Nicknamed the "Heart of Arizona," the small town of Payson is set in just about the center of the state. This is what's known as Rim Country, close to the Mogollon Rim of the Colorado Plateau and surrounded by the mountains, lakes, pines and desert of the almost 3 million-acre Tonto National Forest. “I love living here because I can go fishing, kayaking, hiking and horseback riding,” says Payson resident Kathy Justesen, a Realtor with West USA Realty. “Everything is so close. In 15 minutes, I can be on the water or hiking in the forest.” Wildlife sightings are common, according to fourth-generation Payson native Hannah Lusk, an agent with ERA Young Real Estate and Investment. “Elk cross the street and roam the town,” she says. “I'll commonly see them lying in my neighbors' yards on my way to work."
Many of Payson’s nearly 17,000 residents are either retirees or live in the community part time; according to Lusk, those still in the workforce commonly commute 90 miles to Phoenix. “There are a lot of second homeowners here who want a cabin in the woods or just a place to escape from the summer heat in the Valley,” Justesen says. “A lot of people from out of state are also purchasing a second home here for when they retire. The weather is pretty mild, so we have four seasons and we’re about 20 degrees cooler than Phoenix in the summer.”
A wide range of housing options to a wide range of budgets and lifestyles
As of late 2024, Payson’s median home price is nearly $435,000, up 2% from the previous year and compared to Phoenix's $441,000. Payson's average home value is $438,000, compared to the nation's $554,000.
Homes in Payson date as far back as the late 20th century and options include manufactured homes, townhouses and condominiums, as well as sprawling luxury builds on acreage with mountain and forest views. There are also undeveloped lots for buyers who want to build custom homes.
Many housing options near Payson's city center include condo's and townhomes.
Payson also offers residents sprawling luxury builds on acreage with mountain and forest views.
1/2
Abundant recreation opportunities between Tonto National Forest and community parks
Surrounded by the vast wilderness of Tonto National Forest, Payson residents have tons of opportunities for outdoor recreation. The lakes and tributaries of Tonto National Forest are stocked with trout, and there are dozens of trails through groves of Ponderosa pines and up in the White Mountains. The Tonto Apache Tribe who lives adjacent to Payson are descended from one of several prehistoric tribes who called the forest home; signs of some of these prehistoric civilizations are still found throughout the forest at various archaeological sites.
The 82-acre Rumsey Park is Payson’s largest park, where residents can work up a sweat at its many sports facilities, practice tricks at the skate park and cool off in the community pool. Locally referred to as the “Jewel of Payson," the 43-acre Green Valley Park has plenty of open space and three fishing lakes, and hosts community events like the town’s summer concert series and Fourth of July fireworks.
Locally referred to as the “Jewel of Payson," the 43-acre Green Valley Park has plenty of open space and three fishing lakes, and hosts community events like the town’s summer concert series and Fourth of July fireworks.
The Tonto Apache Tribe who lives adjacent to Payson are descended from one of several prehistoric tribes who called the forest home; signs of some of these prehistoric civilizations are still found throughout the forest at various archaeological sites.
1/2
Western-themed community events, including the nation's oldest continuous rodeo
The town’s Western culture is a point of pride for the community. Residents gather several times a year for shows put on by Payson Pro Rodeo, the oldest continuous rodeo in the country, which has been entertaining locals since 1884. "They have all types of events like tie-down roping, bareback bull riding and Mutton Bustin' where kids jump on the back of sheep, which is really fun to watch," Lusk says. "They raise money and give it to multiple non-profits, so those that attend aren't just there for the rodeo, they're supporting the community."
Each September at the Fiddle and Food Truck Festival, Payson hosts Arizona’s State Fiddling Championship, inviting residents from all over the state to enjoy the talents of fiddlers of all ages.
National grocery, retail and dining chains mesh with locally owned shops and eateries
Most stores and restaurants are concentrated along State Route 87, known locally as Beeline Highway, and Highway 260, which intersect at the center of town. Residents can stop into fast food restaurants and familiar national chains for a bite to eat, though most of the town’s dining options are locally owned. Many of the local eateries serve hearty comfort fare in a cozy and casual setting that caters to the town’s down-home crowd.
Safeway, Bashas’ and Walmart are the local go-tos for groceries, and while there are a handful of big-box chain stores, the town’s retail market is dominated by locally owned antique, consignment and shops with eclectic offerings.
Basha's is one of a few options that the residents of Payson to buy groceries.
Payson residents enjoy a quick bite to eat at the national chain restaurant, Chili's.
