Recently Sold Middlebury, NY Homes

$425,000 Sold Mar 07, 2025

5076 Kelly Rd, Wyoming, NY 14591

• 3 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 2,781 Sq Ft
• Built 1994

Last Sold Summary

• 6% Below List Price
• $153/SF
• 119 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $429,742

Last Listing Agent Sarah Kieffer Listing by HUNT Real Estate Corporation

5076 Kelly Rd, Wyoming, NY 14591

$250,000 Sold Dec 18, 2025

1318 Dale Rd, Dale, NY 14039

• 5 Beds
• 1.5 Baths
• 2,142 Sq Ft
• Built 1850

Last Sold Summary

• 9% Above List Price
• $117/SF
• 13 Days On Market

Last Listing Agent Marcia Veley Listing by Rivellino Realty

1318 Dale Rd, Dale, NY 14039

$163,000 Sold Oct 20, 2025

28 S Academy St, Wyoming, NY 14591

• 3 Beds
• 1 Bath
• 1,537 Sq Ft
• Built 1870

Last Sold Summary

• 4% Below List Price
• $106/SF
• 14 Days On Market

Last Listing Agent Bridget Kelly Listing by Rivellino Realty

28 S Academy St, Wyoming, NY 14591

$189,735 Sold Nov 21, 2025

5037 W Middlebury Rd, East Bethany, NY 14054

• 3 Beds
• 1.5 Baths
• 1,862 Sq Ft
• Built 1890

Last Sold Summary

• 26% Above List Price
• $102/SF
• 34 Days On Market

Last Listing Agent Michael Whalen Listing by Bid-n-Buy Realty & Auctions

5037 W Middlebury Rd, East Bethany, NY 14054

$136,300 Sold Oct 16, 2025

29 Maple St, Wyoming, NY 14591

• 3 Beds
• 1 Bath
• 1,538 Sq Ft
• Built 1900

Last Sold Summary

• 19% Above List Price
• $89/SF
• 4 Days On Market

Last Listing Agent Wendy Sue Freiheit Listing by ERA Team VP Real Estate - Arcade

29 Maple St, Wyoming, NY 14591

$226,310 Sold Aug 07, 2025

2 N Academy St, Wyoming, NY 14591

• 3 Beds
• 1.5 Baths
• 1,858 Sq Ft
• Built 1860

Last Sold Summary

• 3% Above List Price
• $122/SF
• 18 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $217,194

Last Listing Agent Bridget Keough Listing by Rivellino Realty

2 N Academy St, Wyoming, NY 14591

$175,000 Sold Sep 11, 2025

45 S Academy St, Wyoming, NY 14591

• 3 Beds
• 1.5 Baths
• 2,025 Sq Ft
• Built 1900

Last Sold Summary

• 8% Below List Price
• $86/SF
• 36 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $180,409

Last Listing Agent Niccole Hastings Listing by Rivellino Realty

45 S Academy St, Wyoming, NY 14591

$235,000 Sold Dec 15, 2025

39 Sherman Ave, Wyoming, NY 14591

• 3 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 1,449 Sq Ft
• Built 1900

Last Sold Summary

• 7% Above List Price
• $162/SF
• 36 Days On Market

Last Listing Agent Alyssa Cutcliffe Listing by WNY Metro Roberts Realty

39 Sherman Ave, Wyoming, NY 14591

$335,000 Sold Oct 17, 2025

5990 Rowley Rd, Wyoming, NY 14591

• 3 Beds
• 2 Baths
• 1,728 Sq Ft
• Built 1971

Last Sold Summary

• 7% Below List Price
• $194/SF
• 27 Days On Market

Last Listing Agent Lynn Donnelly Listing by Bontrager RE & Auction Service

5990 Rowley Rd, Wyoming, NY 14591

$212,000 Sold Jul 14, 2025

907 Vernal Rd, Attica, NY 14011

• 3 Beds
• 1 Bath
• 1,083 Sq Ft
• Built 1998

Last Sold Summary

• 6% Below List Price
• $196/SF
• 31 Days On Market

Current Estimated Value $204,693

Last Listing Agent Rebecca Guzdek Listing by Keller Williams Realty WNY

907 Vernal Rd, Attica, NY 14011