$264,490Average Value$159Average Price per Sq Ft26Homes For Sale
A charming small town with regional shopping destinations
Originally named Pine Grove, the Grove City neighborhood is a small town community in West Pennsylvania best known for its premium outlet mall and downtown dining scene. Tucked between the local high school and small businesses on Main Street, Grove City Memorial Park has several annual events showcasing the neighborhood’s foodie culture and family-friendly atmosphere. Located just south of the O.D. Anderson Interchange, this charming small town, offers easy access to both Pittsburgh and Downtown Youngstown.
Grove City is a small town with a big personality.
Stop by Beans on Broadway, in Grove City for a Milky Way Latte.
1/2
Grove City Premium Outlets and local restaurants on Broad Street
At the Grove City Premium Outlets, locals can enjoy tax-free shopping and find discounts at over 100 brand-name stores. Down the road, Wendell August Forge Flagship Store is a historical landmark and a unique shopping experience selling hand-crafted aluminum gifts and other novelty products. After a long day of retail therapy, shoppers can grab a bite to eat at the nearby Blackout Burger Bar or sip on a draft beer at TimberCreek Tap & Table. Real estate agent at Coldwell Banker Realty with 15 years of experience selling homes in northwest Pennsylvania, Connie Rusek says, “Lots of local businesses and all kinds of stores and restaurants are on Broad Street.” Grove City College students head down this bustling street to study in cozy coffee shops and grab a late-night slice from Coffaros’ Pizza. On West Main Street, County Market is a locally-owned supermarket where residents can find farm-fresh groceries, pantry staples and other basics. This busy road is also home to the local Walmart Supercenter, ALDI and several fast-food chains
Broad Street Grille, in Grove City, has a cozy atmosphere and expansive menu.
You may lose track of time on Broad Street, in Grove City.
1/2
Historic American Foursquares and ranch-style homes
“Grove City has a nice variety of old historic homes around Olde Towne,” says Rusek. Dutch Colonial Revivals and Traditional American Foursquares are packed tightly in residential boroughs off Main Street and cost between $100,000 and $200,000. Most of these historic homes were built at the turn of the 20th century, and feature paved driveways leading to detached two-car garages. Along the narrow streets, old concrete sidewalks connect residents to the businesses on Main Street and provide students with a safe walkway to school. Further away from the busy downtown district, ranch-style homes built during the 1970s are settled on multi-acre lots and cost between $300,000 to $500,000. Many of these spacious properties are surrounded by tall Pennsylvania pines, offering a peaceful and private lifestyle.
Cape Cod, Bungalow, and American Four Square homes share the streets of Grove City.
Neatly decorated mid-century homes, line the streets of Grove City.
1/2
Annual events celebrate Grove City year-round
For over 20 years, the Annual Strawberry Days Festival marks the official start of summer in Grove City. Throughout the first weekend in June, festivalgoers enjoy musical entertainment, local art and food vendors, and a variety of tasty strawberry treats. In mid-September, Grove City Memorial Park is home to the annual Foodie Fest. At this one-day event, residents can sample an array of delicious foods from different restaurants in the area. After Thanksgiving, Grove City Memorial Park transforms into a winter wonderland where families can tour Christmas light displays every night in December.
Family-friendly parks and movie nights at Guthrie Theatre
At the Grove City Country Club, members can spend sunny Saturdays playing golf on the 18-hole lakeside golf course. Families can head to Grove City Memorial Park to play on the spacious playground, feed ducks in the pond or have a peaceful picnic under the pavilions. During the summer, the park’s public swimming pool is a popular place for neighbors to cool off. On Broad Street, the Guthrie Theater was originally built in 1927 and is one of the only single-screen movie theaters still in existence. This historic theater has recently been completely renovated into a full-service entertainment venue where residents can still watch new movie screenings, live theater productions, music performances and comedy shows.
Grove City Country Club is nestled in the rolling hills of Grove City.
