$233,653Average Value$146Average Price per Sq Ft91Homes For Sale
Sleepy little city of Shelbyville
While the gridded streets of Shelbyville make it appear like a bustling city, “it’s a sleepy little community where everyone knows everybody,” explains Amy Limpus of the Property Shop of Indiana, the city's top agent and a lifelong resident of Shelbyville. “I grew up here, my husband grew up here, and we both have businesses in the community. We never thought about living anywhere else.” Despite its small-town feel, Shelbyville directly connects to the capital via nearby thoroughfares.
An aerial view showing some of Shelbyville's neighborhood streets.
This Ranch home is another example of the typical Shelbyville neighborhood.
1/2
Custom-built homes with a median in the $200,000s
Less than 35 miles from Indy, the city includes a range of custom-built homes constructed anywhere from the 1960s to the early 2000s. While some streets feature Arts and Crafts-style homes, others include bungalows and ranch-style architecture. Sidewalks link together the houses near downtown Shelbyville, but outlying homes offer a more secluded setting alongside farmland. “A typical three-bedroom ranch is probably going to be about $200,000, and that would be one that is older. More custom areas are brick, and they’re selling for much higher—close to $300,000,” Limpus explains.
Homes like this neat and well-kept ranch-style home are typical in the Shelbyville area.
You can find it in Shelbyville, from minor to spacious homes like this.
1/2
Learning through Shelbyville Central Schools
Part of Shelbyville Central Schools, the city's residents benefits from a B-rated district, according to Niche. Students start at Coulston Elementary, a B-minus-rated school, and transition to Shelbyville Middle, a school with a B rating. For high school, students attend B-rated Shelbyville High and gain access to academic teams like Spell Bowl and Quiz League, as well as organizations like Business Professionals of America and Robotics Club.
Kids can easily walk or bike to Shelbyville Middle School.
Shelbyville Sr High School educates teens in Shelbyville's neighborhoods.
1/2
Exercise for residents and their pups at Blue River Memorial Park
Though Shelbyville is a small city with a population of over 25,000, the rural roots of the city shine through its many parks and recreational opportunities. Blue River Memorial Park sits in northeast Shelbyville and includes over 180 acres of green space, including a butterfly habitat, walking trails and a dog park. Though Blue River is the most expansive option, Kennedy, Sunrise, Sunset and Morrison Park offer smaller-scale options closer to the downtown area. When it gets too cold to enjoy the outdoors, the Shelby County YMCA off Route 9 provides a space for locals to play pickleball, participate in group fitness classes or swim in an indoor pool. For an old-school movie experience, the Skyline Drive-In plays new flicks and classics in the eastern part of the city, a more rural section of Shelbyville. The location also includes a small arcade and a café with quick bites like hot dogs and unique eats like the Bonehill Cheeseburger—a burger between two soft pretzels.
Shelbyville's Blue River Memorial Park has abundant activities for the entire family.
The 10-acre Kennedy Park in Shelbyville has a shelter, playground and basketball courts.
1/2
Kroger in Shelbyville, more retail at the nearby Greenwood Park Mall
With several stores and restaurants in Shelbyville, residents don’t need to venture far to grab the essentials. Kroger is less than 2 miles east of the city center, and Walmart is less than 3 miles northeast. For larger-scale shopping trips, residents can reach Greenwood Park Mall in about 25 miles, home to national retailers like JCPenney, Macy’s and Foot Locker. Locally owned and operated restaurants make up most of the dining options in the Shelbyville. Grandma’s Pancake House takes care of breakfast and is within walking distance for those in the concentrated part of the city. Just half a mile north of Grandma’s, Pudder’s covers lunch or dinner. For nightlife, downtown Shelbyville stays lively with cozy bars like Capone’s Downtown Speakeasy and Willie Farkle’s.
Grandma's Pancake House in Shelbyville is known for breakfast, but check out the great lunch too.
Capone's Downtown Speakeasy in Shelbyville has the perfect vibe for your lunch or night out.
