Andrea Amico

7/17/25Danny Carberry

Google Review

We are beyond grateful to have worked with Andrea for the second time—and she truly went above and beyond once again. Relocating from out of state is never easy, but Andrea made the entire home-buying process seamless. She toured homes with us via FaceTime, had boots on the ground locally, and ultimately found us the perfect home that checked every single box.

Andrea is incredibly organized, responsive, and a fantastic communicator. She built great relationships with everyone involved—from inspectors to builders to lenders—and helped keep everything on track without a single hiccup. Her professionalism and attention to detail are unmatched.

More than just a realtor, Andrea has become a true friend. She’s helped us feel at home in Austin by sharing her favorite local spots—restaurants, gyms, shops—you name it. She made a typically stressful process feel smooth and even enjoyable.

If you’re looking for a realtor who is genuinely invested in helping you find not just a house, but a home, Andrea is the absolute best. We couldn’t recommend her more highly!

4/24/25Jenny Hoffman

Google Review

Andrea was a pleasure to work with from start to finish! She was thorough while researching homes, and patient with my husband and I as we compiled lists of properties to look at. I was most impressed with how responsive and available she was to answer questions, as well as how she worked around our schedule to go to viewings. She truly made relocating and closing on our home enjoyable. I would highly recommend her as a realtor to anyone who is relocating to the area (like we were), or moving within the city. She’s incredibly knowledgeable of Austin, flexible, professional, and an overall amazing person!

3/27/25Fiona Condon

Google Review

I’m not sure I’ll be allotted enough characters to articulate the sincere value Andrea brings to the table. In addition to being a sparking human being with immaculate attention to detail and an authentic personal touch that is unmatched — She was born for this business. She’s a motivated connector with detail-oriented precision in each and every step of the listing process. We developed such a strong relationship while working together because Andrea always communicated with as much care, attention, and expertise as possible whenever I needed her. She provided stellar referrals for the photography of my property as well as the movers I hired to move me into my new home after Andrea found me my dream tenant.

To say I’m grateful for Andrea would be a massive understatement. She helped me feel confident in my decision-making throughout the process of listing my property and has been such a sincere pleasure to work with. She’s brought me peace of mind and excitement to work with her again in the very near future. I’ve not only found a top notch Realtor but a true friend.

I have recommended her to countless family members and friends and will continue to shout her name from the rooftops! Andrea will make you feel seen, heard, valued, and confident in her ability to execute on your behalf. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for all your hard work and heart, Andrea! You are so appreciated!

9/3/24Jonathan Kaplan

Google Review

I recently sold my home in Austin with Andrea Amico of Compass Realty, and I couldn't be more pleased with the experience. Andrea is "on it". Her attention to detail and her positive attitude made the sales process much easier. We got a good outcome in a challenging market environment working with Andrea.

A few things that Andrea did well:
1. Excellent Communication: Andrea was always responsive and kept me well-informed throughout the process.
2. Strategic Marketing: Her approach was comprehensive and effective. From professional photography and videos to leveraging Compass Private Exclusive for pre-listing and holding well structured open houses for both agents and buyers, Andrea ensured my home was showcased in the best light possible.
3. Extensive Network: Andrea's connections within the Austin real estate community proved invaluable in finding the right buyer quickly.
4. Data-Driven Insights: Throughout the process, Andrea provided up-to-date local market data, enabling me to make informed decisions with confidence.

If you're looking for a dedicated and effective real estate agent in the Austin area, who is also a genuinely kind and good person, I highly recommend Andrea Amico.

8/27/24Katherine Carberry

Google Review

We have moved several times and Andrea is hands down the best real estate agent we’ve ever worked with. We were hesitant listing, and had a tight timeline so knew several things needed to line up. She rolled up her sleeves and helped expedite getting our house listed. Andrea’s experience and knowledge of the market helped us price right and to get the best exposure to receive an offer within weeks. She even put us in touch with agents in our new state that helped us find a house, emphasizing our timeline.

Andrea went out of her way to help answer questions and do research before, during and after the deal. Her communication was phenomenal as Andrea was a part of the process every step of the way, helping make our home sale smooth and stress-free.

7/15/24Heather Marie Lacey

Google Review

Andrea's knowledge, expertise and professionalism shone through during our experience working with her. She tailored her services to our individual needs and provided an incredibly personalized experience for us. From day one, she took her time to understand our timing and unique needs. She was encouraging and willing to listen every step of the way. Andrea's communication skills and responsiveness were remarkable. There was never a moment when we were waiting on her to be proactive or to respond to an email or a phone call. She was always organized and on top of every single detail. She provided support beyond just the transaction. She genuinely cares about you and your family. Andrea is not only an incredibly hard working, driven and reliable realtor, she is also the most beautiful individual inside and out. We are so grateful for her time and effort!