Enjoy a sunny afternoon at Memorial Park's playground, in Grove City.
Parking is easy to find and marked by public art, on Broad Street in Grove City.
1/3
Central Interstates connect to Pittsburgh and Youngstown
Centrally located interstates provide commuters with easy access to nearby major cities. Residents can head south on Interstate 79 and arrive in Downtown Pittsburgh in about an hour. The Youngstown-Warren Regional Airport is only 45 minutes away via Interstate 80 and offers flights across the country. Grove City Medical Center is a convenient hospital on North Broad Street with a Level IV Trauma Center and primary care services.
Innovative learning at Grove City Area schools
Grove City students can attend highly rated Grove City Area schools. Kindergarteners can start learning to read at Hillview Elementary School, receiving an overall B on Niche. After fifth grade, students can go to the B-plus-rated Grove City Middle School. This local school recently added a unique and popular Inventionland Innovation course where students work in small groups to create new solutions to real-world problems. In ninth grade, teens can easily transition to Grove City Area High School, rated an overall B on Niche. Grove City College is a private Christian liberal arts school in the neighborhood recently ranked #3 in Best Value Schools by the US News and World Report.
Grove City Area High School is ranked 136th in PA, according to US News and World Report.
Grove City Middle School is known for its STEM program.
A cheerful sculpture welcomes students to Hillview Elementary School, in Grove City.
1/3
Written By
Anna Anderson
Photography Contributed By
Tiffany Karla
Video By
Charles Kennedy
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Joan Traggiai,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Grove City, PA sell after 63 days on the market compared to the national average of 52 days. The median sale price for homes in Grove City, PA over the last 12 months is $230,000, up 6% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
OPEN HOUSE SAT. 10/18/25 11AM- 1PM. One level living at its finest! Tucked away in the Grove City Boro, 635 Craig features 2 oversized bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and a finished bonus room in the lower level that could be utilized as a 3rd bedroom, office, playroom, etc. The main floor includes a refreshed kitchen with cherry cabinets and stainless steel appliances, beautifully refinished hardwood
Welcome to this charming corner lot home featuring 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, fenced in yard, and a 1 car garage with additional off-street parking. 409 Summit Street is within walking distance of Grove City College and is conveniently located closely to downtown. The bonus room off the rear of the home would make an ideal studio, gym, or office! High ceilings on the main floor with tons of built ins
This charming ranch style home is located in one of Grove City's finest locations. Whether you are looking for your first home or downsizing; this home is a perfect choice! Kitchen featuring Corian countertops and separate dining area. Spacious living room with an extra room that can be used as a sunroom or den. Covered back patio overlooking the large backyard. Oversized heated 2 car detached
Cedar Contemporary home located on cul-de-sac in one of Grove City's finest neighborhoods. Enter this home into the entryway that leads into a formal living room, dining room with an abundance of natural light and cozy family room. Kitchen features plenty of counter space and storage. Natural wood elements are just some of the unique features of this home. Large primary bedroom with large walk-in
Located at the end of a quiet street only 1 mile from downtown Grove City, Newberry Apartments is a cozy, welcoming community. Pet-friendly apartments offer spacious living units with built-in bookcases, linen and hall closets, attic storage, and laundry room with washer and dryer connections. Every apartment home is single floor with no neighbors above or below you. Your home has an outdoor
This 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home sits on 3 beautiful, level acres. It offers a large, open living room with a wood burner for those chilly evenings. The kitchen offers hand-made wood counter tops. The 30'x40' detached garage offers so much space for your vehicles, storage and has a work bench! The location, in a park-like setting, is close to Grove City and Slippery Rock. Enjoy one-level
Come home to convenient living at Colony and Penn Grove. Enjoy life on beautiful tree-lined streets, with easy access to transportation, shopping, and entertainment. Choose from a variety of spacious apartments, each with ample closet space and modern amenities. Some of our community amenities include a playground and a gazebo with a picnic and grill area. Colony and Penn Grove is right where you
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
