$417,810Average Value$257Average Price per Sq Ft15Homes For Sale
State and federal lands make up Sandyston Township
On the west side of Kittatinny Ridge in Sussex County, New Jersey, rural Sandyston Township is surrounded by greenery and state lands near the Pennsylvania border. "It's a unique spot in New Jersey," says Mayor George B. Harper, Jr., a lifelong resident. "It's a really small community with a lot of community spirit."
Sandyston's location -- 55 miles from Newark and 66 miles from New York City -- helps this community of mainly protected land remain a lush and wild forested landscape. “Sandyston is truly a nature lover’s paradise,” says Realtor Mildred Di Iorio of eXp Realty. “From the scenic hiking trails in the Delaware Water Gap to the fishing and camping opportunities at Stokes State Forest, the area offers countless ways to enjoy the outdoors. It's perfect for those looking to get away from it all and immerse themselves in the tranquility of nature.” The nearest commercial center and the Sussex County seat is 16 miles away in Newton.
Homes with long front yards are common in the rural area of Sandyston.
Stony Lake at the Stokes State Forest in Sandyston is a local favorite park for its trails.
1/2
Hiking and fishing in Stokes State Forest
"We have a lot of fish and game lands," says Harper. "So, a lot of hunting and fishing, that's what most of our tourism is. It supports our economy. All public land is open to fishing and hunting." In Stokes State Forest, within Sandyston, hikers can take in the views from Sunrise Mountain while birders watch the hawk migration during the spring and fall. Stokes also offers trails for hiking, skiing, horseback riding, snowmobiling and more. Also within the township is the Hidden Acres Golf Course, an 18-hole course where baseball legend Babe Ruth once played. The renowned pitcher and his friend, Yankees pitcher Russ Van Atta, would play golf, hunt and fish in Sandyston, closing the day with a drink at Gyp's Tavern in Branchville, 5 miles away.
The Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area, 10 miles away, offers hiking, biking, boating and more along the Delaware River. Within the National Recreation Area sits Millbrook Village, a restored 1800s town born from a grist mill. Visitors may tour the area and explore a few of the old homes. For modern architecture, Luna Parc, home of artist Ricky Boscarino, is a museum and a cabinet of curiosities, displaying colorful exteriors and mosaiced interiors adorned with the artist's various collections. "Absolutely one of a kind," says Harper. "Almost a small amusement park, but it's his home. Twice a year, he has an open house."
Stokes State Forest Park in Sandyston has a series of hiking trails for locals to explore.
Locals can visit the Hidden Acres Golf Course in Sandyston for an afternoon of putting.
1/2
Active recreation committee
In August, the Sandyston Township Fire Department hosts a tractor parade. "The whole town turns out," says Harper. "This year, we had 160 tractors in the parade, and we have a 7-mile route, and everyone has a party on their lawn." The volunteer fire department hosts several events throughout the year, including a barbecue and a Santa Parade in December. The Sandyston Township Recreation Committee also holds events. "The recreation commission is very active," says Harper. "A real pride of our community." The committee plans the Gobble Hobble, a popular 5K run to celebrate the fall season. Religious services are held at Delaware Valley United Methodist Church, St. Thomas the Apostle Roman Catholic Church and Our Lady Queen of Peace R.C. Church.
Township to remain bucolic
Roadways lined with homes and stretches of farmland weave through the township. Most houses sit on large, manicured lots or are part of a farm. Farmhouse, cottage, Colonial Revival and ranch-styles are common and range from $205,000 to $580,000. Sandyston is not an expanding area. "We're never going to be developed to any great degree," says Harper. "Because over 75% of lands are already in state or federal hands. We have over 1,000 acres of preserved farmland, and I don't think we'll see any of the kind of growth that's happened elsewhere."
Farmhouses are a popular housing style in Sandyston, many converted from real farm buildings.
Large colonial homes with long driveways can be found around Sandyston.
1/2
Kittatinny Regional High School serves the Sussex County community, including Sandyston.
Peters Valley School of Craft, ‘a gem in our township’
Children may attend Sandyston-Walpack Consolidated School, which receives a B-minus for kindergarten through sixth grade. Students advance to Kittatinny Regional High School, which receives a B-minus for seventh through 12th grade.
