Cindy Rein

8/31/25Larry Lefkowicz

Google Review

My wife and I worked with Cindy on selling our small farm in Sedalia Colorado. In spite of a very difficult real estate market, especially for properties with land, Cindy was able to sell the property at a great price considering the market. She was able to negotiate a much better price compared to the listing price than any properties have gone for in the last six months.
Cindy has an amazing wealth of knowledge on selling landed properties. Very good at communicating the ins and outs and advising us on how to proceed with our property. Helped us with some minor fix up things that had to be done on the house and was able to refer great contractors.
Cindy has a great heart for her Clients and we would highly recommend her as your agent.

2/12/25Reece Hall

Google Review

I had a wonderful experience with Cindy as my realtor! She worked with multiple contractors on my behalf for the repairs that were necessary to get the property up to the best selling price. Communication was a priority for Cindy, as she kept me in the loop through the repairs, showings and negotiation. Finally, she was able to beat my requested 'sell by' date by a couple months. I will be reaching out when I am in the market to buy in the future!

8/19/24Nymphing LLC.

Google Review

Working with Cindy been the easiest and most pleasant experience possible. On multiple occasions she has helped in both the selling of our home as well as finding a new one. She is an expert at what she does and I couldn’t speak any more highly of her.

8/18/24Angie Cromwell

Google Review

Cindy is so amazing. She’s been helping my family with real estate for years. Very knowledgeable on all different kinds of properties and will guide you through the entire process whether you’re buying or selling.

8/18/24John Hoefle

Google Review

Cindy is helping me by a fishing cabin in Colorado, 2000 miles away from my primary residence in NH. She continues to go above and beyond my expectations! Thank you Cindy. You're are the best!

6/26/24Taylor Olson

Google Review

Cindy is hands down the best real estate agent we have ever worked with. She has been so helpful in answering our questions and working to make sure we have felt comfortable with everything through the process of buying a home. She also has the best recommendations for everything else (lenders, inspectors and more). We have and will continue to recommend Cindy to everyone we know.

6/5/24Meryl Billy

Google Review

Rachel was amazing to work with!! She has so much knowledge of the Castle Rock and surrounding area. She is extremely resilient, and over came a situation that was out of our hands with professionalism, creativity, and tenacity!! Last but not least a free moving truck, well equipped and super nice. Thank you Sherlock Homes!

6/3/24D K

Google Review

Cindy was fantastic. She understood what I wanted and then allowed refinements in the search request once budgets were figured out.

5/22/24Chuck Thomas

Google Review

We had a great experience with Cindy as our realtor. She was responsive and knowledgeable. Buying a house is stressful, but she was great at letting us know that we were not alone and what we were experiencing was normal and all would be OK. She was professional and she had a good team helping her.
Would highly recommend her. She really knows her business.

5/2/24Angie Ramirez

Google Review

Cindy Sherlock Homes, exceeds All of our expectations and more in buying and selling our home. We have been her client for more the 9 years and each time she has provided us outstanding real estate services. From the start to finish. Amazing, professional and extremely knowledgeable in negotiations closing with our interest in mind.

4/29/24Jeff McAlister

Google Review

4/17/24deb johnson

Google Review

Cindy is so knowledgeable and gets answers to questions efficiently and professionally.
I’ll never use any other realtor.

3/22/24Alyssa Smith

Google Review

We had a great experience finding our first home with Cindy. She is extremely patient, kind, supportive and knowledgeable. She helped us narrow down what we were really wanting in a home and offered great advice. Being first time home buyers, she made sure we understood everything throughout the whole process and went above and beyond to address all of our questions and concerns. 1000% recommend working with Cindy.

3/10/24Suzanne Mencer

Google Review

We have had a great experience with Sherlock Homes! Cindy did a terrific job marketing our home and answered all of our questions every step of the way. She provided timely feedback from all of our showings and helped us navigate the tricky real estate market. She found the perfect buyer and has been very helpful through the entire process. We would highly recommend Cindy and Sherlock Homes!

2/28/24Cassi Weatherly

Google Review

I recently had the pleasure of working with Cindy both to sell and buy a home and I cannot express enough how outstanding my experience was. From start to finish, Cindy demonstrated a level of professionalism, expertise, and dedication that exceeded all my expectations.

Cindy was not just a real estate agent; she was a true advocate throughout the entire process. Her responsiveness and communication skills are exceptional, she kept me informed at every stage, and promptly addressed any concerns or questions I had. I always felt like a top priority.

Cindy demonstrated a keen ability to handle complex negotiations. Both the purchase and sale presented unique challenges, all of which Cindy was able to navigate.

Sherlock Homes is uniquely situated to provide any service needed for the home buying or selling process. She was able to arrange for and provide repairs and cleaning on my sale home, and being able to use the company moving truck was so convenient and cost-saving.

I wholeheartedly recommend Sherlock Homes to anyone in search of a top-tier real estate professional. Their commitment to excellence, combined with their unwavering dedication to client satisfaction, sets them apart in the industry. If you want a realtor who goes above and beyond, Cindy is the one to trust with your real estate needs. Five stars is not nearly enough to convey my gratitude and satisfaction!

2/25/24Nathan Meyers

Google Review

Cindy and her team are wonderful to work with. She is so knowledgeable about the market and rural property. She constantly goes above and beyond. She is truly an advocate for you through the whole process.

10/7/23J Bee

Google Review

Cindy did a fabulous job helping us sell our ranch property! We have worked with many agents buying and selling over the years, and she is the best of the best. She has a deep understanding of the real estate market and has the skills, patience and energy as well as extensive experience and industry knowledge needed to navigate all the challenges that arose. She is also an excellent negotiator. She looked out for our interests first, not herself, and gave us excellent advice, even before we hired her!
On top of that, she has extensive contacts to help in any way needed for buying or selling, which helped us in major ways.
She is truly amazing. If you are thinking of buying or selling, call her first even if only to get advice.

