Sara Colby

4/21/22Raylene York

Google Review

Sara did a great job selling our house! She has the knowledge and expertise to not only sell our house quickly, but to do so navigating through issues found on inspection and all while we were out of state. She kept in good communication with us during the process..

4/13/22Heather Carrasco

Google Review

Sara took away all fears of both selling our first home and buying our second home. It can be overwhelming trying to understand the process but Sara was patient and explained everything, giving us peace of mind. She didn't rush us to make a move on a home, she let us set the pace for how quickly we would move. Her experience in selling real estate and also in home renovation were a huge asset in looking at homes. We have recommended her many times over and will continue to do so.

4/8/22Jody Snellbaker

Google Review

4/6/22Tiffany Snellbaker

Google Review

Sara is the absolute best! She is sincere, honest, and hard-working. She is great at communicating and keeping her clients updated throughout the entire buying/selling process. Sara takes the time to listen and advocate for her clients and is genuinely interested in them. Sara is so pleasant to work with and will quickly become a trusted friend to walk with you through the daunting process of buying and selling your home.

4/6/22shaymaa ahmed

Google Review

Sara is an exceptional agent! She is very knowledgable, friendly and truly care about my family and our needs. No matter what time of day or night it was, if I had a question Sara would respond. provided excellent customer service! Very attentive and responsive to client's needs and concerns. She is available day and night! Highly recommend Sara and Hostetter realty.

4/5/22Maggie S

Google Review

Sara is the very best realtor my husband and I have ever worked with. We bought our dream home in 2020 and feel truly blessed that she was there every step of the way to make it all happen. She has a warm heart and is there anytime to answer questions throughout the buying experience. She made what is often a very stressful process into an extremely easy and pain-free time, even in the midst of the pandemic. We can’t thank her enough!

4/5/22Jessie Sargent

Google Review

Sara was such a great help in our search! She is professional and really gets you what you want!!

4/5/22Desiree Stoltzfus

Google Review

Sara has been a great asset to us in our search for properties and she went above and beyond to make our last real estate transaction go smoothly. Thank you Sara!

3/1/22Cesar Mares

Google Review

First time home buyer’s. Sarah was amazing! Super knowledgeable, always able to answer my questions. Extremely helpful and so sweet. Really made the process smooth for us.

2/25/22Andrew Lockman

Google Review

You won't find anyone who will work harder for you! Sara doesn't pressure you into anything! She will tirelessly work to make sure your needs are met. Check her out, you won't regret it!

2/25/22Greg Lapp

Google Review

Sara is awesome! I would absolutely recommend her to anyone buying or selling a home.

2/24/22Kevin Hershey

Google Review

Sara is a fantastic realtor and I would highly recommend her. Not only is she exceptionally competent at what she does, she provides very personal service, which is a big help in finding the right home.

2/24/22Anton Oberg

Google Review

Sara was tremendous to work with when we bought our house. She put effort into finding the best fit for us, she was patient when we looked at multiple properties, she negotiated a good deal with the seller, and she even helped us out in practical ways when we moved in. We could not have asked for a better agent!

2/23/22Scott Gray

Google Review

Sara is a professional who takes time to understand her client’s needs. She is quick to respond to texts and phone calls and is very knowledgeable with buying and selling houses. Highly recommend!

2/22/22Maria Gray

Google Review

2/21/22Kendal Olear

Google Review

Cannot recommend Sara enough!

2/21/22mike mcdowell

Google Review

Sara Colby is the best realtor! We were first time home buyers and thanks to Sara, we were able to find the perfect home for us. Sara was so incredibly helpful and supportive through the process. We would recommend no one other than her, especially for first time buyers. We cannot thank her enough and would give her more than 5 stars if possible!

2/21/22Lisy Figueroa

Google Review

I highly recommend Sara! Being a realtor for her is much more than a paycheck! She is honest, genuine, reliable, knowledgeable and truly has a generous heart. She goes above and beyond for her clients. I admire the fact that the relationship doesn't end after closing either, she builds friendship, and is always just a call, text or email away willing to answer any questions or offer different resources to help out!

2/19/22Leah Weaver

Google Review

Sara is a fantastic realtor who always goes the extra mile for her clients.

2/19/22Joy Stoltzfus

Google Review

2/19/22Wilmer Martin

Google Review

2/19/22Rosee Warner

Google Review

Sara is a Godsend! We sold our home in less than 24 hours, thanks to her. She’s extremely knowledgeable and took so much time with us answering our many questions. Her sensitivity to our schedules and specific requests were stellar. Her constant encouragement and patience even during times of uncertainty helped set our minds at ease. She spent time with us just to pray, which absolutely meant the world. We highly recommend her to anyone needing to buy or sell their home. You will not be disappointed! She is a true blessing!

2/18/22Leann Ryder

Google Review

Sara was such a blessing to work with. So patient, encouraging and knowledgeable. Even though we weren’t her only client, we felt as though we were. If we ever need to sell and move again, she would be our first pick as a realtor in a heartbeat.

2/18/22Sherri Savage

Google Review

Sara goes above and beyond for her clients. We bought our house 11 years ago. There was a few things we needed to do and she walked us through it. She is so patient. She truly does have your best interest in mind. If we ever sold she would be our go to. Each year on the anniversary of the sale she sends a little reminder! Thank you…Sara.

2/18/22Heather Kehlor

Google Review

Sara is an amazing realtor and I would recommend her to anyone looking to sell or buy a home. She goes above and beyond making the whole process seamless. She is extremely personable, helpful and knowledgeable. I wouldn’t trust anyone else. Sara is the best.

2/18/22jon kramer

Google Review

Sara is the absolute best!!! Words that describe her are - Attentive, aware, responsive, respectful, diligent and above all, trustworthy- all things you need in a realtor.

2/18/22Beth Hallett

Google Review

Sara is a great realtor who takes very good care of her clients !

2/18/22Brittany Shore

Google Review

2/18/22Leighann Walsh

Google Review

Sara’s care and concern for each of her clients makes her so valuable in such a stressful process.

Her expertise and professionalism make her a great resource for any looking to buy or sell a home!

I would definitely recommend Sara!

2/18/22Johnathan & Jacinda Davenport

Google Review

Sara has walked through buying 2 houses with us and sold 1. I wouldn't dare consider using anyone else.

2/14/22Beth Boll

Google Review

I would highly recommend Sara Colby to help with any realtor needs you might have. She walked our family through every step of the realty process, making us confident as we bought our home. I always recommend Sara when anyone asks for a knowledgeable, experienced realtor!

2/12/22gina martin

Google Review

Sara is an exceptional realtor who cares for all the needs of her clients. She was amazing in the sale of my aunt’s home and helped us with every last detail.

2/12/22Colby Doug

Google Review

2/12/22Sue Mercer

Google Review

Sara Colby is a very caring, considerate and loyal realtor that will help you sell your home or find the right house for you! I have watched her work endless hours to meet the needs of her clients! You can't go wrong with Sara!