$569,429Average Value$244Average Price per Sq Ft6Homes For Sale
A lakefront community with a stellar school system
The city of Mahtomedi is known for its small-town charm and enviable location on White Bear Lake. And with its location 15 miles northeast of Saint Paul and 8 miles west of Stillwater, this small city is right in the middle of everything one might need. Surprisingly, its great lakeside location is just one of the top reasons people are attracted to the area. “It is within the Mahtomedi Public School District, which is one of the most sought-after in the state,” says Melissa Wiegele, a real estate agent for Coldwell Banker Realty who has sold homes in the area. “It’s definitely one of those areas people want to be in.” Also notable: Mahtomedi has a CAP Index crime risk score of 1 out of 10, compared to the national average of 4.
Lakeside homes along the peninsula in Mahtomedi.
Mahtomedi Middle School is a highly rated public middle school.
1/2
Rich recreation options
Outdoor lovers will feel right at home in the city of Mahtomedi, with its rich park and trail system that provide recreational opportunities to residents of all ages. Mahtomedi Beach is a summer staple with its sandy beach on scenic White Bear Lake. Residents can swim in the crystal-clear water when the weather is warm, and on nice days the small parking lots fill up fast. Neighbors love the relative quiet, calm and cleanliness compared to other beaches. The lake is great for all kinds of boating activities, from sailing to jet skiing, and the White Bear Yacht Club is a big deal in the area, says Wiegele. For folks looking for things to do on dry land, the Dellwood Country Club is popular with Mahtomedi residents, and there are several apple orchards surrounding the area for when the weather starts getting crisp. For hiking, Katherine Abbott Park rests on 76 acres and the varied physical features and terrain make it a unique, natural experience despite its urban location. More traditional parks are also scattered throughout the community, like Wildwood Park, with its playground, open green spaces, and ball fields.
Mahtomedi beach is a cozy spot for the locals.
Mahtomedi residents utilize the walking paths throughout town.
1/2
A top school district that routinely draws buyers
Schools are a draw for homebuyers with small children in Mahtomedi, who attend schools in the Mahtomedi Public School District. “They’ve been known to have a smaller class size and a quality public education there,” says Jay Mangine, a Realtor with Realty Group. Kids start their journey at Wildwood Elementary, which serves kindergarten through second graders and is rated B-minus by Niche, before moving on to O.H. Anderson Elementary, which serves third through fifth graders. The school is graded A-minus and named the second-best public elementary school in the county, according to Niche. Students then go on to Mahtomedi Middle and Mahtomedi High School, both also rated A-minus.
At Wildwood Elementary School, 10% of students get free reduced lunches.
Mahtomedi High School has numerous activity fields and share a campus with the middle school.
1/2
What to expect when house-hunting in Mahtomedi
The real estate market in Mahtomedi is very competitive, with an average price of $561,000, according to Wiegele. While it’s not unheard of to find small early-1900s homes for prices starting around $200,000, new construction is becoming the norm, with more opportunities for luxury homes than there are homes for first-time homebuyers. “It’s a bit of a higher-end community,” Wiegele says. Living lakefront on White Bear Lake is aspirational, with most properties selling before they even hit the market; prices for waterfront property represent the high end of the market, up to around $1.4 million.
New construction homes are available to own in Mahtomedi.
A Colonial style home resting on a hill in Mahtomedi.
1/2
Mahtomedi’s shopping and dining options
Mahtomedi’s shopping and dining scene is limited, but you can find a restaurant any time of the day. The Wild Bean is your quintessential neighborhood coffee house, with its homey décor inside and out and huge bay window. If you’re picky with your chai tea, you’re in luck because guests rave about it here. The Wildwood Tavern opens for lunch and promises scratch-made food prepared daily. The red brick building teases a rustic interior, with beamed ceilings and wooden tables. Residents can enjoy the shrimp and grits, a customer favorite, on the inviting patio decorated with string lights and green umbrellas. For an upscale dinner, Gordy’s Steakhouse is a restaurant and bar serving steak, seafood and pasta in an elegant space with dark wood-clad walls and low lighting, perfect for a date night. More restaurants can be found around the lake, and for more variety, Wiegele says many people go to nearby Stillwater, which is known for its food scene. For groceries and other necessities, the area has an ALDI and Festival Foods. There’s also the Mahtomedi Area Farmers’ Market, which brings produce growers, artists, bakers, crafters and community organizations together every Saturday throughout the summer at Veteran’s Memorial Park. Local vendors offer fresh produce, flowers and plants, honey, artisan breads, and handmade crafts and artwork.
Chilled coffee and scones are a local favorite at Mahtomedi's The Wild Bean.
Aldi's serves as one of Mahtomedi's local grocery stores.
1/2
Getting to and from Mahtomedi
Most folks in Mahtomedi get around by car, and Wiegele says its easy to get to Interstate 35E from Mahtomedi, which leads to St. Paul. Mahtomedi is within 25 miles from the Minneapolis–Saint Paul International Airport, named in 2022 as the 19th busiest airport in North America in terms of passengers served annually. The airport offers service to 136 nonstop domestic and 27 international markets.
