$201,054Average Value$127Average Price per Sq Ft2Homes For Sale
Hannibal offers quiet living between Lake Ontario and Fulton
The quiet town of Hannibal includes a smaller village of the same name as well as villages like North Hannibal, South Hannibal, Hannibal Center and Fairdale. The town's location among the creeks and farmland of Oswego County helps separate it from Lake Ontario tourism and bigger cities like Oswego and Fulton. The smaller communities are spread out and separated by a few miles of fields and forests. “We like the country feel of it,” says resident Kim Malone, the town supervisor. “We don’t want our neighbors too close. I don’t want to hear them snoring at night.” While Hannibal has a peaceful, isolated feel, it's still close to amenities, restaurants and grocery stores. The area also receives a Cap Index Crime Score of 2 out of 10, which is lower than the national average of 4.
Hannibal is not far from Lake Neatahwanta and the Oswego River.
The Hannibal Town Hall and the iconic water tower is one of the first things residents will see when they enter into the village from the South.
1/2
Historic and midcentury homes on multiacre properties and farms
Nationals, manufactured homes and ranch-style homes sit off Hannibal's narrow country roads. There’s also the occasional log cabin. Streetlights and telephone wires hang over the streets, and views from the road are either thick lines of trees or open fields. Like many other Oswego County towns, homebuyers can find more land in Hannibal than in cities like Syracuse, Oswego and Fulton. “My husband and I have 20 acres,” Malone says, “but you can go from 1 acre to 50.” With the additional space, homeowners can keep horses or use the space for farming. Manufactured homes typically cost between $50,000 and $80,000, while ranch-style homes, Nationals and cabins range from $100,000 to $380,000.
Many homes in Hannibal have been converted to businesses on the lower level, though the upper floors are still lived in.
Most homes in Hannibal have driveways and garages.
1/2
Hannibal's small community parks and nearby Lake Ontario
Hannibal Veterans Park is a small grassy area with a war memorial for local armed forces. The park overlooks Ninemile Creek, where locals stop to fish. The Hannibal Community Center doubles as the local public library and a senior center. Outside the community, Stone Creek Golf Club is an 18-hole course open to the public. Hannibal is also about 10 minutes from Fair Haven and Lake Ontario. Fair Haven Beach State Park includes a stretch of sand along the lake. On shore, there’s also hiking and biking. Hannibal and Oswego County’s proximity to Lake Ontario means the area has intense winters and heavy snowfall, but locals make the most of it with snowmobiling and ice fishing.
Hannibal is also about 10 minutes from Lake Ontario, which is a great spot to sit and take in the views.
Hannibal is also about 10 minutes from Lake Ontario, which is a great spot to sit and take in the views.
1/2
Hannibal High School students can earn early college credit
Fairley Elementary School and Kenney Middle School both receive a C-minus grade from Niche. Hannibal High School receives a C-plus. Students can enroll in Early College High School, where they can simultaneously earn high school and college credits. Hannibal High’s program specifically focuses on health sciences. Malone says sports are a big deal at local schools and a great way for newcomers to meet their neighbors.
Fairley School in Hannibal serves the town of Hannibal and surrounding towns such as Fulton.
Kenney Middle School in Hannibal is not far from the iconic Hannibal water tower.
1/2
Local American restaurants and groceries available in Hannibal
The Village Tavern Hannibal offers a mix of American and Italian cuisines, with entrees like pasta, steak and seafood. Coffee Bean Bistro’s menu spans from pancakes and omelets at breakfast to sandwiches and soups for lunch. It also updates the daily specials on Facebook. Hannibal has a Tops Friendly Market and a Dollar General for grocery and convenience trips. The Walmart Supercenter in Granby is about 7 miles away.
Hannibal residents looking for breakfast or lunch can stop in to the Coffee Bean Bistro for coffee or food, while getting excellent table-side service.
Walmart is another store available to Hannibal residents that also sells groceries.
1/2
New York Routes connect Hannibal with nearby cities
Hannibal is a car-dependent community, linked to bigger cities through a few state routes. New York Route goes east to west, toward Fulton, about 8 miles away. New York Route 104 heads north to Oswego, 11 miles away, where Oswego Hospital is also located. Syracuse is on the same route, about 35 miles from Hannibal. Syracuse Hancock International Airport is about 30 miles away.
