$374,900
102 & 108 Main St, Lancaster, NY 14043
An investor’s dream — six units and serious returns. This portfolio offers a rare balance of stability, updates, and future upside.102 Main Street is a five-unit building with a mix of long-term and short-term rental income. Three units are currently rented to reliable long-term tenants, one unit is operating successfully as a short-term rental, and another is a full reno that’s nearly
Merritt Kreutzer Listing by eXp Realty
Explore Lancaster
$219,900
14 Clark St, Lancaster, NY 14086
Location, location, location! Just a few houses down from the corner of West Main and Central, with the Lancaster Opera House and Historical Society in between, this two-unit property sits at the very heart of the Village of Lancaster. Both apartments feature two bedrooms and are fully tenant-occupied, generating steady income from day one. The deep backyard extends all the way to the creek,
Merritt Kreutzer Listing by eXp Realty
$249,900
63 Saint John St, Lancaster, NY 14086
Prime location in the Village of Lancaster! Just steps from the revitalized historic corridor on West Main and Central, this three-unit property blends steady income with future upside. The two front apartments each feature two bedrooms and are currently tenant-occupied, providing reliable cash flow. The rear one-bedroom unit is vacant and ready for your vision—make minor repairs to rent
Merritt Kreutzer Listing by eXp Realty
$499,000 Open Wed 5PM - 7PM
57-59 Conway St, Depew, NY 14043
Welcome to 59 Conway, a truly unique custom-built home designed with multigenerational living in mind. Offering over 3,100 sq ft of living space, this property features 6 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, and full separate basements, providing unmatched versatility for large households, extended family, or in-law accommodations. One side of the home was thoughtfully designed with handicap
Matthew Fowler Listing by HUNT Real Estate Corporation
$299,000
25 - 27 Cadet Cir, Lancaster, NY 14086
Opportunity is knocking.....a rare find! All brick side by side ranch duplex with easy NO step entry. Units mirror each other and the rents are great $1395 /$1375. All appliances will stay! Location-location-location!!! Located minutes from year round activity The Village has to offer w coffee shops, retail and restaurants, but far enough away from any hustle and bustle. This all brick ranch
James Beamer Listing by HUNT Real Estate Corporation
$99,900
559 Penora St, Depew, NY 14043
Welcome to a multi family house in the heart of depew in lancaster. Both units have 2 bedrooms 2 bathrooms separate living/dining and kitchen. This is a great opportunity for investors and new homeowners. This is a very quiet neighborhood. There is a huge driveway where you can park more than 6 cars. There is an Additional vacant lot included. All amenities are close by less than 2 miles
Mohammad Ali Listing by HUNT Real Estate Corporation
$190,000
57 Saint John St, Lancaster, NY 14086
ALERT-GREAT INVESTOR OPPORTUNITY! Property is back on the market to no fault of the seller! This partially fenced, 2-family home on quiet neighborhood street is PRICED TO SELL! There's a large rear deck overlooking Cayuga Creek - No REAR neighbors and a 2.5 oversized garage with front and rear overhead garage doors! The occupied lower offers 2 bedrooms, full bath, large updated kitchen and
Lynne Logan Listing by Howard Hanna WNY Inc.
$299,900
435 Columbia Ave, Depew, NY 14043
Fantastic investment property! This fully rented duplex has a new electrical service, updated and newly rented apartment and a long term tenant! Large corner lot with turnaround blacktop driveway. Utility shed.
Jennifer Sennett Listing by Keller Williams Realty Lancaster
$429,000
169 Warner Rd Unit 167, Depew, NY 14043
This lovely 3 bedroom / 2 bath includes two side by side apartments with private basements for each unit. Driveway for shared parking and large shared back yard is a wonderful addition to this large side by side. Interior is updated and currently has two leases in place. The front covered porch is a very nice place to enjoy and relax. 1 car garage and shed are both included and nice
Jamie Vaarwerk Listing by Saperston Real Estate Corp
$399,900 Open Sun 1PM - 3PM
1499 Town Line Rd, Alden, NY 14004
Charming classic Craftsman home with bonus garage apartment on a picturesque 7.25-acre T-shaped lot! The main house offers 3 bedrooms, including one on the first floor, a full bath, and convenient first-floor laundry. The open floor plan blends the kitchen, dining, and living areas, showcasing refinished hardwood floors and abundant natural light. The first-floor bathroom has been updated, and
Kelly Glinski Listing by Howard Hanna WNY Inc.
Lancaster, NY, established in 1833, is a suburban town located 14 miles east of Buffalo. The town features multiple large parks and a revitalized downtown village area with local boutiques and restaurants on Central Avenue. Residents enjoy dining options such as The Yelling Goat, 99 Brick Oven, Frank’s Grill, and Skoobs Village Grill. Lancaster Central School District serves the community with highly rated schools, including Hillview Elementary and Lancaster High School, which offers dual enrollment classes for college credit. The town's subdivisions offer a variety of home styles, including ranch, craftsman, farmhouse, and colonial revival, with well-kept yards and garages. Lancaster is safer than the national average, contributing to its appeal. Recreational opportunities abound at Como Lake Park, with activities like fishing, disc golf, hiking, biking, cross-country skiing, and sledding. Walden Pond Park provides facilities for softball, volleyball, and youth sports. Lancaster Country Club offers an 18-hole golf course and swimming pool complex. The Lancaster Opera House hosts plays and concerts, while the annual Fall Festival features live music, food trucks, and more. The historic Warren Hull House offers tours by appointment, showcasing life in Erie County 200 years ago.
On average, homes in Lancaster, NY sell after 26 days on the market compared to the national average of 52 days. The median sale price for homes in Lancaster, NY over the last 12 months is $360,000, up 7% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
In Lancaster, there are currently 10 multi-family homes for sale, providing an appealing investment opportunity for buyers. With multi-family homes priced between $99,900 to $499,000, there's a range to accomodate every budget. As of September, 2025 the median home price in Lancaster is $384,900, while the average sale price is $378,786, offering insights into the local housing market. On average, multi-family homes spend 26 days listed before being sold. Multi-family homes include a variety of property types, from duplexes, triplexes, and fourplexes, to apartment complexes, all within a single building divided to accommodate multiple families living separately. These multi-family properties for sale offer investors the chance to generate rental income. Whether you're considering a duplex for a beginner investment or an apartment complex for a more substantial venture, there are investment properties available to meet your requirements. Explore the range of multi-family homes for sale in Lancaster, NY.
Copyright © 2025 CoStar Group