Written By
Katelin Hill
Video By
Nina Violi
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Jennifer Giovinazzo,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Mahtomedi, MN sell after 32 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Mahtomedi, MN over the last 12 months is $500,000, down 57% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Adorable and cozy cottage just two blocks from White Bear Lake and Chautauqua Park, perfectly situated near the charming downtown Mahtomedi. Mahtomedi Schools. Inviting screened-in front porch. Main floor features beautiful hardwood floors and a charming living room with gas-burning stone fireplace, large windows offer lots of natural light. The main floor family room boasts a striking feature
Welcome home to this beautifully updated property in the highly sought-after Mahtomedi School District, offering the perfect blend of modern updates, thoughtful design, and a serene natural setting. Recently renovated, this home features an open-concept layout highlighted by hardwood floors, stainless steel appliances, and two stylishly updated bathrooms. Enjoy the convenience of three bedrooms
Welcome home to 800 Griffin Ave! A well maintained and move-in ready 4-level home in desirable Mahtomedi, known for its award winning school district and small town feel, while still offering easy access to the Twin Cities. This spacious home features 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, with a flexible lower level that offers the opportunity to add an additional bedroom and expanded family room space.
Welcome home to a unique opportunity in the heart of Mahtomedi. Award-Winning Hagstrom Builder is offering custom built villas, each secluded on nearly half an acre with private views. Experience main floor living at its best with the option of 2 bedrooms on the main floor, a finished lower level and 3 car garage. Within minutes of White Bear Lake and miles of bike trails.
Welcome to an extraordinary and versatile estate in the highly sought-after Mahtomedi community, known for its top-rated schools and serene natural surroundings. Set on a generous, private lot, this expansive 9-bedroom, 6-bathroom residence offers exceptional flexibility for a variety of living arrangements, including multigenerational living, assisted living potential, or executive retreat-style
Experience lakeshore living on Park Avenue – one of the most desirable stretches of shoreline on White Bear Lake, featuring ideal water depth and a sandy shoreline for swimming and lake fun. Enjoy the west-facing exposure with stunning sunsets year-round. This fully remodeled home blends modern design with effortless lake living. The main level offers a bright, open-concept layout anchored by a
Welcome to a rare and premium opportunity in the heart of Mahtomedi. Our final costs are much lower than expected thus the price decrease. The existing home at 233 Old Wildwood will be torn down to make way for this fabulous new custom home. Tucked away on the quiet, scenic, and one-way Old Wildwood Road, this 0.69-acre wooded homesite offers unmatched privacy, character, and natural beauty
Totally updated inside and out and still showing off the original classic charm and character. Some of the updates include new roof, siding, and gutters, new furnace, air conditioning, and water heater, solid surface countertops, stainless steel appliances, and more. Oversized windows bring in the beautiful sunlight throughout the day. Big beautiful level backyard (almost 3/4 acre) is perfect for
Welcome to 12 Forest Trail, an exceptional home offering serene water views from nearly every window. Recently redesigned by Eminent Design and renovated by Moser Homes, this residence showcases timeless design, quality craftsmanship, and finishes that truly live better than new construction. The two-story living room features walls of windows and striking floor-to-ceiling gas fireplace. The
Welcome home to this custom built Craftsman style walkout rambler! Main floor living at its finest! Gorgeous private lot overlooking a serene pond and the shores of Echo Lake. Nice updates throughout from mechanicals to gorgeous interior touches! Relax in the fabulous screened in porch with gas fireplace, entertain on the large private deck, throw cocktail parties like never before with the fully
Want to live in Mahtomedi's most coveted neighborhood, Wildridge Pines? Updates include new roof, Hardi-board siding, granite, and more. Culdesac setting backing into the mature trees provides a perfect backdrop for privacy and play. Large family-sized kitchen dazzles with stainless steel appliances and sleek granite countertops. A real wood-burning fireplace in the family room plus a firewood
Exceptional opportunity to own a rare duplex in the heart of Mahtomedi, just five blocks from White Bear Lake and located in the highly rated Mahtomedi School District. Ideal for owner-occupants or investors alike, live in one unit while generating income from the other. While the units are close mirrors of each other, the vacant unit is equipped with four bedrooms and two bathrooms while the
Bethany NelsonKeller Williams Premier Realty Lake Minnetonka
Introducing Vista Point, a brand-new apartment community in Mahtomedi, designed to elevate your living experience. We believe that high-quality living should be accessible to all, and that's why we've crafted a community where you can enjoy the best of both worlds. Our apartments feature elegant finishes, spacious layouts, and a host of amenities that cater to your every need. From a
Welcome to Briarcliff Apartments, a welcoming 55+ community nestled in the heart of Mahtomedi. Designed for comfort, convenience, and connection, Briarcliff offers a peaceful setting with thoughtfully designed apartment homes and a warm, neighborly atmosphere. Surrounded by natural beauty and close to local shops, dining, and everyday essentials, residents enjoy a relaxed lifestyle with the
Griffin Court Townhomes offer spacious, private living in a quiet residential neighborhood just behind Wildwood Elementary School in Mahtomedi, Minnesota. These well-maintained Mahtomedi townhomes feature private patios and green space, perfect for those seeking comfort, privacy, and a suburban lifestyle. Enjoy convenient access to the Gateway Trail, downtown Mahtomedi’s local shops and
Cedric's Landing offers comfortable apartment living with convenient access to local dining, shopping, and everyday essentials. Our community features thoughtfully designed floor plans and a welcoming atmosphere that makes coming home easy.Residents enjoy a variety of community amenities including a fitness center, outdoor pool, community spaces, and on-site management and maintenance. Whether
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
