$305,660Average Value$242Average Price per Sq Ft5Homes For Sale
Sullivan blends Syracuse suburbia with rural serenity
Sullivan’s winding residential roads give locals a place to live within 25 miles of both downtown Syracuse and Oneida Lake. This wide-ranging Madison County community encompasses the village of Chittenango, which offers small-town ambiance with suburban qualities, including roomy yards. Sullivan also stretches north toward the hamlet of Bridgeport, where some properties sit right on the water. “Really the main feature is the access to Oneida Lake, which is kind of the best-kept-secret lake in the area,” says local Realtor Bill Carroll, who’s with Real Broker, LLC. and has over 23 years of industry experience.
Oneida Lake is a centerpiece for boating, fishing, and waterfront sunsets in Sullivan.
Sullivan offers roomy yards and quiet streets near Oneida Lake.
1/2
Sullivan’s differing settings accommodate a range of homes
Much of the Sullivan area, particularly Chittenango, includes established homes lined neatly on quiet blocks. They come with grassy lawns that often stretch from roughly one-fifth of an acre to about a half-acre. However, there’s also the opportunity to find more secluded, rural properties on more than an acre between Chittenango and the lake. Lakeside properties can provide direct beach and dock access. Architectural styles vary quite a bit, but a bulk of the Sullivan’s options are colonial- and ranch-style homes built between 1950 and 2010. “You can get anything from a mid-1800s, stone farmhouse to a contemporary [home] built up on a hill, with views,” Carroll says. “And there’s a wide variety of pricing in the area.” Traditional single-family houses needing work can go for $80,000 to $110,000, and move-in-ready homes under 1,600 square feet typically garner anywhere from $120,000 to $300,000. Larger houses often sell for $310,000 to $880,000. Sullivan also has manufactured homes for $10,000 to $200,000 based on square footage and acreage.
Tudor, colonial and ranch-style homes bring classic charm to Chittenango.
This Sullivan home features a grassy half-acre lot and quiet surroundings.
Colonial homes in Sullivan feature classic design and roomy backyards.
Families in Sullivan appreciate the safe, walkable blocks in Chittenango.
1/4
Lake lends itself to boating, fishing and beachside relaxation
The 51,000-acre Oneida Lake is a centerpiece for recreation in this area. Bridgeport’s Chapman Park features a pier that’s open to fishing, plus a pavilion, athletic fields, tennis courts and a dog park. The nearby community of Sylvan Beach has almost 5,000 feet of sandy shorefront. Bridgeport also has multiple marinas, for area boaters. “You can take a boat all the way to the Hudson River from there,” Carroll says. “It’s connected to the old [New York State Canal System].” Sullivan Park in Chittenango includes a playground, a nine-hole disc golf course and a fishing pond. The Wild Animal Park is another way to get outside in the Sullivan area — it's a 14-acre zoo with a drive-through safari and animals ranging from African leopards to warthogs. “That’s kind of a draw for tourism as well,” Carroll says.
Sullivan locals can drive 20 minutes from Chittenango to Oneida Lake for a day of fishing.
Sullivan Park has green space and walking paths.
1/2
After-school events and clubs enrich school life
The overwhelming majority of Sullivan is part of the Chittenango Central School District, which maintains an A-minus grade from Niche. Students may start at Bolivar Road Elementary, where they can take part in special activities like after-school playground nights and a trunk-or-treat. Chittenango Middle offers extracurriculars including a drama club and a chain reaction club, which focuses on community service projects. Chittenango High has art and esports clubs. All three schools maintain B-plus ratings. A southern portion of Sullivan falls within the B-plus-rated Cazenovia Central School District.
Bolivar Road Elementary has a playground a basketball court for students.
The Chittenango High School is ranked 246th within New York State.
Chittenango Middle School is located on a main road in the village of Chittenango.
1/3
Syracuse-area amenities are a relatively short drive away
Sullivan residents are just under 20 miles from downtown Syracuse using New York state Route 290 and Interstate 690. Crouse Hospital downtown includes a 24-hour emergency room. Travelers in Sullivan heading farther out of town have the Syracuse Hancock International Airport, which is about 20 miles away and offers direct flights to over two dozen cities.
Syracuse Hancock International Airport is 20 miles from Sullivan.
Syracuse is accessible for residents of Sullivan via NY State Route 290 and I-690.