From summer celebrations to winter holiday traditions in Hannibal
In mid-August, Hannibal Field Days celebrates the town with carnival rides and games, food vendors and a parade. The town builds up to Halloween with Demon Acres Haunted Hayrides on the weekends in October. Hayrides with jump scares and haunted houses sit along the 25-acre property. For the winter holidays, the grounds host Deck the Halls, a wagon ride through over 250,000 lights and displays. It goes for weekends in November and December, but Malone also says the town has an annual tree lighting where Santa makes an appearance.
Hannibal residents can come listen to the music as live bands perform at the Fulton Fall Festival.
After the switch flips, fireworks go off at the Fulton Tree Lighting Ceremony, a local event not far from Hannibal.
1/2
Written By
Caroline Ernst
Photography Contributed By
Greg Dunbar
Video By
Tyler Hall
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
James Burnham,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Hannibal, NY sell after 28 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Hannibal, NY over the last 12 months is $213,500, down 11% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Excited to introduce this STUNNING remodel, 1360 County Route 3! Situated on half acre & located just outside of Hannibal, this 3-bedroom has been completely transformed down to the studs! Everything has been done for you including the roof, windows, siding, plumbing, electrical & the list goes on! Enter through the LARGE living room with beautiful wooden planked walls! The kitchen features NEW
What a great piece of property on a no thru-traffic street, nearly 4.5 acres. There is a 150' driveway for access - perhaps a great spot to park a camper and get away. Additional parking spot not on driveway as well. Meandering stream courses through the property and a nice fire pit offers a great place to sit and relax. This recreational lot was recently financed through Compass Federal Credit
Excited to introduce this STUNNING remodel, 1360 County Route 3! Situated on half acre & located just outside of Hannibal, this 3-bedroom has been completely transformed down to the studs! Everything has been done for you including the roof, windows, siding, plumbing, electrical & the list goes on! Enter through the LARGE living room with beautiful wooden planked walls! The kitchen features NEW
Your private gateway to the countryside is ready! Discover the perfect blend of privacy and convenience with this versatile country property, situated on just under 2 sprawling acres of beautiful New York land. If you have been searching for a manageable, affordable, and high-quality escape from the daily grind, this offering is an absolute must-see. This property isn't just a piece of land; it
Discover the perfect blend of privacy and convenience with this country property situated on just under 2 acres. The land offers an excellent setting for recreational use or as the potential site for your future home.Conveniently located near Hannibal, less than 15 minutes to Oswego, and under an hour to Syracuse, this property provides easy access to nearby amenities while maintaining a
4 Bedroom, 1 bath home needs rehab and finishing work. No heat other than an old wood stove. Cash or Rehab loan only. Not FHA, USDA or VA eligible due to the condition. House is sold in AS IS condition.
Welcome to your private slice of paradise! Nestled on 10 sprawling acres, this charming ranch-style home offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and versatility. The main house boasts, cozy living spaces, and panoramic views of the surrounding countryside with attached garage for easy access! But that’s not all—this property includes a 2021 - 3 bedroom 2 bathroom mobile home ideal for
This spacious 10+/- acre parcel offers a blend of open land, wooded areas, and some wetland—perfect for outdoor enthusiasts or those looking to build their dream home. Located in Hannibal, it's just a short drive to both Oswego and Syracuse, giving you the peace of country living with easy access to neighboring areas.
THIS CLEAN AND IMMACULATE, FULLY RENOVATED SINGLE FAMILY HOME IN THE VILLAGE OF HANNIBAL FEATURES 4 BEDROOMS AND 2 FULL BATHS, ENTRY FOYER, FIRST FLOOR LAUNDRY HOOKUPS, A LARGE KITCHEN WITH ALL NEW APPLIANCES, NEW CABINETS AND COUNTERTOPS, NEW WINDOWS, NEW FLOORING, FRESH PAINT THROUGH OUT, AN OPEN LIVING ROOM AND PLENTY OF STORAGE. THERE IS A FIRST FLOOR PRIMARY SUITE WITH A FULL BATH, LARGE
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
