Tusten
Tusten offers a rural escape on the Delaware River in New York. Outdoor activities are popular, and Narrowsburgh has a small downtown. Residents enjoy spacious wooded properties, and kids attend Sullivan West Central schools.
Average Value
$500K
List Price
$260K - $1.6M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
14 Listings
Fremont
Fremont, NY, is a rural town of quiet hamlets near the Delaware River. Its landscape features woods, water, and winding roads, with hiking trails and a craft distillery. Housing includes farmhouses and lakeside cabins.
Average Value
$495K
List Price
$117K - $1.3M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
17 Listings
Forestburgh
Forestburgh offers a rural escape northwest of New York City, with homes on spacious lots. Most people work in Monticello or Port Jervis. Neversink Gorge is good for fishing and hiking, and Forestburgh Playhouse hosts live acts.
Average Value
$487K
List Price
$101K - $1.7M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
12 Listings
Rock Hill
With views of lakes and New York’s Catskill Mountains, the hamlet of Rock Hill is a scenic retreat from New York City. “It’s famous because it’s right off the exit,” says Alla Sienitsky, the principal broker with Resort Realty who’s sold homes in the area for over 27 years. “For people who live in the city, it’s literally an hour and a half, an
Average Value
$470K
List Price
$195K - $905K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
17 Listings
Bethel
Site of the Woodstock Festival, Bethel, is a rural town, 10 miles away from Monticello, New York, in the Catskill Mountains. The area is known for its art scene and abundance of outdoor recreation. “The beauty of Bethel is that it truly fits everyone,” says Elizabeth Bernitt, an associate broker with Century 21 Geba Realty. Bernitt has been
Average Value
$455K
List Price
$113K - $1.7M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
52 Listings
Callicoon Township Sullivan
Callicoon Township is a rural town near the Catskill Mountains in southeastern New York. Crystal Lake Wild Forest and the Delaware River offer water recreation, and the village of Jeffersonville has grocery stores and restaurants.
Average Value
$442K
List Price
$145K - $1.3M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
18 Listings
Delaware
Delaware is a rural New York community with peaceful forests, Delaware River access and thriving hamlets like Callicoon. Major highways lead to nearby towns, and local dining spots include Callicoon Brewing Company.
Average Value
$428K
List Price
$163K - $1.4M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
13 Listings
Lumberland
Lumberland offers peaceful living on the Delaware River. Port Jervis is 20 minutes away, and properties are wooded and private. Boating, hiking and whitewater rafting are popular. Kids attend the Eldred Central School District.
Average Value
$421K
List Price
$157K - $1.3M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
16 Listings
Highland
Highland, NY, in Sullivan County, features scenic countryside with lakes and ponds. Bordering the Delaware River, it attracts outdoor enthusiasts with charming hamlets, campgrounds, river rafting and restaurants in Barryville.
Average Value
$411K
List Price
$110K - $1.5M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
24 Listings
Cochecton
Cochecton, a rural town along the Delaware River in New York, is known for outdoor recreation. It has public boat launches, fishing spots and Lake Huntington. The area offers diverse housing styles, including many vacation homes.
Average Value
$410K
List Price
$69K - $1M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
10 Listings
Mamakating
Surrounded by state forests and preserved areas in New York’s Catskill Mountains, Mamakating offers a blend of outdoor adventure and country living that appeals to those seeking an escape from the city. “It’s really rural, but it’s still centrally located. You’re 20 or 25 minutes to Monticello and Middletown,” says Cheryl Wolfe, who’s sold homes
Average Value
$402K
List Price
$85K - $1.8M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
53 Listings
Rockland
The town of Rockland is known for fly fishing in the Willowemoc and Beaver Kill streams. Roscoe and Livingston Manor feature historic homes and local eateries, and Catskill Park has abundant hiking trails.
Average Value
$390K
List Price
$128K - $1.5M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
19 Listings
Neversink
Neversink’s history comes with a bit of irony. The Sullivan County town was originally located a couple of miles west until the state decided to flood that area to create Neversink Reservoir. The residents relocated to their current location, but Neversink's original land sank underwater. Today, Neversink is a Catskill Mountain town that combines
Average Value
$364K
List Price
$134K - $1.9M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
14 Listings
Fallsburg
Fallsburg has long been a vacation hub in New York’s Catskill Mountains, where people are drawn to the area’s natural beauty and proximity to New York City. Alla Sienitsky, the principal broker with Resort Realty who’s sold homes in the area for over 27 years, says that many people get confused when talking about Fallsburg. “It’s a variety of
Average Value
$356K
List Price
$125K - $1.7M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
42 Listings
Monticello
While many of the surrounding communities in New York’s Catskill Mountains have seen their vacation allure dim since the 1970s, Monticello’s attractions and a revitalized downtown area are attracting a new generation of vacationers and full-time residents. Monticello is the seat of Sullivan County and is the largest village in a mostly rural area,
Average Value
$351K
List Price
$160K - $6.6M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
37 Listings
Liberty
Once known as a vacation destination in New York’s Catskill Mountains, Liberty is now a quiet rural retreat with a mix of vacationers and full-time residents. “Liberty is sort of like the last frontier in Sullivan County,” says Alla Sienitsky, the principal broker with Resort Realty who’s sold homes in the area for over 27 years. “Past Liberty,
Average Value
$323K
List Price
$152K - $850K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
32 Listings
Copyright © 2026 CoStar Group