1/2
Chittenango downtown is a hub for eats
Many of the Sullivan area’s restaurants are located in the heart of Chittenango, along Genesee Street and Genesee Turnpike. Ruby Begonia's Restaurant and Lounge serves southern-inspired items, from fried chicken to shrimp and grits. “They’re originally from Canada, and they helped out with a local winery for a while,” Carroll says of Ruby Begonia’s owners. “This is their first restaurant venture, but they’re doing really well.” Darlene’s Kitchen, farther up Genesee Street, is a popular place for breakfast. Ten Pin is a spot to grab a drink and a homestyle meal with a sign outside boasting the “Best Lunch in Town.” “A fun, kind of old-school, bar that locals go to,” Carroll says.
Other attractions downtown include the All Things Oz Museum. L. Frank Baum, who authored the “The Wonderful Wizard of Oz,” was born in Chittenango and the museum has well over 1,000 Oz-related items on display. The Sullivan Free Library has about 70,000 books, and the St. Paul's Episcopal Church next door dates to 1866. A commercial plaza on Chittenango’s west side features a TOPS Friendly Markets location and the YBR Casino & Sports Book, across from a Dollar General.
Nina's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant in Chittenango offers a variety of Italian cuisine.
St. Paul’s Episcopal Church dates back to 1866 in Chittenango.
Demario’s Eatery serves classic Italian dishes in Sullivan.
1/3
Oz pedigree inspires an annual tradition
Chittenango’s status as Baum’s birthplace is the basis for the community’s annual Oz-Stravaganza Festival, the biggest Wizard of Oz-themed fair on the globe. “It’s their claim to fame,” Carroll says. Held in early June, the festival features a costume contest, rides and a parade through downtown Chittenango, where the brick sidewalks are painted yellow as a nod to Oz.
Downtown paths in Sullivan nod to L. Frank Baum’s enduring legacy.
All Things Oz Museum showcases artifacts celebrating Oz history.
1/2
Written By
Wayne Epps Jr.
Photography Contributed By
EB Fox
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Kristi Croniser,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Sullivan, NY sell after 16 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Sullivan, NY over the last 12 months is $187,500, down 42% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Why wait to build when this exceptional home is ready for you? Set on 1.67 acres and offering over 2,800 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space with beautiful views of Oneida Lake. This 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath property blends quality construction with modern comfort. From the moment it was built, the sellers invested heavily in premium structural components—including ‘Superior Wall’ pre-studded
Why wait to build when this exceptional home is ready for you? Set on 1.67 acres and offering over 2,800 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space with beautiful views of Oneida Lake. This 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath property blends quality construction with modern comfort. From the moment it was built, the sellers invested heavily in premium structural components—including ‘Superior Wall’ pre-studded
Great opportunity to have 2 ranches on the same parcel for a family member that needs to be close by, or live in 1 ranch & rent out the other for great income. Both ranches have a living room, eat-in kitchen, 2 bedrooms, full bath, 1st floor laundry. Combined price for these is $280,000, The ranch on 628 Lakeport Rd has an attached garage, and home is 927 sqft. also has a hot water heater 2 years
Lovely Oneida Lake Waterfront Home!Enjoy stunning lake views and endless recreation from this exceptional property featuring an in-ground pool, private dock (newer), and boat hoists. Many updates make this home move-in ready and perfect for year-round living or a weekend retreat. The main house offers hardwood floors in the kitchen and dining area, a spacious living room with LVT flooring
Property Id: 1616671Welcome to your new home at 355 NY-31 in Bridgeport, NY! This charming 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom unit is available for $1350/month. Enjoy amenities like a refrigerator, oven, microwave, off-street parking, secure building, and vaulted ceilings. Utilities included are garbage, sewage, and water. Will consider small dogs with additional pet rent to cover
Farmhouse + Apartment + Horse Barn For Rent Country living with room for you AND your horses! This charming farmhouse is ready for its next tenant - and it comes with a bonus apartment and equestrian setup. Just the house is listed for rent under MLS # S1639160. In addition to the spacious 4 bedroom, 3 bath home and garage, there is an outdoor grass riding arena, 2 stall barn with an
Farmhouse For Rent - Chittenango SchoolsDreaming of country charm without sacrificing comfort and convenience? Welcome to your new home, sitting right between Chittenango and Manlius! What You'll Love: Spacious Living - gigantic living room + 4 huge bedrooms and 3 bathsBright Kitchen - with ample cabinetry and room for diningPrivate Backyard - fully fenced with a paver
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
