$1,709,397Average Value$761Average Price per Sq Ft10Homes For Sale
Fair Haven is a classic neighborhood surrounded by amenities
Fair Haven is a borough in Monmouth County dedicated to maintaining a community where kids ride their bikes to school, and neighbors catch up at the many social events throughout the year. Bradley Moore is a broker associate with O'Brien Realty who knows the area intimately. “You’ve got a really nice, balanced lifestyle that’s family-focused,” Moore says. “It’s this small town where everyone is looking out for each other. It’s such a great place for kids. ... They go outside and find their friends. Two of my son’s best friends are still like a block away. Sometimes people are like, ‘Why is it so expensive?’, and I say, ‘The dirt’s magic.’ You’ve got great schools, great commuting locations, all these different things that make so much sense for so many people.” The Navesink River flows along the neighborhood’s northern border, and beaches are a short drive away, so residents don’t have to go far to find a spot to relax. Anyone who wants to find their community in Monmouth County moves to Fair Haven for schools, accessibility and a friendly atmosphere.
Newer builds and renovated properties that can sell in the millions
The neighborhood has Colonial Revivals, custom New Traditionals and Cape Cods on sidewalk-lined streets. The front yards are short, while the back yards occasionally feature an in-ground pool or room for one. Newer-built homes are usually the most expensive options in this area, ranging from about $1 million to nearly $3 million. Older properties can sell for about $780,000 to $1 million. A few homes have sold for around $560,000 to $730,000, though developers purchased and completely renovated them or tore them down to make room for a new build. Some homes have been standing since the early 1900s, and residents have maintained the exterior designs while upgrading the interiors. Properties directly along the Navesink River may be in a flood zone. Homeowners should check local maps to see if they need flood insurance.
Colonial Revival homes line Fair Haven’s quiet residential streets.
New Traditionals provide serene living near local parks.
1/2
Riding bikes to class in Fair Haven schools
The Fair Haven School District gets a B-plus from Niche. “In the mornings, one of the things that surprises a lot of people is that we close 3rd Street,” Moore says. “They don’t have bus services for the elementary and middle schools. Kids are traveling on their bikes. It blows people’s minds to see hundreds and hundreds of bikes parked in front of every school.” The A-rated Viola L. Sickles School offers prekindergarten through third-grade classes. Knollwood School gets an A-minus and teaches up to eighth grade. Fair Haven is zoned for the A-plus-rated Rumson-Fair Haven Regional High School.
Viola L. Sickles School serves Fair Haven students from pre-K to grade 3.
Red Bank Regional High School earns an A rating from Niche.
1/2
Exploring the Navesink River, beaches and Fair Haven Field
The neighborhood is surrounded by outdoor destinations minutes from home. Some homes have private docks on the Navesink River, but anyone can use the Fair Haven Municipal Ramp to access the water to fish or pull in crabs. “You’ve got the Shrewsbury River Yacht club; you have a marina,” Moore says. “You’ve got the River Rat Sailing Club. So, you’ve got water options for people who like boating, sailing or kayaking. ... Once people move here, they join a beach club, like in Sea Bright, Monmouth Beach or Long Branch.” Fair Haven Fields has paved tennis courts and athletic fields on one side and the 40-acre Natural Area on the other, where people can follow trails through the heavily wooded space.
Fair Haven’s municipal ramp gives easy access to the Navesink River.
Weekend soccer games are common at Fair Haven Fields.
1/2
Ordering at favorite spots like Tavolo Pronto
Some people walk to busy neighborhood restaurants on River Road, like Fair Haven Diner and Nicholas Creamery. “I really love Tavolo Pronto,” Moore says. “That’s a hidden gem. It’s ... an Italian deli, and sometimes they bring out the linen at night for formal dining.” Moore also points out the community is so connected that families even have running tabs at places like delis and pizzerias. Parents might even call in a to-go order to be delivered to one of the schools so their kids can have a nice lunch. Residents prefer local shops like Fair Haven Hardware Inc. for occasional supplies and ACME Markets for groceries.
Nicholas Creamery serves handcrafted ice cream on River Road.
Tavolo Pronto offers Italian favorites in the heart of Fair Haven.