"Peters Valley School of Craft, that is a gem in our township. It's an independent craft school on federal property," says Harper. "And people come from all over to study crafts from blacksmithing to weaving." The school teaches makers of all levels in various trades and allows students to exhibit and sell their work at exhibitions and craft fairs.
Commuters use U.S. Route 206 to New York
Many residents commute to New York City using U.S. Route 206, which connects to Interstate 280. A park and ride in Newton, 16 miles away, is also open on weekdays and takes commuters directly to New York. The Newton Medical Center is 16 miles away, and the Newark Liberty International Airport is 64 miles away.
Dining along Kittatinny Lake
Layton Hotel Tavern serves American comfort food in a cozy pub setting. Residents may enjoy a similar menu while overlooking Kittatinny Lake at the Mountain House Tavern and Grill. More shopping and dining is available in Milford, Pennsylvania, 5 miles away and Newton. Groceries are available at Dale's Market, 7 miles away, and at Weis Markets in Newton.
Sandyston locals enjoy a fresh pizza at the Mountain House, cooked in a new Italian wood oven.
Layton Hotel Tavern works with local farms to keep their food local and fresh in Sandyston.
1/2
Photography Contributed By
Elma Kukaj
Video By
Brandon Flash Craigie
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Cheryl Towey,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Sandyston, NJ sell after 28 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Sandyston, NJ over the last 12 months is $392,500, up 47% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
One-of-a-Kind Country Retreat with Breathtaking ViewsWelcome to your dream escape this truly unique country retreat is perfectly nestled on over 1.5 scenic acres, offering panoramic mountain views and peaceful privacy.This charming home features 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, including a beautifully remodeled primary ensuite bathroom. The spacious primary suite also offers a walk-in closet and large
This immaculate property features brand new windows, new siding, new roof, and new flooring throughout. Completely renovated in 2025. Step into the elegant kitchen with white soft-close cabinetry, a center island, stone backsplash, upgraded LG stainless steel appliances, and gleaming granite countertops. The open-concept layout flows seamlessly into a bright and inviting living area, highlighted
Welcome to this move-in ready 3 bedroom ranch nestled in the beautiful countryside! This well-maintained home offers the perfect blend of rural charm and modern convenience, set on a spacious lot with a peaceful creek running through. Step inside to discover new flooring throughout, updated appliances, and a full-house water filtration system for everyday comfort. The home features ample storage,
Prime Mixed-Use Property in Kittatinny Lake CommunityThis versatile mixed-use building offers an excellent opportunity for business owners, investors, or those seeking a live-work setup. Situated on a highly visible corner lot along the highway, the property features a commercial space with a built-in garage on the ground level, ideal for retail, office, or service-based businesses.Upstairs, two
This sprawling home, tucked away down a quiet country road, is ready for your own personal touches. It has so much to offer the visionary buyer, with its versatile and unique layout. The first floor offers a living room, family room, dining room, eat in kitchen, laundry, and primary suite. The second floor offers three generously sized bedrooms, plus a bonus room, as well as a full bath. With a
One-of-a-Kind Country Retreat with Breathtaking ViewsWelcome to your dream escape this truly unique country retreat is perfectly nestled on over 1.5 scenic acres, offering panoramic mountain views and peaceful privacy.This charming home features 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, including a beautifully remodeled primary ensuite bathroom. The spacious primary suite also offers a walk-in closet and large
Property Id: 1656926Are you looking for some peace & quiet? Seeking a mature, clean & responsible person to SHARE a 3 bedroom 2 bath country-contemporary style home in beautiful Frankford Twp. The Frankford Park is within walking distance. Sit under the gazebo on the patio as you watch the wildlife on nearly 2 acres.You'll have your own room, 12x14 w/2 windows, & a nice size closet.
Beautifully renovated spacious 2 bedroom 2 full bath wmd floor apartment with full on suite in primary bedroom along with additional full bath off kitchen and adjacent to 2nd bedroom. Find Quartz counter tops stainless steel appliances and laundry hookups in this turn key unit. New floors bathrooms and back deck make this a great space. A large living room and separate and equally as large
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
