Mike Sibbald

8/23/25Jon Klingborg

Google Review

Mike Sibbald of Elevations Real Estate took the time to get to know what we wanted and we drove about 250 miles in 3 days to find it. He was patient, energetic, informative, pleasant, knowledgeable, trustworthy and kind. It has been a great experience working with Mike and won't hesitate to reach out to him again, should we need any help!

8/21/25Emma Brown

Google Review

Mike was so incredible to work with and without his knowledge, expertise, and persistence we would not have been able to close on our house. We thought we would be able to do this without a realtor because we had a house picked and it seemed straight forward enough and when we decided to use a realtor I didn’t know exactly how much help it would end up being. We could not have done it on our own and are so grateful to Mike. It was a small manufactured home and he never treated it like it was a small deal, it was a big deal to us buying our first home and we got the same enthusiasm and hard work from him. We absolutely loved working with Mike and honestly can not say enough good things about him

4/17/25atom h

Google Review

Mike was incredibly communicative, reassuring, and overall helpful throughout such a stressful and overwhelming process. He went above and beyond to ensure we understood everything and were comfortable during each step of the way.

4/17/25Hannah Hunsberger

Google Review

Mike made this experience painless and easy. His knowledge and communication really came in handy!

4/17/25Erin Moomey

Google Review

Mike is a great resource for his clients! He has been in the Fort Collins market for many years and is so easy to work with! His clients are in good hands.

3/8/25sean conway

Google Review

I’ve had the pleasure of working with Mike a couple times in the last few years. Mike has always made the process very easy for me! Hard working, fast and accommodating! I recommend Mike for anyone looking for a Real estate agent!

2/28/25Kelly McMonagle

Google Review

Mike is a real go getter. He doesn’t cut any corners. Very responsive and attentive.

2/19/25Creighton Hejduk

Google Review

If I could give more than 5 stars I would!

Mike is by far the best real estate agent I've ever worked with. From the very beginning I knew that Mike had my best interests in mind. Mike is very knowledgeable and clearly cares for his clients. His attention to detail, timely responses & dedication to helping find a home goes above and beyond! He made everything very clear and helped guide my partner and I to our new home, making it a typically stressful time much easier to handle.

2/14/25Jocelyn Mahuron

Google Review

I could write an essay here bragging about Mike! My boyfriend and I just closed on our first home and Mike was amazing all along the way. He was so thorough in walking us through the contract and process as first time home buyers, before we even toured homes. His communication is so fast and consistent, and he has so much experience and expertise in the field. He also has great references for all the other contacts in the process, and everyone speaks so highly of him and say they love working with him, which is no surprise! We have never felt so much that a professional really had our best interests at heart, we just knew we could trust him right away. I will always be recommending him to anyone I ever know who needs an agent! He’s the best of the best :)

2/11/25Josh Pope

Google Review

It's more difficult than ever to be a first time homebuyer, but thanks to Mike I'm leaving this review from the comfort of my new home. He took the time to really get to know us and, more importantly, what was important to us when looking for a house. Mike was patient and open with us as we navigated the process, and always made sure that we had as much transparency and information as possible, every step of the way. Mike was a genuine partner that worked with us for the best possible outcome, not just a facilitator looking to close a deal and move on. There is no question who I'm going with when it's time to buy my next house.

2/3/25Jeff Hochman

Google Review

Great agent. Works very hard. Sincere and honest.

11/29/24Jerry Polt

Google Review

8/26/24Blueline 344

Google Review

Mike Sibbald is more than a realtor. He is someone who cares about you and works hard to meet your expectations and find the right home for you. Mike Sibbald is extremely knowledgeable about the area and will guide you throughout the process. I would recommend Mike to family and friends. You will not be disappointment.

