18 Pine Island, NY Real Estate Listings

Sort by:
$374,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,184 Sqft
44 Gurda Lane, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale


$419,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,150 Sqft
18 Firehouse Lane, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale

Wow! NOW UNDER CONSTRUCTION. Still time to customize. Sun filled open floor plan with cathedral ceilings and pristine hardwood floors. Three bedroom, Three full baths. Wide welcoming foyer. Living room, dining room and eat in kitchen in true great room fashion. Granite counters, large island for gathering with friends and family. Master bedroom with two closets and full master bath. Huge bright and airy family room, laundry room, over sized garage. Deck. Central air. Construction starting soon. Third generation Orange County builder. Photos shown are of very similar home recently built by builder. Model Available. See MLS # 6074682

$299,900Est. Payment
2 Beds | 2 Baths | 972 Sqft
866 County Route 1, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale

Completely Renovated, Charming 2bd 2ba Cape on 13 acres in Bucolic Pine Island! The Floor Plan has been Reworked allowing for an Open Living Space on the Main Level. Refinished Original Hardwood Floors throughout. Brand New Kitchen and Breakfast Bar, including Custom Cabinets, Granite Counter-tops and Stainless Steel Appliances. Updated Full Bathroom, Formal Dining room and Living room w/ Fireplace complete the first floor. As you make your way Upstairs it will be hard to miss the Master Suite. The owners have added a Full Bathroom complete with a Double Vanity and Tiled Shower w/ Glass Doors. A Spacious Bedroom and Walk-in Closet complete the space. Other updates include New Windows, Updated Electric/Plumbing and Refinished Front Porch to name a few. Large Pole Barn on the property for storage.

$369,800Est. Payment
3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,736 Sqft
34 Kelly Lane, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale

BACK ON THE MARKET! Find yourself at home in this updated and spacious charmer. Situated on a private park-like lot, you will love to entertain in this beautifully updated eat-in country kitchen featuring a beautiful island with quartz countertop and new floor. Take in the beautiful views that this large living room with cathedral ceilings and wall of windows offers. Enjoy your private and spacious 1st floor master suite which is set off the living room. Upstairs there are 2 additional bedrooms, full bathroom and an office. You will love to enjoy your private backyard as you sit on the deck or around the fire pit. There is plenty of space to garden ... Close to hiking, fishing, skiing and many other outdoor activities ... this property offers privacy as well as proximity to Pine Island and Warwick.

$699,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,620 Sqft
60 Bierstine Lane, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale

Live and work! 24.5 acres of active farming. Single family split ranch with 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths. Primary bedroom with walk in closet and full bath, shower and soaking tub. Two bedroom and full bath on opposite side. Walking into foyer and mud room, which opens to open floor plan kitchen, living and dining rooms. Vaulted ceilings and many windows. Property has two greens houses, fully operational with electric and running water. Four car garage. Chicken coup. Labor quarters (in need of updating). Next to the house and across the road black dirt land.

$487,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,100 Sqft
15 Firehouse Lane, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale

Looking for new construction already completed? Elegantly designed and built by reputable and local builder. Custom finishes throughout this spacious 3 bdrm/2bath ranch with master bedroom suite on 1st floor. Full walk out basement with window and plumbing for additional bathroom (ready to finish). Easy to show home is completed and available for immediate occupancy

$280,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,520 Sqft
42 Stage Road, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale

Charming! Charming, Move right in to this lovely Cape Cod featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, Eat in Kitchen with Oak Cabinets, Dining room with French doors leading to the back patio with awning. Master Bedroom with balcony. Original plank floors on the second floor and Bamboo flooring throughout first floor. Covered Deck off of Kitchen. Dead End Street with plenty of privacy. Full basement with laundry room. Delightful vestibule with bay window.

$579,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,427 Sqft
59 Warwick Estates Drive, Warwick, NY 10969
House For Sale

Welcome home sweet home!! Under Construction. Photos depicted are of another finished home @ 39 Walling (UC) Here's another Warwick Ted & Mary's custom built homes! This couple spares no expense when building! A 5 acre mature, partially wooded property. This homes private setting naturally allows you to create your own tranquil space. Interior features: FIRST FLOOR MASTER BEDROOM, Open space kitchen design, granite counters, etc. The spacious great room with vaulted ceilings and stone accented wood burning fireplace offers scenic views to outdoor space. A FIRST FLOOR Master En-suite with tray ceilings, hardwood floors and walk in closet. A Master bath embodies everything long day needs: soak in your deep slipper tub, refresh with the dual vanity sinks while standing on comfortable heated floors. Second floor boasts two additional bedrooms with ample closet space separated by a gorgeous full bath with dual sinks, granite counters and tile floors, a fourth huge bedroom over garage.

$415,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,060 Sqft
846 County Route 1, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale

Welcome home in Warwick School District features beautiful kitchen and baths, master with jet tub... new lighting, flooring, a total renovation in 2020...all new stainless appliances with laundry on first level, recessed lighting... large front porch into an inviting two story foyer...sliding doors to deck overlooking level backyard ... huge full basement with workshop space and new cabinetry ... two car garage ... this home is conveniently located to most amenities such as parks, restaurants, orchards, wineries, hiking and skiing and much more

$349,999Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,866 Sqft
762 County Route 1, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale

LIVE MORE AND WORRY LESS in this unique and charming farm house! Featuring a brand new kitchen complete with granite and whirlpool stainless steel appliances (all new Oct. 2020)! First floor has also had a fresh coat of paint, BRAND new carpeting in the dining area & living room, as well as newly refinished hardwood floors! Owned solar panels power this gem and offer a significant savings in the utility bills. Newer boiler and roof too! All these upgrades don't change that cozy feeling you get in an early 1900 farmhouse set in bucolic Pine Island though! Outside, enjoy time on the large deck overlooking your very own lush 1.9 acre lot complete with 2 large barns & a shed! The barns are a hobby enthusiast dream come true and can be used for anything the heart desires- garage, brewing, agriculture, storage, and well you name it! Close to shops, restaurants, wineries, parks, breweries, and all that this historic area has to offer! Make your dreams a reality and come home to Pine Island!

$399,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,428 Sqft
20 Kay Road, Pine Island, NY 10969
House For Sale

Welcome to 20 Kay Road, a fully updated 4 bedroom, 2 1/2 bath home situated on a half acre corner lot. This lovely homes is located on a quiet street right across from Pine Island Park which has a newly renovated playground, running track, tennis courts, basketball court and softball field. Updates to this beautiful home include: open concept completely updated kitchen with gorgeous quartz countertops and stainless appliances open to dining and living rooms, 2 1/2 baths have all been tastefully updated, new hardwood floors on main level, new waterproof vinyl laminate floors on lower level, completely re-painted interior with a neutral pallet to suit any buyer's taste, new siding completes the exterior remodel. Showings will begin on Thursday Nov 12th.

$295,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,768 Sqft
22 Pulaski Highway, Pine Island, NY 10969
Multi Family For Sale

Two-Family Duplex in the heart of Pine Island. Large front porch. Exterior has Hardiplank front and the rest of exterior is stucco. Windows have been replaced in front of home. New metal roof on front porch section. Tenants pay all utilities. Separate electric meters and separate above ground oil tanks for each unit. Large backyard and off street parking. LOW TAXES, INCOME PRODUCING PROPERTY.

$159,000Est. Payment
26.7 Acres
Mission Land Road, Pine Island, NY 10969
Lots Land For Sale

Great Black Dirt, great for growing most crops. There is also a high output well for irrigation. The property is protected by a dike for that possible once in twenty year flood. It also comes with a 16 thousand gallon per minute PTO driven dike pump. The land is at the end of Mission Land Road on the right. You have to see the quality of this dirt! ADDITIONAL 11 ACRES, 1 ACRE POND, 8 ACRES BLACK DIRT AND TWO ACRES UPLAND LAND AVAILABLE ON NEARBY PARCEL FROM THE SAME OWNER, FOR $175K TO BUILD A WAREHOUSE! Owner is holding back from listing it because the pond is currently being built.

$135,000Est. Payment
86.9 Acres
County Hwy 88, Pine Island, NY 10969
Lots Land For Sale

Beautiful 86.9 acres of untouched land. Property borders the forever green Pochuk Mountain State forest, New Jersey border, as well as federally owned land with hiking trails that lead to the Appalachian Trail. Uses could include hunting, hiking, atv, timber value, sub-division or recreational use. Property is landlocked.

$645,000Est. Payment
86 Acres
327 Glenwood Road, Pine Island, NY 10969
Lots Land For Sale

Exceptional opportunity +/-86 acres, 6 contiguous lots, Black Dirt Farm. Former land and family farm of one of the most well know and respected farmers in the area. Lots include 10-1-14, 10-1-19, 10-1-20, 10-1-21, 10-1-22, 11-1-14.41. Parcels are on Glenwood Rd and Newport Bridge Rd.

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >