

    Ron Scala Scala Custom Properties LTD

    5 Bayberry Ln, Remsenburg, NY 11960
New York Suffolk County Shelter Island

Foreclosure Homes for Sale in Shelter Island, NY

Home Trends in Shelter Island, NY

On average, homes in Shelter Island, NY sell after 261 days on the market compared to the national average of 70 days. The median sale price for homes in Shelter Island, NY over the last 12 months is $2,475,000, up 90% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.

Housing Trends

Median Sale Price
$2,475,000
Median Single Family Sale Price
$2,475,000
Average Price Per Sq Ft
$1,600
Number of Homes for Sale
6
Last 12 months Home Sales
9
Months of Supply
8.00
Median List Price
$2,750,000
Median Change From 1st List Price
17%
Median Home Sale Price YoY Change
90%
How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage

Copyright © 2025 CoStar Group