Lafayette
Lafayette has rugged terrain with larger-lot homes. Attractions include Lafayette Mill Antiques Center and The Shoppes at Lafayette. The Paulinskill Valley Trail offers 27 miles for hiking and biking.
Average Value
$636K
List Price
$254K - $1.5M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
1 Listing
Frankford
Frankford, NJ provides rural living near Stokes State Forest and the Appalachian Trail. Ranch homes and colonials line country roads. Culver Lake offers fishing. The Sussex County Fairgrounds hosts events like Crawfish Fest.
Average Value
$567K
List Price
$202K - $2.3M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
17 Listings
Minisink
Minisink, NY, 65 miles from NYC, offers rural living with family farms and pastoral landscapes. Minisink Valley High is highly rated. Residents enjoy Wallkill River National Wildlife Refuge and local parks for outdoor activities.
Average Value
$545K
List Price
$191K - $1.2M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
11 Listings
Hardyston
Hardyston, Sussex County's gateway, offers diverse housing from lakeside ranches to modern homes. Crystal Springs Resort and Wallkill River Wildlife Refuge provide recreation. Routes 23 and 94 facilitate commutes to nearby cities.
Average Value
$496K
List Price
$263K - $997K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
36 Listings
Wantage
Wantage in Wantage has diverse housing, from 1940s homes to modern estates. High Point State Park offers lakes and trails. Route 23 hosts local businesses. The rural area has low traffic but requires a car for commuting.
Average Value
$482K
List Price
$283K - $1.6M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
31 Listings
Sandyston
Sandyston, a rural New Jersey township, features farmland and spacious homes. Stokes State Forest offers hiking and mountain views, while Hidden Acres Golf Course and the nearby Delaware Water Gap provide outdoor recreation.
Average Value
$424K
List Price
$244K - $1.3M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
15 Listings
Vernon
Vernon, in Vernon, offers rural living with Mountain Creek Resort for skiing and biking. The area features Highland Lakes communities, scenic trails, and popular events. Schools are well-regarded, including a B-rated high school.
Average Value
$406K
List Price
$142K - $772K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
125 Listings
Montague
Montague, New Jersey offers rural living near High Point State Park. The area features Holiday Lake and outdoor activities. Nearby towns provide shopping and dining. Port Jervis Train Station serves commuters.
Average Value
$394K
List Price
$118K - $660K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
27 Listings
Sussex
Located in a county of the same name, Sussex is one of New Jersey’s twenty-one “doughnut hole” boroughs — and not because its borders form almost a perfect octagon, though that can’t hurt. It’s earned the title because it’s an independent borough located completely within Wantage Township, forming a distinct stamp of denser single-family homes
Average Value
$354K
List Price
$230K - $486K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
4 Listings
Greenville Town
Average Value
$521K
List Price
$325K - $2.6M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
11 Listings
Copyright © 2025 CoStar Group
