Ellicottville
Ellicottville, NY transforms from a small town into a bustling ski destination with Holiday Valley and HoliMont resorts. The charming downtown has local eateries, while year-round outdoor activities keep residents engaged.
Average Value
$482K
List Price
$60K - $1.1M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
82 Listings
Great Valley
When people think of Cattaraugus County, they often think of busy ski resorts, state parks and the rolling hills of the Enchanted Mountains. Great Valley is a small community among the hills that keeps residents close to all the action. “For the most part, it’s a 5-to-10-minute drive to Ellicottville, which is home to two ski resorts,” says Tina
Average Value
$279K
List Price
$55K - $927K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
14 Listings
Machias
Machias caters to two distinct populations: seasonal vacationers and a steady group of year-rounders. The population of about 500 increases in summer, when New Yorkers from big cities like Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse come to quiet Cattaraugus County. The county and overall region are full of lakes, ski resorts and space for homebuyers to get
Average Value
$251K
List Price
$52K - $438K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
6 Listings
Ashford
The rural community of Ashford, located in the center of New York's Cattaraugus County, offers quiet living close to nature. The Appalachian Plateau’s hilly terrain provides a scenic backdrop for the area, as elevation changes and forested pockets provide space between properties. The town also attracts homebuyers for its comparatively lower
Average Value
$250K
List Price
$68K - $416K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
4 Listings
East Otto
Set in the rolling hills of Cattaraugus County, East Otto is a small community with farmland and direct routes to the vacation destination of Ellicottville. Most residents have lived in the area for years, and they take the time to catch up when they see one another. Mary Dankert owns the East Otto Trash & Treasures store on Main Street, and she
Average Value
$241K
List Price
$51K - $1.3M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
3 Listings
Yorkshire
Along the northern edge of Cattauragus County, Yorkshire offers homes on large lots and short commutes to busier cities and outdoor destinations. “If you’re looking for rural and affordable housing with a small-town feeling, it’s a good option,” says Melissa Frank, broker and owner of Metro Kirsch Real Estate, who has been in real estate since
Average Value
$224K
List Price
$38K - $823K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
3 Listings
Allegany Town
Allegany Township provides homebuyers looking in Cattaraugus County with proximity to shopping hubs and major highways. Allegany Village and the St. Bonaventure hamlet have more of a suburban feel close to the community's shops and restaurants, while homes on the outskirts offer quiet and spacious rural living. Regis Handley, a licensed real
Average Value
$221K
List Price
$48K - $420K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
13 Listings
Otto
The town of Otto is a small farming community tucked into the rolling hills of northern Cattaraugus County. Some farms, like Boyd Family Ranch, run Airbnbs that tourists stay in before heading to Niagara Falls or down to ski resorts in nearby Ellicottville. Mary Dankert is an Otto resident and local business owner who has lived in the area for
Average Value
$217K
List Price
$74K - $325K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
Freedom
Long two-lane roads and working farms that stretch over gently rolling hills fill the town of Freedom. This Cattaraugus County area is just south of Arcade, where residents go for restaurants and shops, but Freedom has its own experiences like getting breakfast at Moore’s Maple Shack and Pancake House and fall trips to Bliss Family Farm. Freedom
Average Value
$217K
List Price
$50K - $431K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
Farmersville
Farmersville has been a rural part of Cattaraugus County since the town was founded in the early 1800s. Early residents were dairy farmers, and while farming is still a part of life here, Farmersville has turned into a quiet area to live close to state forests and away from noisy neighbors. “Farmersville is very rural,” says Travis Thurston, an
Average Value
$213K
List Price
$77K - $297K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
1 Listing
Perrysburg
With its rural surroundings and sprawling forestland, Perrysburg offers small-town living at the fringe of western New York. It’s home to around 1,500 residents, a few restaurants, two churches and quiet residential streets that extend out into the countryside. It’s about 4 miles from the slightly larger town of Gowanda, and 35 miles south of
Average Value
$203K
List Price
$34K - $465K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
0 Listings
Portville
Portville's name dates to the early 19th century, when it was a bustling lumber port on the Allegheny River. Today, it offers small-town living in the rolling foothills and forests of the Allegheny Highlands, surrounded by outdoor recreation and bucolic scenery. Residents enjoy views of low mountains, sprawling woodlands and winding creeks and
