8

Safest Neighborhoods in Chautauqua County, NY

  • /34

    Hanover

    Hanover, NY, combines lakefront and rural living along Lake Erie. Historic homes dot Silver Creek and Sunset Bay. Residents enjoy beaches, parks, and the Festival of the Grapes. Crime risk is below the national average.

    • Average Value

      $244K

    • List Price

      $171K - $928K

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      3 Listings

    Hanover
  • Westfield Township

    Westfield Township

    • Average Value

      $216K

    • List Price

      $99K - $521K

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      4 Listings

    Westfield Township
  • Poland Town

    Poland Town

    • Average Value

      $190K

    • List Price

      $21K - $762K

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      3 Listings

    Poland Town
  • /22

    Carroll

    Carroll, NY is a rural town on the Pennsylvania border with farmland and pine forests. Frewsburg serves as its main hamlet. South Valley State Forest offers hiking trails, while Erlandson Overlook Park provides panoramic views.

    • Average Value

      $187K

    • List Price

      $42K - $398K

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      3 Listings

    Carroll
  • /33

    Cherry Creek

    Cherry Creek, NY, is a rural town in Western New York offering year-round outdoor recreation. It features Cockaigne Ski Resort, horseback riding trails, and campgrounds. The town has a lower crime risk than the national average.

    • Average Value

      $174K

    • List Price

      $56K - $718K

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      4 Listings

    Cherry Creek
  • /34

    Villenova

    Villenova, NY, is a rural town with rolling hills and farmland. Notable spots include Chainbiters disc golf and Canadaway Creek Wildlife Management Area. The town is safer than the national average.

    • Average Value

      $181K

    • List Price

      $95K - $511K

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      2 Listings

    Villenova
  • /38

    Ellington

    Ellington, NY is a rural town in Chautauqua County with a walkable center amid farms and forests. The town park hosts community events, while nearby Chautauqua Lake offers recreation. Crime risk is below the national average.

    • Average Value

      $176K

    • List Price

      $72K - $253K

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      3 Listings

    Ellington
  • Sunset Bay

    Sunset Bay

    • Average Value

      $297K

    • List Price

      $145K - $940K

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      3 Listings

    Sunset Bay