2/24/23Daryl Solis

Google Review

As a first-time home buyer I had done some research beforehand but was really grateful for Cindy Rein. The process went smoothly. She was very knowledgeable about the process and was a great resource. She offered her opinion when I asked and helped me to consider things I hadn’t thought of. I’ll definitely reach out to Sherlock Homes in the future!

2/23/23Rebeca Guillen

Google Review

Amazing job! I was looking for a house as a first time homebuyer and Cindy made that so much easier. She answered any question I had and helped me find a good house. She was very honest about what each house can give me and was never shy to point out any issues she saw throughout the house. She was always available. She also helped with lender and inspection company recommendations that did not disappoint. I would highly recommend! They went above and beyond throughout my home buying process

4/22/22Cori Cromwell

Google Review

Cindy is truly the best realtor for your rural property needs. We explicitly trust her in this crazy market with multiple contracts and offers! She is amazing!

4/20/22Cara McLean

Google Review

Simply the best! If you are seeking experience, integrity, and optimized outcomes as a buyer, seller, or both, call Cindy! She has helped us in the sale of two homes and the purchase of one. No real estate venture is without challenge, but Cindy is always calm, objective, and collaborative in identifying and recommending solutions. We would absolutely work with Cindy in the future and recommend her to you without reservation!

2/14/22mike moharer

Google Review

Cindy is the best realtor I have ever worked with! I met her through my sister who said she was a wonderful realtor and that is exactly what she turned out to be. Very empathetic, hard-working, transparent, honest, and a delight to be around. She is very well versed in her field, with a ton of knowledge in regards to the housing market and all contributing factors. I highly recommend Cindy Rein to anyone looking for a house, in this crazy market she was able to find me a house to move into with equity during a time that that was nearly impossible!! Buying a house is a very big investment and very stressful, but with Cindy it was a smooth process in a chaotic time!! Highly recommended!!!!

2/10/22J Clay

Google Review

Incredible service! Cindy is warm, down to earth, and one smart cookie. I was going through one of the most stressful times of my life and Cindy guided me through the home-buying process with care. She is the perfect blend of strategist and advocate. I can't recommend her enough and will be contacting her for future business.

2/10/22Kristine Clay

Google Review

Cindy with Sherlock Homes was amazing to work with! She is experienced, knowledgeable, and always quick to respond to questions. She made my home selling and buying process painless. I cannot recommend her company highly enough!

10/5/21Kyla Yerance

Google Review

Cindy, was very helpful. very professional. She is an excellent realtor. Would recommend to all my friends for a realtor.

8/4/21Blair Weed

Google Review

Cindy has a great deal of local experience that she uses to help her clients make good decisions/investments in real estate. From first-time buyers to large acreage ranch owners, Cindy understands what is needed and communicates that effectively.

7/30/21Lynae Smith

Google Review

Cindy is the absolute best! She went above and beyond to help us get a house with very short notice, in this wild market. She has helped us with so many things to help us relocate and get settled, that she didn't need to help us with. She's very honest and straight forward, while also being incredibly patient and respectful. She made buying a house, sight unseen so easy. Now after closing she has worked so hard for us to make sure we have everything we need and even lended some elbow grease. If you're looking to buy or sell, Cindy is the best there is!

6/5/21Erica Pasmino

Google Review

Cindy made the selling experience a very seamless process. She communicated well and was patient with our many questions. Jeffrey helped us get the house ready for closing and was very knowledgeable and professional. Looking forward with working with them both in the near future!

4/26/21Joseph Cummings

Google Review

Cindy is Awsome. She knows her business and I will use and recommend her again. Best of the best.

4/25/21Noosha Sara Moharer

Google Review

Great and very professional! Not only was our selling and purchasing experience with Cindy very pleasant, but happy to have also found a dear friend through the whole process!!!

4/24/21Jessica Grenier

Google Review

3/24/21Vincent Parenti

Google Review

Cindy Rein was great to work with! I am a lender and appreciated her communication and detail in our transactions. Cindy was very dedicated to her buyers and helped them close a deal in this very difficult market. Thank you Cindy!

3/24/21Alli Marrero-Cummings

Google Review

Cindy has been great to work with! She has been able to answer all of our questions and help guide my Fiancé and I through this whole process! Highly recommend!

2/26/21Rachel Hill

Google Review

Cindy was awesome to work with. Extremely knowledgeable and made you feel very comfortable through out the entire process. Definitely would recommend Cindy to anyone buying or selling a house.

2/25/21Lacee Hill

Google Review

It’s been such a positive experience working with Cindy! Having such support purchasing my first home with her, I was thrilled to work with her on purchasing my second home. Recently moved in, and am very pleased. Thanks Cindy!

2/25/21Lisa Shaull

Google Review

Cindy is the most experienced caring real estate agent in Douglas County. She always puts her customers first. If you want the best... Call Cindy

2/6/21Sami Brazell

Google Review

Cindy was so quick to respond to any and all questions we had. She was able to help us close on our land in just over a week!

2/4/21Jared Johnson

Google Review

Top notch. Felt like working with family. Looked out for our families best interests. I highly recommend.

2/3/21Allen W

Google Review

1/26/21Anne Thomas

Google Review

Cindy helped us sell my Dad’s home. As the issues came up, she had solutions and was able to move the process forward and get closed. Cindy was very professional and very responsive. We were so pleased with her experience and knowledge and recommend her thoroughly!

1/26/21Jo Hamsher

Google Review

By far the best real estate company I have ever worked with. Very responsive and professional, as well as helpful all the way around. I will never work with anyone else!