$275,646Average Value$159Average Price per Sq Ft8Homes For Sale
Home to the only 24/7 Christmas-themed bar in Omaha
Developed mainly in the 1950s and 60s, Keystone is a suburb full of intergenerational families. Rob Rutar, the owner of Rudy's Bar — the only 24/7 Christmas-themed bar in Omaha — says it's the kind of place he dreamed about living in High School. "There are a lot of older, nice homes here. Not mansions, just nice homes on big lots here with big trees," he says. "It's a crazy kind of twisty and turny neighborhood whereas the majority of Omaha is set up on a grid system." Rutar describes Keystone as a "floating island" as most retail and shopping options are outside the neighborhood but still close. People here work all kinds of jobs and, true to small-town living, run into each other often. "I'll have bankers and insurance guys sitting right next to mechanics and people who work from basement waterproofing places, and everyone gets along."
Split level home in Keystone provides little more room than a typical two-story home.
Find beautiful updated Cottage homes in Keystone.
1/2
The pub crawl ends at Rudy's Bar
Rudy’s, on Maple Street, is always alight with festive decor no matter the time of year. It’s one of the small neighborhood bars along the borders of Keystone. The local pub crawl, which just began last year, was organized by local Realtor Linda Bischof Carpenter. It will end at Rudy’s but the bus the community hired takes them to all the pubs in the area. “Our residents try to support our local establishments as much as possible. That's what this bar crawl is about. They support us and we support them." For breakfast, lunch, brunch, and bottomless cups of coffee, locals head to Keystone Kafe on Military Avenue. Their salted caramel French toast is a favorite and the vintage atmosphere, complete with checkerboard floors, is inviting. “What’s amazing is the customers — most are from the neighborhood,” says Deb Jensen, the general manager.
Keystone cottages and ranch-styles
There isn't new development, but rather a lot of remodeling happening in Keystone as people move in and sometimes back to the area. "We raised our family in the same home I was raised in. We find that very common here," Bischof Carpenter says. "I just sold a house to a third generation — a cute young couple in the neighborhood whose parents and grandparents all live in Keystone." She describes the market here as eclectic. "There is a wide range of price points, and we are seeing — on average — 90 homes sold annually." A 1960s ranch-style home with room for love and care might begin around $170,000 in Keystone; an updated cottage with a wraparound porch for $370,000; and a remodeled midcentury modern ranch-style house may cost around $560,000. Prices rarely climb higher than that.
Bungalows are great for first-time home buyers in Keystone.
Ranch homes in Keystone are a great place for new small families.
1/2
School scholarships funded by the Neighborhood Association
Students are served by Omaha Public Schools. Homes are zoned to the neighborhood elementary schools and Morton Middle. The elementary schools are Adams Elementary School and Boyd Elementary School. After Morton Middle, students either attend Omaha Northwest Magnet High School or Benson Magnet High School. Aside from Benson, which earns a B-minus rating, these schools all score a C from Niche. The volunteer neighborhood association, the Keystone Community Task Force, creates a scholarship fund with proceeds from their bi-annual Chili Feed that benefits the neighborhood high school students.
Boyd Elementary School teaches around 500 students a year.
Boyd Elementary School in the center of the Keystone neighborhood.
1/2
Laps at Keystone Klub Swimming Pool
Starting in Democracy Park, the Keystone Trail runs along the neighborhood's western border, following the Little Papillion Creek south. It travels nearly 30 miles, ending at Haworth Park in neighboring Bellevue. Keystone Park is at the heart of the neighborhood, offering a playground, a tennis court and a site for events like the summer concert in the park and a pickleball tournament. Keystone Klub Swimming Pool is there when locals want to swim laps. There's also a sports complex and two golf courses outside the neighborhood.
Democracy Park has a playground great for kids' meetups.
Burn some calories at the Keystone Trail in Keystone Park.
1/2
Westroads Mall is 3 miles south
Conveniently located near highways 133 and 64, and with Interstate 680 less than 3 miles away, Keystone provides easy access to the rest of Omaha and beyond. Most residents drive as the area isn't super walkable, but the Omaha Metro does run buses through the area, creating commuting options to nearby shops and downtown. Bus stops line the highways as do the local pubs and taverns. There is a Target on 73rd Plaza and a Walmart Supercenter for groceries and other essentials on 99th Street – both are just 2 miles from Keystone. Westroads Mall is 3 miles south, off Nicholas Street, with popular chains like Dick's Sporting Goods and Aerie and an AMC Theatre.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Keystone, Omaha sell after 21 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Keystone, Omaha over the last 12 months is $262,500, up 4% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
*contract pending on market for backup offers. Beautifully updated home on large 0.33ac lot in the popular Keystone neighborhood! This 3-bedroom, 3-bath property blends modern updates with classic charm. You’ll love the spacious and bright layout featuring gorgeous hardwood floors, an updated kitchen with skylight and dining area, and a comfortable living space perfect for entertaining or
*** OPEN HOUSE 10/18/25 Saturday 11:30 AM - 1:00 PM *** Unique 3 bed/3 bath 2-story in Keystone neighborhood, 3.5 car garage! Vaulted ceiling in living room. Primary bedroom has vaulted ceiling and 3/4 bathroom. Open floorplan. Fully fenced backyard with wooded feed. Storage shed.
True 4-Bedroom Home with a Spacious Addition! Step inside to a welcoming living room highlighted by a beautiful bay window. The remodeled kitchen is a chef’s dream, offering abundant cabinets and counter space, double ovens, a large center island, and an open layout to the dining area—ideal for cooking and entertaining. Convenience shines with main floor laundry and a rare 1/2 bath off the
MOVE IN SPECIAL- Reduced deposits with OBLIGO!Located just blocks away from one of Omaha’s hippest neighborhoods, Keystone Park apartments are ideally located to enjoy all that Benson has to offer and are situated just east of our sister property, Keystone Court. The surrounding Maple Street corridor boasts a vibrant culture that is an attractive place for foodies, musicians, artists and
1 Bed 1 Bath Keystone - Check out this cozy and cute 1 bed 1 bath available at Keystone! Located in a quiet neighborhood with walking trails and parks near by. Close to Benson, UNO, and has easy access to I-680. Plenty of space and storage for a 1 bedroom apartment, and parking is enforced so no need to hunt for a spot at the end of the day! Additionally, all entrances are
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