1/2
First Fridays and a Christmas parade
The Horseshoe Indianapolis Casino includes year-round entertainment close to home, but the city also hosts events throughout the year to connect the community. The monthly First Friday event highlights the area’s local shops, restaurants and musicians, and the Christmas Parade celebrates artists, the high school marching band and local organizations.
Travel into Indy via I-74
While there’s no public transportation, there are senior service vans that assist with access to medical care or trips to nearby MHP Major Hospital. For trips into Indy, there are multiple ramps to Interstate 74, including one to the north and west of downtown. If residents need to travel outside of Indiana, the Indianapolis International Airport is about 40 miles away.
Written By
Hannah Rainey
Photography Contributed By
Mark Chenoweth
Video By
Derek Fowler
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Tamara Scroggins,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Shelbyville, IN sell after 46 days on the market compared to the national average of 49 days. The median sale price for homes in Shelbyville, IN over the last 12 months is $239,480, up 9% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Just starting out? or Downsizing? This compact all electric home has everything you need and is just waiting for you! Cute 3 bedroom home in popular Loper Ponds. Fresh paint, newer carpet and flooring. Updated lighting. Efficient galley kitchen offers granite counter tops, fun wall covering, 2023 electric range/oven, microwave/convection range hood and refrigerator. There is even a handy
New Construction - August Completion! Built by Taylor Morrison, America's Most Trusted Homebuilder! Welcome to the Simplicity 2115 at 1961 Black Oak Drive in Twelve Oaks, where Midwest charm meets modern living. Enjoy parks, walking paths, and Blue River Memorial Park with 180 acres of green space, a dog park, and butterfly habitat. Downtown Shelbyville, recently revitalized, offers boutiques,
New Construction - Built by Taylor Morrison, America's Most Trusted Homebuilder - August Completion! Settle into Shelbyville, where small-town charm meets fresh energy. Explore a revitalized downtown filled with local boutiques, great eats, and live shows at the historic Strand Theater. Outdoor lovers will feel right at home with nearby parks, trails, and Blue River Memorial Park's 180 acres of
Enjoy a carefree lifestyle in this 3 bedroom, 2 full bath condo in Shelbyville. This home has a newer roof (taken care of by the HOA), newer laminate flooring throughout the home & kitchen appliances. This home offers an enormous living room/dining room space, plus a sunroom that was completely enclosed in the past few years. With a split floorplan, the primary suite is privately tucked away
Beautiful 5 bedroom, 3 full bath home in Eagle Brook now available! Enter from the covered front porch into the inviting foyer & take in the view of the formal dining room, formal living room & family room. The formal living room has a vaulted ceiling & tons of natural light, while the formal dining is situated near the kitchen & has engineered hardwood flooring. The enormous family room
Welcome to this large American Four Square on Shelby Street! This home offers tons of space, original wood floors, built-in shelving and many updates! The large foyer showcases the stairs to the 2nd and 3rd floors, and opens up to the generous sized living room, with a fireplace (non-functional) flanked with bookcases behind leaded glass. There is space for an enormous dining room suit & more
Offering one and two bedroom apartment homes in Shelbyville, IN 46176. Our pattern of ownership, development and management enables us to provide you with consistent, reliable and dedicated service. You'll love the place where you can call home and feel comfortable just being yourself. It's a place to relax at the end of a hard day, a place to entertain friends and to spend quality time with
Experience comfort and convenience in this updated apartment in Shelbyville! This charming one-bedroom rental offers a cozy retreat in the heart of Shelbyville. Enjoy a well-designed space with an open layout perfect for personalizing. The full bathroom enhances daily comfort. Located in a vibrant community, it provides easy access to local shops, dining, and entertainment. Ideal for a relaxing
Discover comfortable living at Loper Commons Apartments in Shelbyville,Indiana. Our pet-friendly community offers spacious one, two, and three-bedroomapartments with updated cabinetry, granite countertops, and fully equippedkitchens with upgraded appliances. Enjoy beautifully landscaped grounds, apond, and amenities like a playground, picnic & grill areas, a clubhouse,and a
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