1/2
Flexible and online learning options in the Payson Unified School District
The Payson Unified School District earns a B-minus from Niche and serves about 2,300 students across one high school, one middle school and two elementary schools. Payson High School offers online learning and flexible hybrid scheduling options through the Payson Center for Success. Eastern Arizona College also has a satellite campus in Payson.
Payson High School offers online learning and flexible hybrid scheduling options through the Payson Center for Success.
Julia Randall Elementary School receives a B rating from Niche and sits at the corner of the three lakes in Green Valley Park.
1/2
A local bus line and access to Beeline Highway
State Route 87, locally known as Beeline Highway, runs north-south through the center of town, leading about 90 miles southwest to Phoenix. Via the Beeline Bus, residents can travel throughout Payson and to the nearby communities of Star Valley and Mesa Del Caballo. Payson is home to the Banner Payson Medical Center and the general aviation Payson Municipal Airport; for commercial flights, Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport is roughly 80 miles away.
A recent decrease in overall crime
According to the Arizona Department of Public Safety, reported incidents of violent crime in Payson decreased by 38% between 2022 and 2023. Reported incidents of burglary also decreased by about 23% during this time, though larceny increased by about 39%.
Written By
Lauren Schott
Photography Contributed By
John Williams
Video By
Bill Jennings
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Keri Reidhead,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Payson, AZ sell after 104 days on the market compared to the national average of 70 days. The median sale price for homes in Payson, AZ over the last 12 months is $500,000, up 5% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Absolutely stunning 4-Bedroom, 3-Bath Home with Beautiful Southern Views! The main floor offers elegance with an open floor plan kitchen, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, a dining, living room combo, two guest rooms, with the first of two primary suites. The downstairs features a second oversized primary suite equipped with its own split-system heating and cooling for year-round
Nestled in the picturesque East Verde Park neighborhood, where the East Verde River winds through the community, this beautiful 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers the perfect blend of comfort and outdoor adventure. With hiking trails, fishing, and swimming spots just moments away, this is a true nature lover's paradise.Step inside to find a spacious kitchen featuring an electric cooktop, double
Well maintained, quality built home includes 2 bdrm plus den, office or 3rd bdrm, and many well appointed features. Professionally painted exterior in June of 2024. Walk to stores and college, 1 level no steps. Large windows, beautiful kitchen, stainless appliances, beautiful custom cabinetry, tile back splash, breakfast bar & granite counter tops. Luxury bathrooms with tiled showers, split
Rare Mixed-Use Opportunity in the Heart of Payson704 S Meadow Street, Payson, AZThis unique mixed-use property just steps from Main Street in the cool mountain town of Payson, Arizona, offers a blank slate with massive potential. Currently a shell with a dirt floor, it's primed for developmental, residential, commercial, or both. Zoned for flexible use, this property supports
Charming home in need of a little TLC in the Woodhill Subdivision, 1,266 square feet of living space, split floor plan, 3 bedrooms, 2 bath, living room features rock inlayed fireplace, open floor plan, covered deck, seller is offering flooring allowance with acceptable offer
MAIN HOUSE FURNISHED for rent on horse estate in town. Great room with wood floors, furnished with comfortable furniture, TV, fireplace, eat in counter to large kitchen. Dining table, french doors, tile and large rugs. Very large master suite with walk in shower and closet, king bed. 2nd bedrm has queen bed, and bath has tub/shower. Exit off master to garden.Covered patio in front and large back
Beautifully remodeled 3-bed, 2-bath home on a private corner lot in the heart of Payson! Updated in the last 5 years with a gorgeous kitchen featuring a gas stove, new appliances, updated flooring, 5'' baseboards, new lighting, fresh interior/exterior paint, new blinds, and a new roof. Enjoy the outdoors with a shady gazebo, Hot Springs 6-person spa, irrigation system, and 15 newly planted trees,
STUNNING SINGLE LEVEL HOME IN CHAPARRAL PINES ON A CORNER LOT! UPGRADES GALORE*GREAT ROOM*DINING AREA*KITCHEN INCLUDES: S/S APPLIANCES, SLAB GRANITE,*HARD WOOD FLOORING VERY OPEN FLOOR PLAN* CEILING IS VAULTED W/TONGUE AND GROOVE*8'DOORS*LARGE MASTER SUITE WITH IT'S OWN ENTRY TO BACK DECK *MASTER BATH HAS SLATE TILE FLOORING,LARGE WALK IN SHOWER*LARGE MASTER CLOSET W/BUILT INS*ONE ADDITIONAL
Edyi Fawcett-NickolaKeller Williams Realty Sonoran Living
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