1/2
Fair Haven always has a celebration planned
Fair Haven has a full calendar of annual events, from a Halloween-themed egg hunt to the bustling Firemen’s Fair. “The town has great camaraderie,” Moore says. “In June, we have Fair Haven Day. It’s a party where the town gets together. They get a tent, caterers and bands, and then they have a big fireworks show. ... Most New Jersey towns have a Firemen’s Festival, but Fair Haven’s ... is special. People from all over come around for it."
Short trips to nearby destinations and direct routes to NYC
Residents don’t have to worry about busy highways or interstates since two-lane roads cut through the area and connect to nearby destinations. “My kids, when they were in high school and got their licenses, never drove on a parkway, because everything is 15 minutes away,” Moore says. “They never had to drive over 35 miles an hour.” HMH Riverview Medical Center has an emergency room and primary care services a mile away.
“A lot of people here work in the city,” Moore says. “It’s a great position to hop on the train in Red Bank. Depending on where you're going, you may want the bus service. A ton of people take the Seastreak Ferry out of Highlands and Atlantic Highlands. It’s 45 to 50 minutes to get to Wall Street. It’s the most relaxing way to commute.” The Newark Liberty International and Trenton-Mercer Airports are a little over an hour away by car. Closer to home, people can take a short drive to places of worship like Church of the Nativity or the Rumson Jewish Center at Congregation B’nai Israel.
Written By
Rylee Doyle
Video By
Kyo Nguyen
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Pamela Girard,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Fair Haven, NJ sell after 15 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Fair Haven, NJ over the last 12 months is $1,385,000, down 3% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Great opportunity to secure a fully renovated home w/brand-new addition in desirable Fair Haven! This 4 bedroom, 3 full bathroom colonial offers 2,130 sf of luxury living with custom millwork, 10 ft ceilings, oak floors, solid doors, & recessed lighting. The stunning chef's kitchen features white slim shaker cabinetry, waterfall island, quartz counters, & GE Cafe appliances. Enjoy a 1st-floor
Justin NathansonKeller Williams Realty Central Monmouth
THIS IS A COMING SOON LISTING AND SHOWINGS BEGIN ON 12/4/25Classic Fair Haven Cape Cod - Turn-Key, Coastal-Lifestyle Living, & Priced to Sell Fast!Welcome to 40 Buena Vista Avenue, an impeccably maintained and thoughtfully updated 4-bedroom, 2-full-bath Cape Cod tucked along one of Fair Haven's most charming, tree-lined streets. Brand new roof, AC air handler and condenser, gas-fired hot
Great opportunity to secure a fully renovated home w/brand-new addition in desirable Fair Haven! This 4 bedroom, 3 full bathroom colonial offers 2,130 sf of luxury living with custom millwork, 10 ft ceilings, oak floors, solid doors, & recessed lighting. The stunning chef's kitchen features white slim shaker cabinetry, waterfall island, quartz counters, & GE Cafe appliances. Enjoy a 1st-floor
Justin NathansonKeller Williams Realty Central Monmouth
Welcome to Fair Haven! 'Move right in', or go ahead and 'make it your own' with this bright 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath, open floor plan home that includes a truly spacious lot with unlimited potential! This beautiful location on a quiet street is just two houses away from Fair Haven's famous '3rd Street' where school students walk and ride their bikes to and from Fair Haven's top-rated elementary and
Location. Lifestyle. Livability.Welcome to 349 River Road, where classic Colonial architecture meets the ease of modern living. A bright two-story foyer sets the tone, drawing you into warm, defined spaces that feel both open and welcoming. Multiple living spaces, including an inviting living room, a spacious family room with a sunken fireplace lounge, and a bright sunroom overlooking the
Fantastic rental in River Oaks!Fully updated in 2019, this home is warm and welcoming with bluestone covered front porch.It offers modern, open-concept living with a bright kitchen, dining, and great/family room featuring beamed ceilings + custom built-ins.The chef's kitchen incl. custom cabinetry, double pantries, quartz counters, butcher-block island, SS appliances.Flexible living space
Christine MarcoullierHeritage House Sotheby's International Realty
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
