Recently Sold Butternuts, NY Homes

/46
$159,900 Sold Mar 27, 2025

977 New York 51, Gilbertsville, NY 13776
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,296 Sq Ft
- Built 1936
Last Sold Summary
- 11% Below List Price
- $123/SF
- 155 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $165,222

Last Listing Agent Christy Dahms Charlotteville Realty

977 New York 51, Gilbertsville, NY 13776
/50
$200,000 Sold Feb 24, 2025

1136 County Road 8, Morris, NY 13808
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,848 Sq Ft
- Built 1981
Last Sold Summary
- 7% Below List Price
- $108/SF
- 198 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Steven Rose Listing by Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties

1136 County Road 8, Morris, NY 13808
/41
$365,000 Sold May 29, 2025

227 Smith and Georgia Rd, Otego, NY 13825
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,128 Sq Ft
- Built 1900
Last Sold Summary
- $172/SF
- 2 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $367,345

Last Listing Agent Kathy Hartman Listing by Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

227 Smith and Georgia Rd, Otego, NY 13825
/41
$222,900 Sold Mar 21, 2025

666 Wilbur Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,680 Sq Ft
- Built 2016
Last Sold Summary
- 1% Below List Price
- $133/SF
- 25 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Chris Palmer Listing by United Country Palmer Real Estate, Inc

666 Wilbur Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
/39
$275,000 Sold Jul 10, 2025

264 Lulu Coon Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,352 Sq Ft
- Built 1993
Last Sold Summary
- $203/SF
- 89 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $282,670

Last Listing Agent Stacey Camilleri Listing by Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

264 Lulu Coon Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
/38
$156,000 Sold Oct 31, 2025

1050 Copes Corners Rd, South New Berlin, NY 13843
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 988 Sq Ft
- Built 1999
Last Sold Summary
- 2% Below List Price
- $158/SF
- 59 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $159,170

Last Listing Agent Bonnie Monzeglio Listing by Benson Agency Real Estate LLC

1050 Copes Corners Rd, South New Berlin, NY 13843
/37
$280,000 Sold Oct 07, 2025

553 Lilley Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 1,404 Sq Ft
- Built 2006
Last Sold Summary
- 4% Above List Price
- $199/SF
- 109 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $278,007

Last Listing Agent Jared Miller Listing by Howard Hanna Cny Inc

553 Lilley Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
/24
$30,000 Sold Aug 21, 2025

Lot 15 Nelson Rd, South New Berlin, NY 13843
- Land
- 8.35 Acres
- $3,593 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 25% Below List Price
- 42 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Richard Santos Listing by Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

Lot 15 Nelson Rd, South New Berlin, NY 13843
/50
$400,000 Sold Jan 22, 2026

513 Halbert Hill Rd, Butternuts, NY 13843
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,156 Sq Ft
- Built 1988
Last Sold Summary
- 5% Below List Price
- $346/SF
- 176 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Jennifer Noble Listing by Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties

513 Halbert Hill Rd, Butternuts, NY 13843
/36
$70,000 Sold Apr 11, 2025

826 River Rd, Gilbertsville, NY 13776
- Land
- 23.56 Acres
- $2,971 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 18% Below List Price
- 24 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Pauline Trottier Listing by Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties

826 River Rd, Gilbertsville, NY 13776
/34
$89,000 Sold Jul 21, 2025

1059 County Highway 4, Butternuts, NY 13849
- Land
- 9.13 Acres
- $9,748 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 19 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $89,128

Last Listing Agent Kate Bolton Listing by Howard Hanna

1059 County Highway 4, Butternuts, NY 13849
/31
$205,000 Sold Sep 09, 2025

368 Wilbur Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,050 Sq Ft
- Built 1994
Last Sold Summary
- 5% Below List Price
- $195/SF
- 14 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Heather Madsen Listing by Howard Hanna

368 Wilbur Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
/26
$164,000 Sold Oct 21, 2025

476 Musson Erwin Rd, South New Berlin, NY 13843
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,080 Sq Ft
- Built 1985
Last Sold Summary
- 9% Below List Price
- $152/SF
- 160 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $156,741

Last Listing Agent Maureen Rutherford Listing by RPI Realty

476 Musson Erwin Rd, South New Berlin, NY 13843
/7
$135,000 Sold Apr 07, 2025

2292 County Highway 18, South New Berlin, NY 13843
- Land
- 50.15 Acres
- $2,692 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 10% Below List Price
- 57 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $138,178

Last Listing Agent James Omahen Listing by Howard Hanna

2292 County Highway 18, South New Berlin, NY 13843
/41
$189,000 Sold May 09, 2025

181 Wilbur Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,248 Sq Ft
- Built 1991
Last Sold Summary
- $151/SF
- 9 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $215,505

