20
Safest Neighborhoods in Orange County, NY
-
-
Hamptonburgh
Hamptonburgh in Maybrook features diverse homes on wooded lots. The Orange County Arboretum and Thomas Bull Memorial Park offer green spaces. The area has lower crime risk than the national average and highly rated schools.
-
Average Value
$613K
-
List Price
$205K - $1.2M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
4 Listings
-
-
Woodbury
Woodbury in Central Valley blends suburban charm with natural beauty. Highlights include Harriman State Park, Woodbury Commons Outlets, and highly rated Monroe-Woodbury schools. Interstate 87 provides easy access to New York City.
-
Average Value
$598K
-
List Price
$144K - $820K
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
11 Listings
-
-
Goshen
Goshen, NY, a historic Hudson Valley town, blends rural charm with suburban amenities. Home to Legoland and the Harness Racing Museum, it offers diverse dining options. Goshen Central High School boasts strong academic programs.
-
Average Value
$588K
-
List Price
$169K - $3.4M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
7 Listings
-
-
Cornwall
Within the Hudson Valley, Cornwall, 61 miles from New York City, is a mountainous area known for its highly rated schools, revival architecture, proximity to military bases and nature. “It’s also right by the Hudson on the west side,” says Diana Polack, a Realtor with Compass Greater NY, LLC. Polack has been working in the industry for over 35
-
Average Value
$580K
-
List Price
$64K - $1.1M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
15 Listings
-
-
Monroe
Monroe, NY, combines historic charm with suburban living near NYC. The town offers diverse housing, local businesses, and Woodbury Commons Outlet Mall. Residents enjoy parks and highly rated Monroe-Woodbury schools.
-
Average Value
$576K
-
List Price
$146K - $7.2M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
22 Listings
-
-
Blooming Grove
Blooming Grove near Washingtonville offers rural charm and urban amenities. It includes Brotherhood Winery, scenic parks, and diverse housing. Washingtonville High School is highly rated. The area is an hour from New York City.
-
Average Value
$546K
-
List Price
$196K - $11.6M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
27 Listings
-
-
Minisink
Minisink, NY, 65 miles from NYC, offers rural living with family farms and pastoral landscapes. Minisink Valley High is highly rated. Residents enjoy Wallkill River National Wildlife Refuge and local parks for outdoor activities.
-
Average Value
$535K
-
List Price
$201K - $1M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
4 Listings
-
-
Crawford
Crawford in Middletown includes Pine Bush, known for the annual Pine Bush UFO Fair. Local spots like The Cup & Saucer Diner and hiking trails in the Appalachian Mountains add charm to this rural area.
-
Average Value
$505K
-
List Price
$97K - $4.2M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
6 Listings
-
-
Newburgh
Newburgh, NY, a historic Hudson River city 70 miles from NYC, offers urban and suburban living. It features waterfront dining, events in Downing Park, and serves as a transportation hub with easy access to NYC.
-
Average Value
$471K
-
List Price
$145K - $5M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
28 Listings
-
-
Mount Hope
Mount Hope in Otisville offers a rural escape with rolling hills and active farms. The area features Mount Hope Town Park and scenic hiking trails. Minisink Valley High School is highly rated, attracting families to the region.
-
Average Value
$458K
-
List Price
$221K - $4.6M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
10 Listings
-
-
Highlands
Highlands in the lower Hudson Valley features Bear Mountain State Park for outdoor recreation and the historic West Point Academy. Fort Montgomery Elementary and James I. O'Neill High School are highly rated.
-
Average Value
$435K
-
List Price
$229K - $839K
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
3 Listings
-
-
Wallkill
Wallkill, Middletown blends urban and rural living. It offers parks like Highland Lakes State Park, hosts the Orange County Fair, and has diverse housing options. New York City is accessible by car or train, 75 miles away.
-
Average Value
$427K
-
List Price
$104K - $1.7M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
25 Listings
-
-
Deerpark
Deerpark, NY, is a rural town with forested landscapes near New Jersey and Pennsylvania. It offers hiking trails, camping, and fishing. Residents enjoy a quiet lifestyle and access to the highly rated Port Jervis High School.
-
Average Value
$341K
-
List Price
$154K - $1.8M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
-
-
Wawayanda
Wawayanda, NY, provides rural living with rolling hills and spacious properties. The town has highly rated Minisink Valley schools. Residents enjoy fruit picking at Soons Orchard and shopping in nearby Middletown.
-
Average Value
$497K
-
List Price
$195K - $801K
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
7 Listings
-
-
Warwick
Warwick, NY combines village charm with rural beauty. The town center offers diverse dining and local markets. Outdoor enthusiasts enjoy Greenwood Lake and Appalachian Trail access. Warwick Valley schools are highly rated.
-
Average Value
$576K
-
List Price
$180K - $2M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
33 Listings
-
-
Chester
Chester, NY, a rural town known for dairy and Philadelphia cream cheese, offers recreation at Castle Fun Center and Goosepond Mountain State Park. The area features small-town homes and farmhouses near Hudson Valley attractions.
-
Average Value
$537K
-
List Price
$238K - $1.1M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
15 Listings
-
-
Greenville Town
Greenville Town, NY offers rural living with outdoor recreation. Homes sit on large lots amid trees and hills. Local parks and Huckleberry Ridge State Forest are nearby. The area has highly rated schools and lower crime risk.
-
Average Value
$506K
-
List Price
$107K - $2.1M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
1 Listing
-
-
New Windsor
-
Average Value
$468K
-
List Price
$118K - $3.9M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
23 Listings
-
-
Montgomery
Embedded within rural Orange County, the village of Montgomery offers small-town conveniences and the quiet that comes with the exurbs while still enjoying highway access to New York City. “Montgomery has a rural feel compared to the rest of our area,” says Brian Caplicki, a Realtor with Keller Williams Realty Hudson Valley United who has sold
-
Average Value
$452K
-
List Price
$157K - $2.9M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
29 Listings
-
Neighborhoods in Nearby Cities
More About Living in Orange County
Homes in Nearby Neighborhoods
Copyright © 2025 CoStar Group
