
5631 University Ave Indianapolis, IN 46219
Irvington NeighborhoodHighlights
- 0.32 Acre Lot
- Vaulted Ceiling
- Wood Flooring
- Family Room with Fireplace
- Gothic Architecture
- Covered patio or porch
About This Home
As of March 2021A rare opportunity to purchase the 1876 Johnson House, often referred to as the Irvington Castle! A masterpiece of design with 2 turrets, intricate brick design & dominant features guaranteed to steal your heart! Be a part of the home's rich history named after the founder of Irvington. With 6 fireplaces, 12ft ceilings, transom windows, French doors, original hardwood floors & a grand staircase, this striking Victorian Gothic home is simply captivating! The unique windows nearly reach the floor & flood the home with natural light. Access the inviting roof top views of the South Audubon Circle from the turret! Dual staircases, 3 generously sized bdrms, 2.5 baths & laundry rm that doubles as a home office complete this Irvington dream!
Last Agent to Sell the Property
F.C. Tucker Company License #RB14040767 Listed on: 02/17/2021

Last Buyer's Agent
Natalie Clayton
Maywright Property Co.
Home Details
Home Type
- Single Family
Est. Annual Taxes
- $3,522
Year Built
- Built in 1876
Lot Details
- 0.32 Acre Lot
- Partially Fenced Property
Parking
- 2 Car Detached Garage
- Gravel Driveway
Home Design
- Gothic Architecture
- Victorian Architecture
- Brick Exterior Construction
- Brick Foundation
Interior Spaces
- 2-Story Property
- Vaulted Ceiling
- Wood Frame Window
- Family Room with Fireplace
- 6 Fireplaces
- Formal Dining Room
- Den with Fireplace
- Wood Flooring
- Permanent Attic Stairs
- Fire and Smoke Detector
Kitchen
- Gas Oven
- Dishwasher
Bedrooms and Bathrooms
- 3 Bedrooms
Laundry
- Laundry on upper level
- Dryer
- Washer
Basement
- Basement Fills Entire Space Under The House
- Sump Pump
Outdoor Features
- Covered patio or porch
Utilities
- Forced Air Heating and Cooling System
- Heating System Uses Gas
- Gas Water Heater
Community Details
- Julian Johnson Rawles & Goodes Subdivision
Listing and Financial Details
- Assessor Parcel Number 491010178194000701
Ownership History
Purchase Details
Home Financials for this Owner
Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.Purchase Details
Home Financials for this Owner
Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.Similar Homes in Indianapolis, IN
Home Values in the Area
Average Home Value in this Area
Purchase History
Date | Type | Sale Price | Title Company |
---|---|---|---|
Warranty Deed | $397,500 | None Available | |
Deed | $325,000 | -- | |
Warranty Deed | $325,000 | First American Title |
Mortgage History
Date | Status | Loan Amount | Loan Type |
---|---|---|---|
Open | $357,750 | New Conventional | |
Previous Owner | $272,000 | New Conventional | |
Previous Owner | $292,500 | New Conventional |
Property History
Date | Event | Price | Change | Sq Ft Price |
---|---|---|---|---|
07/13/2025 07/13/25 | Pending | -- | -- | -- |
07/08/2025 07/08/25 | For Sale | $540,000 | +35.8% | $160 / Sq Ft |
03/30/2021 03/30/21 | Sold | $397,500 | +3.2% | $85 / Sq Ft |
02/20/2021 02/20/21 | Pending | -- | -- | -- |
02/17/2021 02/17/21 | For Sale | $385,000 | +18.5% | $82 / Sq Ft |
05/30/2018 05/30/18 | Sold | $325,000 | 0.0% | $69 / Sq Ft |
04/24/2018 04/24/18 | Pending | -- | -- | -- |
04/23/2018 04/23/18 | For Sale | $325,000 | -- | $69 / Sq Ft |
Tax History Compared to Growth
Tax History
Year | Tax Paid | Tax Assessment Tax Assessment Total Assessment is a certain percentage of the fair market value that is determined by local assessors to be the total taxable value of land and additions on the property. | Land | Improvement |
---|---|---|---|---|
2024 | $4,758 | $422,600 | $37,600 | $385,000 |
2023 | $4,758 | $384,500 | $37,600 | $346,900 |
2022 | $5,021 | $400,600 | $37,600 | $363,000 |
2021 | $4,361 | $359,000 | $37,600 | $321,400 |
2020 | $3,823 | $310,000 | $24,900 | $285,100 |
2019 | $3,667 | $291,600 | $24,900 | $266,700 |
2018 | $3,512 | $276,800 | $24,900 | $251,900 |
2017 | $2,926 | $258,700 | $24,900 | $233,800 |
2016 | $2,567 | $231,400 | $24,900 | $206,500 |
2014 | $2,269 | $208,000 | $24,900 | $183,100 |
2013 | $2,109 | $200,700 | $24,900 | $175,800 |
Agents Affiliated with this Home
-
Seller's Agent in 2025
Natalie Clayton
Maywright Property Co.
(317) 522-8727
30 in this area
269 Total Sales
-
Buyer's Agent in 2025
Kristin Glassburn
@properties
(317) 513-4251
2 in this area
225 Total Sales
-
Seller's Agent in 2021
Molly Hadley
F.C. Tucker Company
(317) 446-7656
58 in this area
452 Total Sales
-
Seller's Agent in 2018
Quinn Demaree
Everhart Studio, Ltd.
(317) 701-0479
190 Total Sales
-
C
Buyer's Agent in 2018
Chelsea Humble
United Real Estate Indpls
Map
Source: MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative®
MLS Number: MBR21765578

APN: 49-10-10-178-194.000-701
- 5511 E University Ave
- 324 E Burgess Ave
- 5715 Oak Ave
- 5905 Dewey Ave
- 5841 E Julian Ave
- 130 S Arlington Ave
- 376 S Arlington Ave
- 39 N Layman Ave
- 316 Ohmer Ave
- 48 S Arlington Ave
- 385 S Arlington Ave
- 22 N Bolton Ave
- 46 N Ritter Ave
- 319 S Webster Ave
- 367 S Butler Ave
- 310 S Butler Ave
- 330 S Butler Ave
- 38 N Irvington Ave
- 123 S Butler Ave
- 28 S Hawthorne Ln