Last Listing Agent Stacey Camilleri Listing by Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

181 Wilbur Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
/41
$350,000 Sold Sep 17, 2025

532 Wilbur Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,049 Sq Ft
- Built 1989
Last Sold Summary
- $171/SF
- 82 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $345,060

Last Listing Agent Susan Muther Keller Williams Upstate NY

532 Wilbur Hill Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
/50
$150,000 Sold Jun 02, 2025

5 Elm St, Gilbertsville, NY 13776
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,190 Sq Ft
- Built 1900
Last Sold Summary
- $68/SF
- 49 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $172,875

Last Listing Agent Tim Mullinnex Listing by Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

5 Elm St, Gilbertsville, NY 13776
/3
$52,500 Sold Dec 23, 2025

143 Cross Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 812 Sq Ft
- Built 1970
Last Sold Summary
- 12% Below List Price
- $65/SF
- 11 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Rich Rudolph Listing by Country Squire Realty

143 Cross Rd, Unadilla, NY 13849
/15
$17,900 Sold Dec 26, 2025

0 Town Line Rd, Butternuts, NY 13849
- Land
- 5.09 Acres
- $3,517 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 22% Below List Price
- 457 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Suzanne Darling Listing by EXIT Realty Homeward Bound

0 Town Line Rd, Butternuts, NY 13849
/13
$45,000 Sold Sep 26, 2025

0 Wilbur Hill Rd, Butternuts, NY 13849
- Land
- 20.76 Acres
- $2,168 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 8% Below List Price
- 7 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Anthony Heath Listing by Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

0 Wilbur Hill Rd, Butternuts, NY 13849
/50
$207,500 Sold Sep 18, 2025

44 Bloom St, Gilbertsville, NY 13776
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,746 Sq Ft
- Built 1900
Last Sold Summary
- 10% Above List Price
- $119/SF
- 6 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $200,560

Last Listing Agent Suzanne Darling Listing by EXIT Realty Homeward Bound

44 Bloom St, Gilbertsville, NY 13776
/7
$30,000 Sold Jul 03, 2025

105 Johnson Ln, Guilford, NY 13780
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 744 Sq Ft
- Built 1974
Last Sold Summary
- 7% Above List Price
- $40/SF
- 45 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Olivia O'Donnell Listing by Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

105 Johnson Ln, Guilford, NY 13780
/44
$159,500 Sold Nov 21, 2025

113 State Highway 51, Mount Upton, NY 13809
- 4 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,768 Sq Ft
- Built 1900
Last Sold Summary
- 6% Below List Price
- $90/SF
- 21 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Hillary Giuda-Philpott Listing by Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties

113 State Highway 51, Mount Upton, NY 13809
/50
$414,500 Sold Aug 04, 2025

779 Taylor Rd, Otego, NY 13825
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,600 Sq Ft
- Built 1975
Last Sold Summary
- 8% Below List Price
- $159/SF
- 229 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $411,691

Last Listing Agent Shelly Nichols Listing by Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties

779 Taylor Rd, Otego, NY 13825
/31
$153,000 Sold Jun 05, 2025

1828 State Highway 8, Mount Upton, NY 13809
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,600 Sq Ft
- Built 1970
Last Sold Summary
- 6% Above List Price
- $96/SF
- 33 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Leah Long Listing by Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties

1828 State Highway 8, Mount Upton, NY 13809

New York Otsego County Butternuts

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average home price in Butternuts, NY?

Homes for sale in Butternuts, NY have an average home price of $280,666.

What is the average time to sell a house in Butternuts, NY?

The houses for sale in Butternuts, NY spend an average of 97 days on the market.

What is the number of active homes for sale in Butternuts, NY?

There is 1 active home for sale in Butternuts, NY.

How many homes have sold over the last 12 months in Butternuts, NY?

2 homes have sold in Butternuts, NY over the last 12 months.

Home Trends in Butternuts, NY

On average, homes in Butternuts, NY sell after 97 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Butternuts, NY over the last 12 months is $244,500, down 24% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.

Housing Trends

Median Sale Price

$244,500

Median Single Family Sale Price

$334,000

Average Price Per Sq Ft

$239

Number of Homes for Sale

Last 12 months Home Sales

Months of Supply

6.00

Median List Price

$334,000

Median Change From 1st List Price

Median Home Sale Price YoY Change

-24%

How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home

Butternuts Types of Homes for Sale

More About Living in Butternuts

Homes in Nearby Cities

Homes in Nearby Counties

Homes in Nearby Zip Codes

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage