Long Island is often discussed in terms of north shore versus south shore, but its more landlocked neighborhoods can also be great places to live. Located about halfway between the island’s eastern and westernmost boundaries and halfway between the Long Island Sound and the Atlantic Ocean, Middle Island is a prime example of this. “There are a lot of advantages to living in the center of the island,” says Todd Yovino, a licensed real estate broker and owner at Island Advantage Realty with over 30 years of experience. “For one thing, if you have quick access to major corridors, you can reduce your daily commute by about 15 minutes each leg. Add that up and see how much extra time you have on your schedule each month to do what you want.” Middle Island also has its own charm and provides everything locals need for day-to-day life. “It’s a quaint little place,” says Jacqulene Mitrani, an associate real estate broker at Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty who has sold homes here for four years and lives in the neighboring town of Yaphank. “There’s a lot of stuff to do — there’s a lot of great places to eat, there’s a lot of great trails.”
This father and son love spending time together at Pine Lake in Middle Island.
Middle Island residents can easily commute via nearby i-495.
1/2
Single-family houses starting at $400,000
Although many of Middle Island’s residential streets lack sidewalks, they tend to be quiet and shaded by trees, making daily walks and bike rides safe and enjoyable. In parts of the community, colonials, Cape Cods, ranch-style and hi-ranch homes are set back from the streets by large front yards, trees or both. It’s easy to find properties with half an acre or more of land. Home prices are typically between $400,000 and $650,000, though a handful of renovated properties on larger lots can climb over $800,000. Condos, co-ops and townhouses typically start at $200,000 and climb to around $600,000 for a renovated three-bedroom in a gated community.
Come to Middle Island to find affordable ranch style homes.
Two grand colonial homes sitting on spacious lots In Middle Island.
1/2
Career and college readiness at Longwood High School
The Longwood Central School District gets a B-plus from Niche. Children can attend West Middle Island Elementary School, which has a B, before moving to Longwood Middle School, which has a B-plus, for fifth and sixth grades. Kids then move on to Longwood Junior High School, which has an A-minus, for seventh and eighth grades and finish their studies at Longwood High School, which has a B-plus. The high school offers both career and technical education courses, which provide hands-on learning experience on business and technology topics, and a career and college pathways program that partners with local colleges and universities to allow students to take dual credit courses.
Longwood Senior High School is home to the Longwood Lions in Middle Island.
Longwood Middle School is located off of Yaphank Middle Island Rd.
1/2
Hiking under rare white pines
The Prosser Pines Nature Preserve is home to the only white pine tree forest on Long Island and the oldest concentration of white pines on the East Coast, making it truly unique. The trees, which aren’t native to New York, were brought from Quebec to Brookhaven in the 1800s. These days, locals love hiking under the preserve’s majestic pines. “I bring my kids to Prosser Pines,” Mitrani says. “It’s got these cool things inside the woods that almost look like little huts that the kids crawl into, and it’s an easy 0.7-mile loop. So it’s an awesome place to hang out and take a nice little stroll. It’s kid and pet-friendly.” Next door to the preserve and also shaded by the iconic trees, Cathedral Pines County Park is popular for hiking, mountain biking and camping.
Locals often take their dogs to Middle Island Dog Park, though they need to swipe a “Pooch Pass” from Brookhaven certifying that their dogs are vaccinated and spayed or neutered to get in, or play golf at Spring Lake Golf Club or Middle Island Country Club. Both organizations allow nonmembers to reserve times on certain courses. Just outside Middle Island, Rocky Point State Pine Barrens Preserve offers 3,800 acres where visitors can hike, bike, horseback ride and hunt.
The L.I. Mountain Biking Fest in Cathedral Pines in Middle Island has a stunt course.
A nice place to take a stroll is Prosser Pines with its tall trees and well maintained trails.
1/2
Bagels and Italian food off Middle Country Road
Middle Island doesn’t have the density of restaurants that some neighborhoods boast, but it still has a solid collection of local dining spots. “There’s a lot of different eateries — you have your little hidden gems,” Mitrani says. Locals often start their days at Bagels 101 or drop by Mac’s Countryside Deli & Catering for a sandwich, and they’ve headed to Lombardi’s for Italian classics since 1977. Walmart and King Kullen provide groceries close to home and the dog-friendly All Island Pet Supplies is the favorite shopping spot for furry members of the family.
Middle Island
Bagels 101 in Middle Island does a good job with this Long Island staple.
1/2
Nearby Long Island Rail Road stations
Middle Country Road, also known as State Route 25, runs right through the hamlet's heart and serves as its main thoroughfare. An onramp to Interstate 495 is about 5 miles to the south and reaching beaches on either shore takes 20 minutes. Those who commute to the city can drive to a Long Island Rail Road station in Yaphank, Medford or Ronkonkoma. Some stations run fewer trains during the day, even during rush hour, so it’s wise to study the schedules carefully. From the Ronkonkoma depot, which is 13 miles from Middle Island, the train reaches Midtown in under 90 minutes during peak travel times.
Annual carnival rides and fireworks
For over 70 years, Middle Island has held an annual Fireman’s Carnival & Parade in July. The event, which spans an entire weekend, features a parade, carnival rides and games, food and a night with fireworks.
Written By
Hannah Rainey
Photography Contributed By
Anthony Costa
Video By
Maurice McNeil
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Sharon A Fenimore,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Middle Island, NY sell after 47 days on the market compared to the national average of 49 days. The median sale price for homes in Middle Island, NY over the last 12 months is $459,900, up 19% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Beautiful Hampton model on the golf course. Three bedrooms, 2.5 baths, large formal Living room, main bedroom on the first floor, two-car garage, new roof, and HVAC 5 years young.Country club living in a gated community. Two clubhouses, each with a gym and indoor and outdoor pools, tennis, pickleball, basketball, and bocce courts.An active community with many activities.
Welcome to 3 Barberry Lane, Middle Island, NY 11953!This charming Ranch-style home sits on a level and spacious 0.58-acre lot, offering a private setting with vinyl siding, a paver patio, and ample outdoor space. Inside, you'll find an expansive living room featuring a wood pellet stove, mini-split central air conditioning, and gleaming hardwood floors that flow into a beautifully designed custom
Enjoy Country Club Living with Golf Views! Perfectly Maintained 2 Bedroom 2 Bath Devon 2 Model with many Updates That Include: Wood Flooring, Oak Cabinets, Crown Moldings, High Hat Lighting, Master Bath w/ Soaking Tub And Extended Rear Patio! Amenities Include: Private 9 Hole Golf Course, 2 Clubhouses, 2 Indoor And 2 Outdoor Pools, Tennis, Pickleball, Racquetball, 2 Gyms and Many Social
Magnificent End Unit with Garage, 3 Bedroom 2 Full Bathroom condo, Features Living room, Dining room, Eat in kitchen with SS appliances Granite countertops plenty of cabinets , 1st floor Primary bedroom with Full bathroom, 1st floor laundry, 2 bedrooms upstairs and a 2nd full bath spacious Attic. Large Deck. Brand New Oil Burner.
Suffolk County's premiere, 55 and up rental community has been carefully designed to fit your active lifestyle. Nestled among beautiful trees, Pinewood Estates provides the amenities and conveniences you want. Pinewood Estates apartment homes are beautifully appointed, with spacious floor plans and special features which rival those of many private luxury residences. At Pinewood Estates, the
Beautiful Sunny Garden Apartment – 2nd Floor | Long-Term RentalEnjoy easy, low-maintenance living in this bright and spacious garden apartment, perfectly situated on the second floor. Soak up the sun in a serene, green setting with access to top-notch amenities: Outdoor Pool, Club house, Tennis courts and scenic walking trails. Conveniently and centrally located, you'll have quick access to
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