5/6/24Kelly Lowther

Google Review

Mike Sibbald of Elevations helped us navigate preparing our house to sell and coming up with a winning strategy. We had six viewings in three days that resulted in three good offers. It was a nice, smooth transaction and we greatly appreciate his time and effort. If we return to the area we will absolutely be reaching out to him again!

2/22/24Dan Coogan

Google Review

I recently had the pleasure of working with Mike Sibbald from Elevations Real Estate to sell my property, and I was completely satisfied with the experience.

From the initial consultation to the closing, Mike demonstrated a high level of professionalism and expertise. He was attentive to my needs, providing valuable insights into the market and guiding me through each step of the selling process.

Communication was seamless – Mike was always responsive and kept me informed about potential buyers, market trends, and competing offers. His attention to detail and proactive approach ensured a smooth and stress-free transaction.

What sets Mike apart is his knowledge of the market. Mike has significant experience with the Fort Collins market and was able to provide valuable guidance in setting the perfect price. He also provided great insight on how to manage and counter the multiple offers I received.

I highly recommend Mike to anyone in need of a dedicated and knowledgeable real estate professional. No one will work harder for positive sale. If you want a positive and successful real estate experience, Mike is the one to call.

12/4/23Emily Curren

Google Review

Our experience working with Mike was extremely enjoyable and rewarding. He worked tirelessly to help us navigate a complicated purchase and was a trusted sounding board for us along the way. We've already recommended him to friends in the area!

12/4/23Evan Smith

Google Review

Mike helped us navigate a particularly tricky real estate deal with ease and expertise. He listened to our priorities when looking at a property and was extremely responsive!

10/15/23Anna Feeney

Google Review

Mike was extremely attentive and patient with me during my first home buying experience. We were not in a rush, and he helped us navigate a tricky market, showing us homes over a 9 month period. He was extremely knowledgeable, and guided us to the perfect home. We just closed, and the process could not have been easier. We barely had to lift a finger! My husband worked with Mike to buy his first home in 2017! We are so happy! And so happy to have worked with Mike!

9/4/23Jenny Rodriguez

Google Review

Just love this place..

6/21/23Arnold Cantu

Google Review

Words can't describe how great it was and has been to work with Mike. From first meeting with you to explain the process in an easy-to-understand manner, taking care of things before and throughout under contract, and keeping you in the loop while being incredibly kind and responsive--can't recommend Mike enough!

3/30/23Megan P

Google Review

My husband & I recently moved back to FOCO with no intention of buying straight away, but that changed once we met Mike. We were first time home buyers & he perfectly explained everything down to the tiny details. He helped us SO much through the process of looking & buying. We bought much sooner than planned, but Mike showed us the perfect first home that we just couldn’t refuse. He truly is a buyers agent & understood exactly our wants/needs. I cannot recommend him enough.
Thank you, Mike, for helping us find our dream home!

3/29/23Darrell Glaser

Google Review

Mike is an amazing realtor. After looking at a few houses, he knew the perfect home for my wife and I. Deal with confidence. Best buyers agent in Northern Colorado.

2/12/23Agnes B.

Google Review

Mike had our house under contract the day after it was listed! Mike also worked with us as buyers. He was always there for us. He truly cares about his clients. We could not have been happier with our experience!

10/19/22Erica Withrow

Google Review

Highly recommend Mike! He's an expert when it comes to real estate and excellent at communicating. My partner and I had ZERO knowledge about real estate. Mike was patient with us and clearly answered any and all of our questions until we felt we could confidently make the right decision for ourselves. Mike really made everything go very smoothly.

We were able to find and buy a perfect first home, and Mike truly made the process feel like a walk in the park.

Thank you so much, Mike!!!

7/18/22All Sobsons

Google Review

Mike helped us negotiate a contract in this crazy market that saved us, potentially, thousands of dollars!! He was super creative in how he wrote up the offer. He knows his business, he has a wealth of information about all kinds of contractors and trades-people to use for various things you may need. Very connected in the community. A good person to have at your fingertips!!
Thanks for your help, Mike!

