$451,843Average Value$244Average Price per Sq Ft18Homes For Sale
Coastal-living along the East River
Mathews is as far east you can go along the aptly named East River before encountering the Chesapeake Bay. It’s one of the many peninsulas jutting away from Gloucester, but it’s unique in two ways: first, it has Gwynn Island hovering around the north end, and second, New Point Comfort Lighthouse sits on the southern tip, near a nature preserve. Without a doubt, this is a coastal community with a secluded rural aspect, dotted with outdoor recreation opportunities. “There’s lots of acreage, but keep in mind that the tradeoff is you’ll have to drive to reach what’s considered a common amenity nowadays,” says David Tortolini, a Realtor with eXp Realty. “You’re not going to wake up and just dip over to Starbucks.”
Mathews also offers quiet neighborhoods along the water edges for residents.
Signage with written local history can be found along the downtown streets of Mathews.
1/2
Cast a line or collect seashells at Haven Beach
Two beaches on the east end attract a lot of attention. Haven Beach, as the name suggests, is a quiet place. There aren’t many big waves. Visitors show up to fish, collect shells and swim. The drive there is also part of the experience, with beach grasses that exceed the height of approaching cars. Bethel Beach is considered more of a scenic spot: locals prefer to watch the sunset here or listen to the lapping waves, rather than swim. The Bethel Beach Natural Preserve is attached, which also brings out birding enthusiasts. Another destination frequented by wildlife enthusiasts is the New Point Comfort Natural Area Preserve, which is in the path of migratory birds.
Relax at Haven Beach within the Mathews community.
It's not hard to find Gwynn's Island homes that flow along the Chesapeake Bay beaches.
1/2
Traditional Colonials, Cape Cods and coastal cottages
Home prices range from the $300,000s up to $700,000. Colonial styles are prominent here, owing to the historic atmosphere pervading Mathews. It’s not uncommon to have multiple acres of land as part of the lot. Beachfront homes are frequently seen as well, given the amount of coastline in Mathews. These may have hints of Cape Cod style or pops of bold color like turquoise. Some outlying properties do reach into the million-dollar range, for those who want more of an estate lifestyle. It’s common for historic properties from the late 19th century to be the spotlight of such properties.
Mathews beach offers unique coastal homes varying in color.
Cape Cod architecture drapes a lot of the Mathews landscape.
1/2
Live music and local food at Gwynn's Island Festival
One of the most popular events of the year happens the last weekend of June: the Gwynn's Island Festival. As a free admission event, people of all ages come out to eat local food, enjoy live music and buy arts and crafts. In early December, the Mathews Historical Museum hosts the annual Christmas Bazaar, where local artisans are on hand to discuss their wares.
Local eateries and grocery shopping at nearby Food Lion
Richardson’s Café in downtown Mathews is a community anchor. The décor inside presents an old school diner, complete with booths and a lunch counter. Sandwiches, burgers and seafood fill out the menu. Most residents grab their groceries nearby at Food Lion. For a fun shopping experience, Etc. Vintage on Buckley Road is a prime place to pick through gems of yesteryear.
Downtown Mathews provides opportunities to pick up groceries at Food Lion.
Visit Etc. Vintage on Buckley Hall Road for cute vintage finds within the community.
1/2
Education at Mathews County Public Schools
Mathews Elementary has a 10-to-1 student-teacher ratio and serves over 300 students. Thomas Hunter Middle has a 12-to-1 student-teacher ratio, and receives a B from Niche in the diversity category. Mathews High has a 10-to-1 student-teacher ratio, and earns a B-minus in academics. Students report being satisfied with the school’s well-organized extracurricular clubs, like the Future Business Leaders of America.
Mathews Elementary has over 300 students in grades PK and K-4.
Thomas Hunter Middle School has over 200 students in grades 5-8.
Mathews High School scores an overall grade of B- from Niche.
1/3
Transportation around Mathews
Mathews is too remote and spread out for public buses, so it’s essential to have a car here. Route 14 is the closest road that could be considered a major thoroughfare: it runs along the west end, into downtown Mathews where residents can access commercial amenities.
Photography Contributed By
Michael Bell
Video By
Daniel Willingham
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Beth Autery,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Mathews, VA sell after 132 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Mathews, VA over the last 12 months is $332,975, down 32% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
This Unique Waterfront property has a renovated Farmhouse Style 4 Bedroom Main Home plus a Waterfront Guest Home on over Three 3.41 +/- Private Acres. This property features beautiful water views on 3 sides with 475' of shoreline, a deep water pier and boat lift w/quick access to the East River. Great fishing and crabbing. Gazebo, 2 Waterside Patios, and fire pit. The home features lovely
Discover serene waterfront living at its finest in this beautifully maintained 4BR, 3BA ranch home. Nestled along the peaceful Stutts creek w/water views from multiple rooms, this single-level gem offers effortless one-level living and an inviting open-concept floor plan perfect for everyday comfort & effortless entertaining. Step inside to expansive living spaces bathed in natural light, where
Welcome to this stunning new construction home by Harbin Builders. This subdivision features beautifully designed homes and expansive common areas perfect for families and outdoor enjoyment. This beautiful 3BR, 2BA residence offers 1972 sqft of thoughtfully designed living space. As soon as you step inside, you will appreciate the bright, open concept floor plan that seamlessly connects the
Welcome to this beautiful new construction home offering 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and the perfect blend of modern comfort and small-town charm in the heart of Mathews. Enjoy peaceful country living from the inviting front porch before stepping inside to an open, light-filled floor plan designed for everyday living and entertaining. The spacious kitchen features an air fryer stove, abundant
Tanager 2031 Tract Overview The Tanager 2031 tract is a significant property encompassing 2,120 acres in Mathews County, situated approximately 6.5 miles north of Gloucester. This expansive tract features about 3,000 feet of frontage along John Clayton Memorial Highway (Route 14), 3,100 feet on Windsor Road (Route 3), and 600 feet on Ridge Road. Additional access is available from Vaux Hall Road
Two parcels consisting of 5.64 acres. Beautiful, paved drive awaiting your new home. Marina, boat ramp and beach within minutes of property. Mathews County has made the top small towns to visit, retire or own a second home in this beautiful town. Soil study completed at one time for 3-5 BR home. Call for private showing. Water access to public sand beach at Haven Beach. A little Marsh may come
Spacious bright home on Morris Creek - just minutes to Mathews Yacht Club, Hole in the Wall and the best of the Chesapeake Bay! Open concept floor plan with direct access to the waterside deck and yard. Expansive first floor 2 room addition with full bath that can be primary suite, family room, office, etc. Kitchen has custom glass front cabinetry, SS appliances, granite counters, second prep
Welcome to this lovely cape that has been beautifully maintained and updated. All major items replaced in the last 5 yrs to include the roof, HVAC, hot water heater, plumbing, kitchen, baths, flooring, electrical...the list goes on. Sit on the back screened porch and enjoy watching nature in the large back yard. The fire pit and the 2-car detached garage offer add'l options to really create an
Two parcels consisting of 5.64 acres. Beautiful, paved drive awaiting your new home. Marina, boat ramp and beach within minutes of property. Mathews County has made the top small towns to visit, retire or own a second home in this beautiful town. Soil study completed at one time for 3-5 BR home. Call for private showing. Water access to public sand beach at Haven Beach. A little Marsh may come
Situated back off the road on Salem Church Road this lot the Owner says has a right of way. We do not have a plat. We have no perk site or septic info. Buyer must Acquire. Owner selling lot AS IS. We have a county tax map. You will have to obtain your own well permit and drill your own well. Electric must be obtained but electric is at the state highway at end of your right of way to this lot.
This Unique Waterfront property has a renovated Farmhouse Style 4 Bedroom Main Home plus a Waterfront Guest Home on over Three 3.41 +/- Private Acres. This property features beautiful water views on 3 sides with 475' of shoreline, a deep water pier and boat lift w/quick access to the East River. Great fishing and crabbing. Gazebo, 2 Waterside Patios, and fire pit. The home features lovely
Don't miss this one, if you love the water & nature check this out. Whole house renovated, move-in ready. Need a place for horses, this is it, NEW Barn, +/- 7 ac fenced pasture, HUGE workshop, conditioned & running H20. This vintage home has it all, YB 1870 w/modern day amenities. Original Heart Pine floors in original footprint, HW, Ceramic or Laminate in remainder. ALL wood floors newly
Prime location for 24 acres just outside of Mathews proper, just a short walk to restaurants and shops. Has 95 feet of road frontage on Buckley Hall Rd and has separate ingress and egress options. Zoned Residential for single family or residential development but also has commercial development possibilities. 4 parcels make up the 24 acres, 26A2-7-2, 26A2-8-38, 26A2-8-5, 26A2-7-1D.
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