Average Value
$177K
List Price
$92K - $349K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
7 Listings
Conewango
Conewango, home to the oldest and largest Amish settlement in New York, provides rural living and proximity to the outdoors. Located in Cattaraugus County, the town gets its name from the local Native American tribe’s word for “walking slowly.” Most of the town consists of farmland and forest pockets on the rolling hills created by the Allegheny
Average Value
$174K
List Price
$35K - $379K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
1 Listing
Little Valley
Like many other towns in Cattaraugus County, Little Valley hosts a mix of permanent residents and seasonal vacationers traveling from nearby cities. Ellicottville is nearby, with a ski resort and other attractions, so some vacationers spill over into Little Valley, buying winter and summer homes. “There are more people living here full time,” says
Average Value
$173K
List Price
$71K - $581K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
4 Listings
Coldspring
Situated in what’s known as the “Enchanted Mountains of Western New York,” Coldspring is a rural town in Cattaraugus County that offers homebuyers more space and convenient access to New York’s largest state park. Established in 1837, the town has primarily been an agricultural community. Coldspring is split in half by the Allegheny River. The
Average Value
$171K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
1 Listing
Randolph
With country lanes surrounded by the rolling hills of the Allegheny Highlands, Randolph offers small-town living with easy access to the outdoors. The town is in the furthest reaches of western New York, about 60 miles south of Buffalo and just a short drive from Allegany State Park. It’s home to about 2,500 residents, older homes, farm properties
Average Value
$170K
List Price
$50K - $405K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
6 Listings
Franklinville
Rolling state forests, quiet streets with neighbors spread out and direct routes to larger cities define Franklinville, a slow-moving town in Western New York’s Cattaraugus County. Outdoor explorers and nature lovers often find their home in Franklinville for the scenery and access to recreation. People might join the local hunting club or spend
Average Value
$167K
List Price
$32K - $332K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
9 Listings
New Albion
New Albion is a rural community of around 2,000 residents situated in the rolling hills and forests of western New York. Residents enjoy small-town living in a remote, wooded landscape, about 50 miles from the nearest major city. New Albion encompasses the hamlet of New Albion as well as the community of Cattaraugus, known for its historic
Average Value
$163K
List Price
$64K - $322K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
3 Listings
Hinsdale
Hinsdale’s main claim to fame is its haunted house. The Haunted Hinsdale House, or Dandy House, is said to be a hotspot for paranormal activity, making it a popular destination for ghost hunters. Otherwise, rural Hinsdale is mostly quiet hills and a small strip of buildings along Main Street, featuring the volunteer fire department, a post office
Average Value
$161K
List Price
$31K - $370K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
8 Listings
Dayton
In Dayton, forest and farmland make way for comparatively lower-priced homes that provide quiet, rural living. Part of Cattaraugus County, also known as the Enchanted Mountains of Western New York, the town sits on the hilly terrain created by the base of the Allegheny Mountains. Movie buffs might recognize the town’s scenic backdrop from the 1987
Average Value
$150K
List Price
$52K - $390K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
3 Listings
Carrollton
Carrollton, located on the southern edge of New York's Cattaraugus County, is a quiet rural town with a strategic position near the Pennsylvania state line. Its access to major highways makes it a convenient home base for cross-state workers. “It’s between Pennsylvania and New York, so you have a lot of people around here commuting for work to
Average Value
$144K
List Price
$62K - $290K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
0 Listings
Olean
Olean, NY, sits on the Alleghany River with historic homes and parks. It hosts St. Bonaventure University and Cutco. Southern Tier Catholic School is highly rated. The nearby Ellicottville ski resort hosts festivals year-round.
Average Value
$138K
List Price
$32K - $350K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
38 Listings
Salamanca
Salamanca is a mountain town tucked away along the Allegheny River in western New York. Set amid the rolling foothills of the Allegheny Highlands, its residents enjoy small-town living, plenty of outdoor recreation and enough shopping and dining to save a trip to Olean. The city is within the Allegany Indian Reservation, which is part of the
Average Value
$129K
List Price
$40K - $700K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
6 Listings
Copyright © 2026 CoStar Group