4/12/22Kent Rychel

Google Review

Mike Sibbald has brokered many Real Estate deals in Fort Collins for me. He is experienced, detail oriented, personable, and a great communicator. He has helped me with some difficult purchases creatively and ethically. He has turned potentially stressful situations into smooth and successful transactions.
He makes the buying or selling experience painless and enjoyable… a celebration! If you want the best person to handle your home buying or selling experience, go to Mike Sibbald at Elevations Real Estate. Outstanding!

3/27/22Wendy McMosher

Google Review

I am convinced no one knows more about NOCO real estate than Mike. His family has been in the business for many years - not only does he know current market dynamics, he has a history of the area to help inform your purchase or sale. Even after close, he is helpful with needed information - down to a list of services and contractors in the area by County. We are very grateful for this level of professionalism and customer service.

3/25/22John McKay

Google Review

It was a great pleasure working with Mike and his team.

3/24/22zachary butler

Google Review

1/31/22Ashley Shoham

Google Review

Mike is an excellent agent! He is professional, dedicated, personable and knowledgeable. He made the process easy to understand every step of the way. Thank you Mike!👍

11/27/21christine ginnity

Google Review

Mike helped us purchase our first home nearly 16 years ago! He is personable and professional. He helped guide us through the unknown territory of home buying with care - joining us in our excitement in first time home ownership and keeping us on track!

Over the years, we have consistently turned to Mike with our home and real estate questions. From referrals for home maintenance and improvement companies, knowledgeable discussions regarding national and local real estate trends and assistance with comparative market analysis in order to help us make decisions about our home, (we may have even contacted him with a question or two about a car purchase).

Mike is knowledgable and intelligent. He is honest, kind, helpful and has integrity. Mike always makes us feel as if we are his most important clients.

Thanks Mike!
Christine and John Ginnity

11/17/21Juli Sickels

Google Review

Mike was a great choice for us as first time home buyers! He helped us find the true values of what we were looking for, and was a trusted voice in navigating the challenging home-buying process! Mike was diligent in communication with us and other realtors in order to give us the best chance on the offers we made. Best of all, we were able to buy in our own great community- Fort Collins. We’d recommend Mike to anyone.

10/16/21Colleen Conway

Google Review

My faith community was searching for a space and Mike listened closely to our needs and the culture of our community and of course limited funds. As a many years community member in the area he is very knowledgeable about the different neighborhoods, schools, culture and can find the perfect fit for a buyer. He had to work with the church governing board 9 community members who only make decisions based on consensus. We had never ending questions and Mike is the ultimate professional in his knowledge and patience in ushering us through the process. I can absolutely recommend Mike with utmost confidence to any one looking to purchase or sell a home (or a church!).

10/15/21Nichol Wolverton

Google Review

I had an excellent experience because Mike was punctual, direct, and caring. I appreciated his communication and honesty throughout the whole process.

10/5/21Jacob Pratt

Google Review

We bought a house with Mike and it was an excellent experience. He was professional, responsive, and friendly from start to finish.

2/28/20Tyler Wible

Google Review

We would highly recommend Mike Sibbald and Elevations Real Estate. He took amazing care of us, walked us through the process, answered all of our questions throughout all of it.

If you are new to the home buying process, Mike will take the help you understand each step in the process, answer anything that comes up. He is extremely knowledgeable about the current real estate market, locations, home features, and provided us with a thorough review and comparison of homes in our area, all the while making sure we were comfortable and confident in our decisions before moving to the next step. Mike took excellent care of us and kept us on track and at ease through buying our first home.

3/29/18SMC

Google Review

I have used Mike for several house sales and purchases. Mike has been great. He is always helpful with his suggestions and willing to work with what we want. What I really appreciate the most is his honesty. Mike is a "straight shooter" and his knowledge of the Northern Colorado market makes him an amazing asset in your home purchase or sale.