7/8/24B B

Google Review

We have moved a lot and worked with a lot of realtors. Andrea was my favorite since day one. Every time we met she came with a folder of info and was prepared for any question that I might have. I trusted her plan and everything worked out just like she said it would. Andrea went above and beyond to make things as easy as possible for me while I was out of town. She even made sure the house was doing ok and the grass was being cut so I didn’t have to. The house was sold for the full asking price and I made a very good friend at the same time. Thank You Andrea.

6/26/24mutsa tongoona

Google Review

If you are looking to move to Austin, Andrea is your agent! Her attention to detail and customer service compares to none! I highly recommend Andrea!

5/14/24Alice Kennon

Google Review

Andrea is amazing! She is thoughtful, professional and can quickly find you your dream house. An incredible and efficient experience.

10/24/23Kathryn Machuga

Google Review

Andrea went above and beyond for me in my search for a home in a specific neighborhood. When one transaction went awry (the sellers backed out) she went knocking on doors to see if anyone in the neighborhood was interested in selling. We found the perfect house which was a better fit than the first one! I highly recommend using Andrea as your agent.

5/30/23Gracian Mariathasan

Google Review

I had an excellent experience with Andrea when searching and purchasing my home in 2022. She is very knowledgeable, dedicated, and highly responsive. She was always available to answer any questions and worked around my unpredictable work schedule. I would highly recommend Andrea to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

-Gracian

5/16/23Jeanine Nosker

Google Review

My husband and I recently had the pleasure of working with Andrea Amico from Compass to sell our home during one of the most difficult real estate markets out there, and I cannot express enough how grateful we are for her exceptional services.

Throughout the entire process, Andrea demonstrated a remarkable level of dedication and commitment. All of our questions were responded to quickly and she kept us on task, ensuring we were never caught off guard with an upcoming deadline. Andrea was always available to address any concerns or provide guidance, making us feel confident and at ease during what was a very stressful time (Did I mention our move was cross country?)

Thanks to Andrea's guidance we were under contract within 72 hours and closed in less than 4 weeks (March-2023)

We wholeheartedly recommend Andrea to anyone in need of a reliable and results-driven realtor. Whether you are buying or selling a property, you can trust her expertise and rest assured that she will go the extra mile to exceed your expectations.

7/13/22Selina N

Google Review

Andrea made the stressful process of being a homeowner into one that was fun, exciting, and decidedly stress-less! From the moment I met her, I knew her bubbly and inquisitive personality would be so beneficial for me navigating all the ins and outs of tours, paperwork, contracts, and more.

She worked seamlessly to make sure I could tour based on my schedule and availability, answered all my questions in an extremely timely manner, took into account my preferences and styles perfectly, and communicated without my asking to the sellers, title companies, and everyone without missing a hitch.

To top it off, she made the very best personal gift to greet me at my signing appointment. Andrea is simply the best, and I wouldn't have wanted to have anyone else at my side during this process. 10000% recommend. I couldn't sing higher praises!

5/9/22Mckenzi Hilton

Google Review

Andrea worked hard to get us into our dream property which included working through multiple unique scenarios and a more difficult seller. She navigated each situation well and I always felt incredibly confident that she had our best interest at heart. Definitely using her again!

4/19/22Ryan Vanderlip

Google Review

We are just over a month into homeownership and I can't thank Andrea enough for helping us get here. She was extremely responsive and accommodating throughout our search for a home in Austin. Her tenacity was invaluable in negotiating our closing date and managing communication between us, the builder (seller), and our lender. But I'm most grateful for the trust I was able to place in Andrea that she was looking out for us each step of the way.

4/13/22Jesse Lokken

Google Review

Andrea is one of a kind. Her kindness, compassion, and intelligence set here apart from all other agents. Being a mortgage lender for two decades now; it is refreshing to know that there are quality people like her in this real estate world.
Keep rocking Andrea, and I look forward to working with you.

11/11/21Brian Boles

Google Review

Andrea did a fantastic job finding us an amazing house in Austin when we moved here from NYC. We had to do our search remotely and she made the process as easy as possible. We couldn't possibly have been happier with the entire experience.

9/4/21Roxana Donegan

Google Review

We had a wonderful experience with Andrea. She helped me paint my fence!
Andrea is kind, responsive, proactive and caring. She went above and beyond for us! Highly recommend you hire Andrea as your realtor.

6/21/21Joanie Cahill

Google Review

If you are looking for a Realtor who will take the stress out of your home buying or selling experience, and add confident expertise you've found it in Andrea Amico. She found my first home for me, and I'm so pleased and satisfied with all the hard work she put in. She was always highly prepared, available, and proactive. She anticipated every question and need before I even knew I needed it. Truly above and beyond. She made this experience joyful, smooth, and painless. Would give her 10 stars if I could. Highly recommend.

5/28/21Serena McCabe

Google Review

It's official! We are homeowners in ATX. We had the BEST experience with Andrea Amico. We couldn't have done it without her. She went above and beyond many times over and even though the housing market is incredibly competitive here, her tenacity and commitment got us the house. Plus, we had a blast working with her.

Serena McCabe, Buyer