Joni Donaghy-Myers, Coldwell Banker Holloway

7/29/25Amanda Thompson

Google Review

Joni is absolutely amazing! She walked my wife and I through our first home buying experience 2 years ago, and just finished up walking us through our first selling experience! As first time home buyers, we were totally clueless…Joni was so patient with us, and was always happy to explain things to us. The process was easy and painless with Joni. Our selling experience took a bit of a turn just a week before closing…the buyers had some major issues, and we really weren’t sure if the deal was going to go through or not. Joni worked tirelessly behind the scenes with their realtor, and managed to make things happen…and happen on time nonetheless! Despite the nerves we had with all of that happening, we just have such an ease working with Joni that we knew it would all work out. Joni works around the clock constantly for her buyers and sellers. The thing we love the most about Joni is the fact that she truly cares. She cares about your story, she cares about you as a person. I don’t think she views anyone as just another buyer/seller. She gets to know you on a personal level, and she goes to the ends of the Earth to make things work out for you. We can’t recommend her enough to everyone! Whether you’re a seasoned buyer/seller, or this is your first time…I promise you, you will not be disappointed with Joni. As her slogan states, “Just Call Joni!”

7/23/25Tyler McKitrick

Google Review

We can’t say enough great things about Joni! As first-time homebuyers, the process of finding and purchasing a home felt overwhelming—but Joni made it feel easy, exciting, and completely manageable from start to finish.

She took the time to understand exactly what we were looking for and guided us with so much care, patience, and expertise. No question was ever too small, and her responsiveness made us feel like we were her top priority. Her knowledge of the market, neighborhoods, and every step of the buying process was incredible, and we always felt like we were in the best hands.

Thanks to Joni, we not only found a house—we found our home. She advocated for us, celebrated with us, and made the whole experience truly unforgettable. We are beyond grateful to have had her by our side and would recommend her to anyone without hesitation.

Thank you, Joni, for making our dream a reality

6/25/25K K

Google Review

Joni is the wham bam thank you your house is sold agent! Amazing from start to finish! If you are looking to buy or sell your house Joni is your go to! Thank you for making it so easy! You are amazing!!!!!

5/18/25Jennifer Burkholder

Google Review

Joni was fantastic to work with, even after we made her wait 3 years before finally buying our house. She communicated everything very clearly to us throughout the whole process as this was our first home purchase and she was very patient with us. We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor to work with!

4/28/25Tabi Marshall

Google Review

Working with Joni was an absolute dream! As first-time homebuyers, we were nervous and unsure about the process, but Joni made everything so smooth and easy to understand. She was incredibly patient, always available to answer our questions, and truly listened to what we were looking for. Thanks to her dedication and expertise, we found our perfect first home! We are so grateful for her support and guidance every step of the way. We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor and would highly recommend Joni to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

4/22/25Greg VanMeter

Google Review

Joni has helped our family with numerous transactions over the years. She works extremely hard, is patient, kind and always puts her clients first. We recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor that truly cares about them and what they are looking for in a home.

4/15/25Regina Klotz

Google Review

I give Joni 5 stars for her communication and talent! She is a good listener who is attentive to the details and wants of her client. I appreciate her knowledge, experience,
support and kind words during the process of buying my first home.

3/29/25Cierra Hart

Google Review

Joni is an absolute joy to work with. Anyone should be so lucky to find her and have her help navigating buying a property. She is knowledgeable, attentive, and the best quality honest! You never have to question if she is just in to sell houses or if she actually cares about you, because she will tell you if you should walk away. She is on your side and will advocate for you endlessly. She also answers questions day,night and on weekends.

I will recommend her time and time again.

2/4/25James

Google Review

Joni was so easy to work with , communication, professionalism, understanding, and the best thing friendly hometown personality. Thanks so much from my family and myself .

1/31/25Shannon Grimm

Google Review

Joni just helped my husband and I buy our first home. She did an amazing job answering any questions we had, and making us feel comfortable throughout the entire process. If you are looking for a realtor, you found the best one around!

1/31/25Levi Grimm

Google Review

Joni was amazing to work with! My wife and I were both first time homebuyers, and she made the entire process easy, and fun for us. I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home!

1/16/25Tayler McLaughlin

Google Review

Joni was amazing to work with! She was quick, responsive and very knowledgeable during every step of the process. The entire time, she made us feel as if we were her only clients. Even during the holiday season, she worked all days and hours. Her passion for her career is one that cannot be matched! Her communication is a 10/10 and we always knew what was going on even while we were waiting on others to respond. We are recommending her to all friends/family. Our family was blessed finding our forever home & it is all thanks to Joni!

12/26/24Megan Gilly

Google Review

Joni was absolutely amazing throughout the whole process of buying our home! Great communication and very knowledgeable. She made the process so smooth. We are so thankful we chose her to help us find and buy our home!!!

12/18/24Heather Lee

Google Review

If you are looking for a realtor highly recommend choosing Joni, she truly goes above and beyond for her clients. From the beginning she was very prompt in getting things going for us, and was always very responsive through the entire process. Joni was very patient and helped us find solutions for any issues that came our way!
There were a few things we had to fix before the sale of our older home, Joni was able to get someone right out and address the issues and fixed at an affordable rate. The process of selling a home can be stressful but she eased the process. 10/10 Highly recommend!

12/2/24Nick Gibson

Google Review

Joni was a delight to work with! My wife and I couldn't be any more happier with our experience having Joni as our realtor in buying our first house. She is very knowledgeable and was able to answer any questions we had. You couldn't ask more from anyone to have a better personality and the eagerness to help finding our home.
Highly recommend going with Joni as a realtor for any home buying or selling needs.

11/27/24Shaina Gibson

Google Review

We LOVED working with Joni! She was not pushy, she is knowledgeable, explained everything to us and knew how to help us for the things you don't think about as first time home buyers.
Thank you again Joni!!!

11/15/24Angie Chaney

Google Review

Joni is such a hard worker and an incredible agent. She always responds to messages quickly and is full of knowledge regarding real estate transactions. She has made our home buying and home selling experiences very enjoyable. Thank you Joni!!

11/9/24Amber Shatto

Google Review

Joni has continued to hang in with us through the last couple years as we searched for our forever home. She was patient with our likes and dislikes and always eager to help. When we found our forever home she began immediately on listing our current home and selling it. She made the process so smooth, easy, and enjoyable. She helped with anything and everything. We couldn’t have done it without her! She is the kindest and most caring around. Just call Joni, you don’t want to do it without her! The best around ♥️

11/4/24Vicki.Garry MayZCZYK

Google Review

My wife and I met Joni at a house she was showing. Because of our situation, we needed to move quickly on buying and selling.

Joni was very responsive with all questions as well as knowledgeable with the industry. Joni was very professional with her communication and our requests throughout the process.

If you are looking to buy/sell in the Fort Wayne and surrounding areas, we would highly recommend Joni for her services. It was clear to us that Joni not only knew the industry very well but also cared deeply about us as a family.

10/29/24Stacy Swingley

Google Review

The. Best. ....Seriously. Joni is fantastic at her job, and navigated us through a long and difficult transaction. She chased down loose ends, and went to bat for us again and again in the negotiation phase. I would not hesitate to hire her again.

10/22/24Whitney Lambert

Google Review

Joni has been helping us for almost a year to find a house! She has become a great mentor and my kiddos refer to her as “grandma Joni” which is so sweet! I couldn’t have asked for anyone better to be our realtor and friend through this process of buying a home! We are so thankful for her and high recommend working with her. ❤️

10/16/24carlee nelson

Google Review

Joni is wonderful. So patient, hard-working, honest, kind, and knowledgable! She was constantly working on our behalf, and her communication skills were excellent. I always felt totally taken care of with Joni! If I could give her a 100 stars, I would! She sets the bar very high!

8/21/24Kreigh Williams

Google Review

Joni was all over every detail from start to finish. She communicated frequently and I always knew I could count on her to answer any question I had. The next time I need a realtor Joni will be my first and only call.

8/12/24Caleb quickstad

Google Review

Joni did an excellent job with helping sell my house earlier this year. I am the type of person to ask a lot of questions. She answered all my questions and did so in a timely manner. During closing the buyer wanted me to paint my deck in order to close, Joni offered to come paint part of the deck to help close on the house. She went well above and beyond what I expected. Look forward to working with her again when I buy another home.

8/12/24Monique Biddle

Google Review

We love working with Joni! She is the absolute best! We have worked with her numerous times and she always gets the job done. She is very knowledgeable and has provided us with so much great advice when selling and buying a home. She is highly responsive and is willing to show us any house, any time. We would definitely recommend working with Joni to anyone who is buying or selling a home! We can’t wait to continue working with her in the future!

7/23/24Adrianna Sowards

Google Review

In the best way possible, I don't even know where to begin when reflecting on how pivotal having Joni as my real estate agent was to the process of buying my first home.
Joni communicated so fluidly and was easy to reach with any questions or concerns I may have had throughout the entire process.
From the beginning, Joni eased the stress of sorting through listings as I tried to find the house that was the best fit for my family and my budget.
Joni deserves an award, and maybe a vacation, for supporting me through each showing and every bid.
I could not be more appreciative of her expertise and empathy. The experience was affirming and I walked away with my house and having learned quite a bit.
Thank you, Joni! You helped me achieve my goal of home ownership before my 35th birthday.
And, should my family be in the market for another home in the future and in need of a real estate agent, Joni would be my first pick. 💜

7/10/24Amanda Thacker

Google Review

Fantastic communication and willingness to show you any house you want to see, no matter what! She really knows her stuff and is so willing to do what it takes to get a deal done.

7/10/24Crystal Payton

Google Review

Joni was absolutely wonderful to work with!
Our home selling process couldn’t have been easier! If you are looking for an experienced and reputable realtor- she is your gal!
We would recommend Joni to any of our family and friends and plan on utilizing her again when it’s time for us to purchase our next home.

7/10/24Ava Reel

Google Review

7/10/24Lyle Beachy

Google Review

I highly recommend Joni. Above and beyond all realtors. Great to work with.

6/5/24Brian Myers

Google Review

Joni is committed to listen to her clients needs/wants and then help them through the entire process to find them exactly the right family home. Her work ethic is outstanding! Whether you are selling or buying a home, I would highly recommend Joni...let her help your family find your next forever home.

11/22/23Cathy Lepley

Google Review

Finding Joni and hiring her to help me sell my mom's house was the best decision I ever made. She is very knowledgeable and my sale had a few unique issues that she was willing to go the extra mile to make sure they were done correctly. I agree with other reviews that she treats her clients as if they were her own family. I really loved working with her and would recommend her to ANYONE that is looking to buy or sell. Five star service!!!

11/18/23Tanner Bowen

Google Review

Joni treated me like a son and took care of us from beginning to end. Communicates perfectly and answered every question we had! Went above and beyond for us! Will always use her for future selling/buying!

11/12/23Kent Park

Google Review

I highly Recommend Joni for your real estate needs in Northeast Indiana!

8/22/23Justin Branock

Google Review

When we decided to move, it was a no brainer who we were going to call. Joni Donaghy Myers was getting a call. I have known Joni for 10+ years having coached her son many years ago for the the Summit City Sluggers. The Myers family is a family that would give you the shirt off their back or the last dollar in their bank account if you needed it, regardless of how bad they needed it too. You won’t find a better person. Joni is so caring and loving of others, she truly invest in the process and the vision you have like it’s her own. That is why Joni gets my call every time and will always do so! If you are in the market to buy a house, you might find someone out there who has made more sales than she has, you might find someone out there who is considered a better realtor on paper, but what you won’t find is someone that cares as much about you that is also amazing at what she does. She is an unbelievable realtor but an even better person.

Sure, you want to be just another sale, call someone else. If you want to be another box checked off the list and forgotten about once the deal is made, call someone else. However if you want to be heard, valued, and taken care of like you are your realtors own family, there is only one call to make and that is Joni. She invest it all with you!

Joni, thank you again, you truly are amazing! Wells county, and all the surrounding areas are a better place because you are working in them.

8/7/23Cathe Music

Google Review

I always love working with Joni! She takes great care of her clients and guides them through the process! Her service and availability make her second to none!

8/1/23Angie Topp

Google Review

Joni always treats her clients like they are family! She cares deeply and that shows in the excellent service she provides every single time! I love working with Joni!

7/31/23Elizabeth Landis

Google Review

We had a wonderful experience working with Joni to sell our home. She walked us through the every step of the process and gave counsel regarding our final decisions. She always answered texts and calls promptly. She was a joy to work with!

7/24/23Grant Wilson

Google Review

We couldn't have asked for a better realtor! Joni was extremely knowledgeable about the whole process, fought for what we wanted, and had our best interests in mind to the very end. Thank you!

7/21/23Kylee Loose

Google Review

Joni walked me through the entire home buying process, often providing me with genuine advice and opinions that helped me feel more confident in all of my decisions in this unfamiliar situation. She was super kind and easy to work with. I hope to work with her again in the future, but for now, I love my new first home! Thanks for everything, Joni!

7/7/23Shannon Mann

Google Review

Highly recommend Joni! First time working with her and if we need another agent she will be absolutely be the one we call.

6/5/23Deborah Gallagher

Google Review

Joni is amazing. We met her at one of her open houses and everything just clicked. Joni kept encouraging us as we were getting discouraged with the way the housing market is. We were in constant communication and if we found something we wanted to look at we were looking at it that day. We closed the Friday before Memorial Day, 2 weeks ahead of schedule. We will highly recommend Joni and if we decide to sell in the future we will use Joni again.

5/16/23Leah Nash

Google Review

Joni was great to work with when selling our house! Very knowledgeable and prompt with sharing information to keep us updated on what we needed to do. Joni’s been great as we’re also now looking for a new house to make our home!

5/4/23Demi Allen

Google Review

Joni was absolutely amazing. She helped us every step of the way as first home buyers. She made us her top priority and never took more than a minute to reply! I HIGHLY recommend.

3/28/23Lois Falk

Google Review

I highly recommend Joni for your real estate needs. She is knowledgeable, honest and detail oriented. I was out of state, but I needed to purchase a home in the Bluffton area. I chose Joni to help me. I am so glad I did! She went over and above taking walk through videos of potential homes that fit my requirements. Joni answered all my questions and concerns throughout this process. She gave me excellent professional advice, and promptly guided me through this buying process. With her excellent negotiating skills, I bought an awesome home in the perfect location!

3/22/23Brad Pursley

Google Review

Great to work with, looks out for my best interest. Great personality, kind, and not pushy. Best of all she knows what she is doing. I recommend her to everyone

3/21/23Tina Pursley

Google Review

We appreciate all your help in selling our home and helping us find our forever home!

3/2/23Ashley Coleman

Google Review

Joni is absolutely amazing and was super to work with! I couldn't have done it without her help! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!!

2/22/23Lane Stringer

Google Review

Joni went above and beyond to help my family find our perfect first home! Working with her was better than I could have ever expected! Definitely recommend Joni if you want to work with, not just any realtor, but a friend!

2/9/23Sarah Reed

Google Review

Joni Donaghy-Myers made it easy to set up the house for sale. She had good ideas & kept me informed through the listing/selling process. Most importantly, she was pro-active & focused on the final goal of selling the house—I felt well looked after as the seller. I recommend Joni & am convinced you will be pleased with her professionalism.

1/31/23Kara Ackley

Google Review

Joni was great to work with when selling my parents home. She went above and beyond whenever I had questions or needed help! I would definitely use Joni again and recommend her to anyone thinking about selling their home or looking for a new one.

1/29/23Cheryl Grimm

Google Review

Joni sold our lake property. She is great! You don't have to worry about anything because she handles it all. Please give her a call if your needing a realtor.

1/1/23Charlotte Wolfe

Google Review

12/29/22Kent Sonnenberg

Google Review

Joni is the best realtor hands down. I highly recommend her for your real estate needs!

12/22/22Rozay D

Google Review

12/16/22Cara Click

Google Review

Joni is the best! She was available basically 24/7 for the big and small questions to help us out along the way. We are first time home buyers and she was fantastic!

11/18/22Eric Westfall

Google Review

Joni was wonderful to work with. She was patient in helping me find a house that was perfect for myself and my family. It was my first time buying a house and she guided through the steps with ease! I felt she had the best interests for my family through the entire process!!

11/18/22Ethan Westfall

Google Review

Joni did an amazing job helping my girlfriend and I buy a house! She was super communicative and was always ready to answer our questions! I highly recommend having her help if you’re looking to buy a house!

11/18/22Kylie Tomlin

Google Review

Joni was AMAZING. She made house hunting so easy and fun, and having her along was like having a friend to give input and advice. We felt taken care of and prioritized the entire time. Joni was flexible with our schedule and got us into houses very quickly! I would highly recommend Joni if you want this process to be enjoyable!

11/18/22Norman Gould

Google Review

Joni was exceptional at bringing us together and helping sale and purchase all in a short time. She knows how to pull everything together and make the process smooth and with minimal setbacks. I would highly recommend her, if you are selling or buying. We have sold and purchased homes with her twice and she was fantastic on all occasions. Exceptional agent who knows real-estate.

11/17/22Ann Donaghy

Google Review

Joni is absolutely amazing! I was looking for a home to buy in Indiana while living in Florida. Joni really went above and beyond to show me homes and made sure they met my needs. Once I found a home I loved she helped me through the entire buying process. Anything I needed she was there to help. Even after I moved in Joni was there to help. I’m so happy with the home she helped me find. It definitely feels like home.

11/17/22Conner Nash

Google Review

Best realtor in NE Indiana!! No joke, Joni is the person to go to!!

11/17/22Blake Byerly

Google Review

Joni found my family the perfect home! She will be my realtor for life!

11/17/22Brandon Burch

Google Review

Made my first home buying experience easy and enjoyable. I would recommend to anyone!

11/17/22Lexie Myers

Google Review

Joni is the best realtor hands down! She is very knowledgeable, patient, understanding, and has a big heart for her clients! Being first time home buyers, my husband and I were incredibly nervous and didn’t know a lot about the process, but with Joni the process was seamless! She will get you what you deserve and won’t settle for anything less! You won’t regret having Joni as your realtor! Highly recommend.

11/17/22Justin & Kara Branock

Google Review

11/17/22Amber Park

Google Review

Joni is great to work with and very flexible on times! She gives great advice and is super friendly! Will be using her for future homes.

11/17/22Brianna Abbott

Google Review

Joni will treat you like family! She will walk you through every step of transitioning your family into a new home and is on top of every detail. We were in great hands!

11/17/22Wayne Heffelfinger

Google Review

Working with Joni was both a joy and a pleasure. She helped us buy our home in the midst of a CRAZY housing market. Not only was she always available to answer our questions, she did it with great patience and expertise. Her attention to detail was second to none, and it helped us avoid a potentially large problem at closing. I can’t recommend her highly enough!

11/17/22Karen Everett

Google Review

Joni helped sell our home. She was very patient and answered a hundred questions! She knows what she is doing and will well beyond what is expected.

11/17/22TheBohataFam

Google Review

11/17/22Angela Flickinger

Google Review

Joni is absolutely phenomenal! Our family relocated to Indiana from Ohio, late Summer 2022, and Joni was so incredible to work with. She responded to all of our questions, concerns, and needs, as well as made special arrangements to accommodate us when we would be in Indiana and available to view homes. Joni is professional, genuine, down-to-earth, and FUN! Although we'd never met Joni until we began our real estate adventure in Indiana, we felt as if we'd known her our entire lives. We couldn't imagine any real estate adventure in our future, without Joni.

11/17/22Cheryl Dehaas

Google Review

Joni Donarghy-Myers is one of the best realtor that I have ever seen in a long time she helped me and my husband find a great house.

11/17/22ryan tomlin

Google Review

Joni was amazing to work with and she didn’t stop showing us houses she thought we would like until we found out forever home! Pick Joni when you are looking for your next home!

11/17/22Kristi Gould

Google Review

I highly recommend Joni. She listens to everything you want in your dream home and puts 110% into finding that perfect home for you. She is very knowledgeable about the market place, value of homes, and looks at homes within your budget. We never felt pressured or rushed throughout the process. She also works with title and mortgage companies that are detailed and fast to get you approved and closed creating less stress on the buyer. By the end of the process Joni isn't just a realtor but becomes a friend. She truly wants what is best for both parties.

11/17/22Devon Coffield

Google Review

She is the absolute BEST! She goes above and beyond. I would highly recommend her!

11/17/22Kim Nash

Google Review

Truly amazing customer service! Would highly recommend to everyone looking for a realtor. Joni is absolutely the best and knows her stuff!

11/17/22Haley Howell

Google Review

We had the BEST experience with Joni! Very helpful, kind, and supportive. Joni will go-to-bat for you to keep you informed and getting a good deal. 10/10 would recommend!

Joni Donaghy-Myers

About Joni

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Joni Has the Most Experience In

Joni's Listings and Deals

Joni's Active Listings

Other Experience

Joni's Reviews