$550,000
970 Middleville Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
Custom colonial nestled in a picturesque setting on 4.81 acres, offers timeless charm and modern comfort. The Craftsman-style living room features a coffered ceiling and intricate woodwork, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The spacious eat-in kitchen includes a pantry and opens to a large deck through French doors?perfect for indoor-outdoor living.Enjoy the expansive family room with
JULIE KILLEN COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
$900 per month
936 Hampton Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
*ROOMS ONLY FOR RENT* Two rooms for rent- $900 monthly each. Bedrooms come unfurnished. You will have access to all common areas of the house; kitchen, living & dining room, bathrooms, and yard. Rent includes all utilities as well as passes to Crandon Lakes. Owner occupied. Dogs approved on case by case basis.
FRANCES LATAWIEC KISTLE REALTY, LLC.
$374,950 Sold Mar 17, 2025
945 County Road 521 Unit 949, Newton, NJ 07860
ANTHONY NELSON COLDWELL BANKER REALTY RDG
Est $355,644 Not Listed For Sale
944 E Walnut Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
$525,000
992 Stillwater Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
Tucked back from the road and surrounded by nature, this expanded brick ranch offers an incredible opportunity for those seeking space, privacy, and potential. Set on 6.90 acres backing to serene woods, this home is ready to be reimagined. Step inside to find a spacious layout with high ceilings and great flow throughout. The entryway features a soft archway that leads to the large family room
NICOLE MORESI KELLER WILLIAMS INTEGRITY
$2,900 per month
909 Cedar Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
Welcome home to this charming and well maintained 3 Bedroom Rental Home Located in the Paulinskill Lake Community. Tucked away from the hustle and bustle, you'll feel like you are in a fairytale woodland cottage. The interior of this home has been freshly painted and is light and bright and move in ready. This is truly one floor living with 3 Bedrooms, 1.5 baths, lots of closet space, a renovated
Tiffany Kjellander BETTER HOMES & GARDENS PORCHLIGHT
$600,000 Sold Mar 10, 2025
986 Fairview Lake Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
Denise Molnar RE/MAX TOWN & VALLEY
Est $288,939 Not Listed For Sale
934 Hampton Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
$639,900
955 Middleville Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
A rare find of 11.5 acres in Sussex County..As you enter the private driveway1.5 acres of level land is on the left. Continue to a comfortable three bedroom, two bath open concept ranch, beaming with sunlight, and views! Large charming living room with fireplace, stunning dining room, white modernized eat in country kitchen, primary master bedroom, second bedroom, full bath all on the main
Ricki Durino COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
$2,000 per month
922 Plymouth Lake Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
Lake living has never looked better! Cozy 3 Bed 1 Bath Ranch on a private lot with serene lake views is ready and waiting for you! Situated in the private Plymouth Lake community with nearby lake access. This charming home features 3 Bedrooms with New plush carpeting, 1 full bath with tub shower, a Large Eat in Kitchen with SS Appliances, Breakfast Bar, and a plethora of cabinetry for storing all
Patryk Krajewski RE/MAX 1st Advantage - Clark
$700,000 Sold Jun 13, 2025
907 Dove Island Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
KELSEY KISTLE KISTLE REALTY, LLC.
Est $659,361 Not Listed For Sale
925 Upper Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
$625,000 Pending
902 Sprout Hill Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
Welcome to peace and quiet! This incredible country homestead boasts 4BR (can easily be turned into 5), 2.5 baths, and over 3600 sqft of living space. Plus, a full basement partially finished which is currently being used as a gym and game room with a beautiful bar included. The property has just over 3 acres of land to enjoy and borders tranquil Swartswood State Park for endless outdoor
SARA ADAMAITIS WEICHERT REALTORS
$475,000 Sold Jun 13, 2025
1028 Stillwater Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
Kelly Holmquist KELLER WILLIAMS METROPOLITAN
Est $337,263 Not Listed For Sale
901 Poppy Trail, Newton, NJ 07860
$450,000 Pending
926 Cedar Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
WELCOME TO STILLWATER! Paulinskill Lake is a scenic, narrow, 3-mile-long lake situated in Sussex County. It was created in the 1920s by damming the Paulins Kill River, primarily to offer seasonal housing and recreational opportunities for all. Today, Paulinskill Lake is a vibrant, year-round residential community comprising over 500 homes! Amenities include well-maintained beach facilities, a
Matthew Regan KELLER WILLIAMS PROSPERITY REALTY
$456,000 Sold May 29, 2025
911 Homestead Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
MARY RUSSO-SIMEONE COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
Est $538,104 Not Listed For Sale
963 S Shore Terrace, Newton, NJ 07860
$575,000 Pending
902 W Walnut Dr Unit 904, Newton, NJ 07860
In-Law Suite Lake style home in Stillwater! Paulinskill Lake is a scenic, narrow, 3-mile-long lake situated in Sussex County. It was created in the 1920s by damming the Paulins Kill River, primarily to offer seasonal housing and recreational opportunities for all. Today, Paulinskill Lake is a vibrant, year-round residential community comprising over 500 homes! Amenities include well-maintained
Matthew Regan KELLER WILLIAMS PROSPERITY REALTY
$529,000 Sold May 23, 2025
1060 Stillwater Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
JENNIFER WEEKLEY EXP REALTY, LLC
Est $428,131 Not Listed For Sale
949 Edgewood Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
$489,000 Pending
917 Upper Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
Experience this charming Country Colonial Gem backing up to over 62,000 acres of Park Land in peaceful Plymouth Lake Community. This well-maintained residence offers a comfortable layout perfect for everyday living and entertaining. 3 Spacious Bedrooms featuring a Primary Suite including an En-Suite Bathroom, Stall Shower, Walk-In Closet & Walk Up Attic. Enjoy an absolute MASSIVE Backyard with
Mikhail Senderovich KELLER WILLIAMS - NJ METRO GROUP
$15,000 Sold May 07, 2025
00 Quail Trail, Stillwater Township, NJ 07860
Alison Miller REALTY EXECUTIVES EXCEPTIONAL
Est $397,959 Not Listed For Sale
906 Kill Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
$4,500,000
936 Dove Island Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
Set on over 40 private, wooded acres, 936 Dove Island Road is an awe-inspiring retreat with magazine-worthy organic gardens, private pond, and property features seen in numerous publications over the years. The Main Residence began as an old farmhouse and now hovers around 10,000 sf, featuring an expansive primary suite with dual dressing rooms, sitting room with fireplace, walk-in shower
Evelyn Tilney KL SOTHEBY'S INT'L. REALTY
$505,500 Sold May 05, 2025
931 Maple Ave, Newton, NJ 07860
Tanner Sommese KELLER WILLIAMS INTEGRITY
Est $406,130 Not Listed For Sale
921 Upper Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
$345,000
907 Meadowbrook Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
Nature and privacy come together to make a beautiful retreat at 907 Meadowbrook Road. This charming two-bedroom cottage on over 1.5 acres is tucked into the scenic woods of Stillwater, NJ and situated 1/ 4 mile from Paulinskill Lake, with membership that conveys to the new owner. In addition, Swartswood State Park and numerous trails can be found in under 3 miles from the front door- perfect for
Evelyn Tilney KL SOTHEBY'S INT'L. REALTY
$550,000 Sold Mar 12, 2025
914 Fairview Lake Ln, Blairstown, NJ 07825
NANCY ZINGONE COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
Est $251,897 Not Listed For Sale
929 Cedar Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
$799,000
1011 Stillwater Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
Welcome to your own private homestead retreat! Set on 19.02 acres (18.02 woodland-assessed), this beautifully updated home blends modern comfort with country charm. The front of the property is lined with mature evergreens, offering natural privacy and a peaceful, secluded feel. Inside, the kitchen features maple cabinetry, granite countertops, and new appliances, and is open to the dining and
Jennifer Meyler RE/MAX PLATINUM GROUP
$90,000 Sold Feb 26, 2025
907 Plymouth Lake Dr E, Newton, NJ 07860
Debra McGrath WEICHERT REALTORS
Est $300,762 Not Listed For Sale
911 Cedar Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
$495,000
1055-1057 Rt521, Stillwater Twp., NJ 07860
Extremely well taken care of investment property with 3 units fully rented & a current Cap Rate based on asking price of 7%. Low taxes. Located in the quiet rural area of Stillwater this property has 2 buildings. Option to live in one and rent other 2. The smaller building (unit 1) has 1-bedroom & 1 bathroom while the 2-family property has 1 bedroom & 1 bathroom on the ground floor level (unit
Damian Ryan REALTY EXECUTIVES MOUNTAIN PROP.
$649,000 Sold Feb 24, 2025
935 Five Points Ln, Newton, NJ 07860
Stacey Michelman REALTY EXECUTIVES EXCEPTIONAL
Est $413,507 Not Listed For Sale
1017 Mount Benevolence Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
$325,000
906 Upper Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
First time ever on the market for this cozy 3 - 4 Bedroom Cape home in the wonderful lake community of Lake Plymouth nestled on an extra wide lot. Lake dues are optional. Sold fully furnished and as is. Hardwood floors under carpet on 1st floor. Also Included in sale is all appliances, lawn equipment, and generator.
BRENDA LEE ZABRISKIE WEICHERT REALTORS
$420,000 Sold Feb 18, 2025
941 W End Dr, Newton, NJ 07860
REKA HUEBSCHER CORCORAN SAWYER SMITH
Est $651,773 Not Listed For Sale
938 Emmons Ln, Newton, NJ 07860
$250,000
0 Mount Benevolence Rd, Stillwater Township, NJ 07860
Magical 12A parcel w/babbling stream for fishing & fun*Great outdoor fishing/hunting site or build a weekend/fulltime dream home*800' of road frontage*Some paths on property*Perc test from 1990*Fantastic lot to build w/privacy but homes nearby for community*Absolutely beautiful land
mark royer RE/MAX COUNTRY REALTY
Showing Results 1 - 40, Page 1 of 18
On average, homes in Stillwater, NJ sell after 37 days on the market compared to the national average of 50 days. The median sale price for homes in Stillwater, NJ over the last 12 months is $392,500, up 26% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
The data relating to the real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of the NJMLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Ten-X are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Some properties listed with the participating brokers do not appear on this website at the request of the seller. Listings of brokers that do not participate in Internet Data Exchange do not appear on this website.
All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Source: New Jersey Multiple Listing, Inc.
© 2025 New Jersey Multiple Listing Service Inc. All rights reserved.
Homes.com Licensing Information
§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures
New York Fair Housing NoticeTREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice
California DRE #01937601
Contact Homes.com BrokerageCopyright © 2025 CoStar Group
