$381,290Average Value$190Average Price per Sq Ft15Homes For Sale
Close to downtown with an identity of its own
Though its namesake church closed its doors to parishioners in 2018, Holy Cross is still one of the most vibrant and community-oriented neighborhoods in Indianapolis. “We try to make it so people have opportunities to see each other and form community bonds,” says Holy Cross Neighborhood Association president Jen Higginbotham. Located just across Interstate 70 from downtown, this Near Eastside neighborhood combines the perks of that proximity with amenities of its own.
Holy Cross is a historic neighborhood that is full of personality.
Holy Cross residents enjoy one of the finest views of the skyline in all of Indianapolis.
1/2
Plenty of pizza and an array of antiques
Holy Cross is a pizza lover’s delight thanks to a pair of Indy’s top pizzerias: King Dough and Futuro. King Dough specializes in New York-style pies, while Futuro focuses on Detroit-style and Chicago tavern-style pizzas. La Parada, voted Indy’s top Mexican restuarant in 2021, is another neighborhood staple. Natural State Provisions, a Southern-style restaurant and bar with a roomy outdoor patio and dog park, is a top summer hot spot. Ash & Elm Cider Co. Offers a full food menu to match with its house-made ciders. And the neighborhood has its own version of Antiques Roadshow thanks to the 40,000-square foot Midland Arts & Antiques Market. “It’s just an eclectic mix of anything from furniture to dishware to posters of characters from the past. And lots of records,” Higginbotham says. “You can find anything and everything.”
Local businesses in Holy Cross feature beautifully designed artwork.
Holy Cross sits near lots of eclectic and fun places to spend a day shopping.
1/2
Homes date to the turn of the 20th Century
Most houses in Holy Cross are east of the neighborhood’s centerpiece, Highland Park. The western half of the neighborhood, where there is some flood risk between Pogue’s Run and I-70, is primarily commercial. Most of the neighborhood’s houses were built between the late 1890s-late 1910s. Newer custom-builds are also popping up and tend to fit in with the character of those bungalows and Craftsman-style houses. The price range for homes in Holy Cross is from $200,000-$750,000.
Holy Cross features a diverse blend of architectural styles in homes in the neighborhood.
Holy Cross residents pride themselves on friendship, camaraderie, and neighborly kindness.
1/2
Highland Park is Indy's perch
Highland Park is one of the highest points in Indianapolis and offers immaculate views of downtown. The 4-acre park has a picnic shelter, playground, and walking trails. The Sturm Avenue Esplanade is a block-long stretch of neutral ground that’s been transformed into a park area with a playground, gazebo and grills.
Highland Park serves as a gathering place in the Holy Cross neighborhood.
Holy Cross is one of the most pleasant neighborhoods in Indianapolis.
1/2
Events build sense of community
The Wine and Cheese Fest hosted by the Holy Cross Neighborhood Association is becoming a signature neighborhood event. There are educational sessions on pairing wines and cheeses, a grilled cheese cookoff, plus a large play area for kids. For years, Highland Park was considered the best place in the city to view fireworks on the Fourth of July, but the city moved the show a few blocks north from the Salesforce Tower in 2021. “It’s still a great place to be for the Fourth,” Higginbotham says. “People still show up because of the tradition.”
Holy Cross schools in a transition period
Holy Cross schools are in a transition period. Washington Irving School 14 joined the Indianapolis Public Schools Innovation Network in 2023. The K-8 school received a D-grade on Niche when it previously operated as a charter school. Holy Cross Central Catholic closed its doors at the end of the 2023 school year, with students transferred to St. Philip Neri School. Arsenal Tech, Indy’s largest high school on a 76-acre campus, is in neighboring Cottage Grove. Arsenal Tech has a C-rating on Niche. A-plus rated Herron High, a charter school open to Holy Cross residents, is two miles from the neighborhood.
Arsenal Technical High School is located in Indianapolis, Indiana.
Washington Irving Elementary School serves Indianapolis students up to 5th grade.
1/2
Convenient to many forms of transportation
Multiple bike lanes and a Pacers Bikeshare hub near King Dough make Holy Cross an ideal neighborhood for bicyclists. It’s also about a 20-to-30-minute walk to downtown Indianapolis. “It’s very easy to walk downtown,” Higginbotham says. And with I-70 forming the neighborhood’s western boundary, all of Indy is easily accessible by car. IndyGo bus routes 3 and 8 also go through Holy Cross.
Plenty of bus routes run through Holy Cross, making it easy to get around town.
Holy Cross has a bike-sharing program, offering residents with the opportunity to rent bicycles.
1/2
Busy streets can be heard
With I-70 to the west and busy Washington Street to the south, significant traffic noise is heard in parts of the neighborhood. Those issues are less pronounced in the neighborhood’s primarily residential eastern half.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Holy Cross neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Holy Cross Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Holy Cross, Indianapolis sell after 57 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Holy Cross, Indianapolis over the last 12 months is $402,500, up 9% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Located at 242 N Arsenal Ave, this historic Holy Cross residence is full of character and charm, waiting for its next owner to make interior updates and cosmetic repairs. Lovingly maintained this home offers endless potential for your personal updates and vision. The exterior has been thoughtfully restored within the past year, with fresh paint, extensive wood replacement, and fully restored
What a great opportunity to own a downtown home. Located east of the city center. This half duplex is 1.2 miles from Monument Circle and 1.1 miles from Mass Ave. This two bedroom one and a half bath home with a bonus room has been meticulously cared for by the current owner. The professional landscaping was put in to be both visually appealing and a low maintenance garden scape. The entire duplex
Nestled at 1205 Sturm AVE, INDIANAPOLIS, IN, this condominium presents an attractive property in great condition, featuring hardwood floors on the main floor. The living room is a welcoming space, defined by the inviting presence of a fireplace, suggesting cozy evenings and a natural gathering place. Imagine relaxing and unwinding in this comfortable and inviting atmosphere or head out to the
New Apartments That Balance Neighborhood Life and Downtown Living Gathyr Apartments is where modern design, historic charm, and convenient living come together. Located in the vibrant Holy Cross neighborhood of Indianapolis, Gathyr strikes a perfect balance between the energy of downtown life and the comfort of a connected community. Our beautifully crafted studio, one-, and two-bedroom
Revel in the charm and comfort of this delightful duplex located at 1543 E Ohio St, Indianapolis, IN 46201-3861. This spacious 1400 sq ft residence boasts three inviting bedrooms, perfect for creating your ideal living space. With one full bathroom, every morning routine and evening unwind is effortlessly accommodated. Step into a home that promises both functionality and warmth, offering an open
This apartment is located at 1337 E. Market St. in Indianapolis. Come for a visit to check out the current floor plan options. Freshly painted, newly renovated unit featuring an electrical fireplace, and much more to come! A coin laundry is available in the basement. The tenant only pays for the electricity. Gas, water, and sewer included!Please note- In addition to the monthly
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
