When to offer less than a home's list price

Key takeaways

• In a so-called balanced market, when buyer demand equals supply, offering 1% to 5% below asking price is typically competitive, but homes needing major repairs or sitting 60 days or more on the market may justify discounts of 5% to 10% or more.
• Five factors determine your offer price — comparable sales, market type, days on market, home condition and seller motivation.
• Non-price terms like a mortgage pre-approval letter, a larger earnest money deposit and flexible closing dates can make a below-asking offer more attractive to sellers than the dollar amount alone.

Figuring out how much below the asking price you should offer on a house that's for sale depends on several factors, including local market conditions, comparable sales and the property's condition. There is no single right number that works for every home or every market.

The size of the discount a seller will accept comes down to two variables: your leverage and the home’s condition, said Alex Blackwood, co-founder of Mogul, a real estate platform for investors.

"Leverage is what the market hands you," Blackwood said. "It's supply of homes, time on the market and how motivated the seller is."

"Condition is how far the home sits from move-in ready. The discipline is to price the gap, not the list price," added Blackwood. "In today’s market, with mortgage rates in the mid-6s and inventory rising, buyers hold more of that leverage than they have in years."

When Jessica Robinson of Family Nest North Central Florida helps buyers consider whether to offer less than the listing price, she always recommends they consider all factors involved rather than focusing on a single issue, she said.

"If at least two, if not all three of these situations are true, then I think it’s OK to offer less than the listing price: The listing has been up much longer than other listings in the area, the listing price is higher than comparable properties and it requires extensive repair work," said Robinson, whose Newberry, Florida-based agency helps seniors downsize. "The market in Florida right now is still in a place where buyers are still offering well over the asking price, even if the house has similar issues as I stated above."

Comparable sales, often called comps, are the single strongest indicator of fair market value. Agents will prepare a comparable market analysis of three to five recently sold homes, ideally closed within the past 90 days, that match your target property in size, style, condition and location. If the adjusted comp values cluster below the list price, you have data to support a lower offer. If they cluster at or above it, the home is likely priced fairly.

Related content:

• Making an offer on a home: What you need to know
• What is a comparative market analysis in real estate?

The right offer price is always grounded in comparable sales. Back up your bids with data. Ask your agent to include the competitive market analysis with your offer so the seller can see exactly which recent sales support your price. A documented offer is harder to dismiss than one that looks like a guess.

Certain ranges tend to fit certain situations, according to Blackwood and Chloe Shubin, vice president of operations and strategy at Griffin Funding, a mortgage company in San Diego.

This offer fits a home that is fundamentally sound, priced fairly, and on the market under 30 days, said Shubin. "Industry guidance generally treats this small a gap as a low-risk negotiation when comps support it, since the seller is likely optimistic and hasn't yet faced pressure to move," she said.

This offer is the norm in the give-and-take of a balanced market, and most sellers expect it, said Blackwood. It's a property that has been listed two to four weeks, priced in line with recent comparable sales, in a market carrying four to six months of inventory, he said. The house is sound and move-in ready, with only cosmetic gaps: paint, flooring, fixtures and a little deferred maintenance.

"You are not exploiting weakness at this level," said Blackwood. "You are trimming the cushion sellers build into the asking price."

A 6% to 10% discount applies once a listing crosses 30 to 60 days, particularly if there has already been one price reduction or the home shows cosmetic issues like outdated flooring or finishes, Shubin said. "Buyers justify this range with documented comps and the time-on-market signal itself, which tells a seller their original price didn't hold," she said.

"Here you need real leverage, and the market has to give it to you," Blackwood said. Look for the signatures of a buyer’s market: rising inventory, a listing sitting 45 or 60 days when homes in that neighborhood normally go in two weeks, and at least one price cut already posted, he said. "Seller motivation does the rest — a vacant home, a relocation, an estate sale, anyone carrying two mortgages at once."

In terms of the home's condition, it should have signs that it needs a rehab — dated kitchen and bathrooms, a roof or furnace near the end of its lifespan, Blackwood said. "A $15,000 roof and a failing HVAC are a number, not a feeling, and that number is what your discount should map to," he said.

A discount this deep almost always means that the home was mispriced from the start, or something is genuinely wrong with the property, the location or the seller's situation, Blackwood said.

It's often an oversupplied or stalling local market, a listing 90 days or longer with repeated price cuts, he said. A seller is usually distressed and out of options, he added.

The condition tends to involve major work: structural or foundation problems, full system replacement, or a flaw a renovation cannot solve, like a poor layout or a hard location, Blackwood said.

"At that point you are not really negotiating a discount. You are pricing in the work and the risk you are personally taking on, and a motivated seller knows it," he said.

An offer 11% or more below list is reasonable when a home carries significant condition issues, such as roof, foundation or major system problems, or has sat 60-plus days with multiple price cuts already on record, Shubin said.

"At this level the buyer typically pairs the number with an inspection report or contractor estimate, since a steep gap without documentation risks being dismissed outright rather than countered," Shubin said.

Related content:

• How to decide what to offer on a house: A buyer's guide

After settling on a price, non-price terms can strengthen the offer in the seller's view. Non-price terms often matter as much as the dollar amount. Here are the terms that carry the most weight.

Attach a mortgage pre-approval letter to your offer. Getting pre-approved confirms your income, assets and credit have already been verified. This reduces the seller's financing risk.

Pair it with a larger earnest money deposit. Offering 2% to 3% instead of the typical 1% signals financial strength and helps offset a lower purchase price.

Accommodate the seller's preferred closing date rather than insisting on your own. If the seller hasn't found their next home, a rent-back agreement — an arrangement in which the seller stays in the property as a tenant for a set period after closing — can be a strong incentive to accept a lower price.

Keep your inspection and financing contingencies in place because they protect you. But review whether a home-sale contingency or other non-standard conditions is truly necessary. Removing unnecessary contingencies tightens the deal without exposing you to major financial risk.

Related content:

• Mortgage pre-approval is your first step to homeownership
• Understanding earnest money: A guide for prospective homebuyers
• The key role appraisals play in your homebuying process

Can a seller refuse to counter if my offer is too low?

Yes. Sellers can accept your offer, counter it, reject it outright or simply ignore it. In most states, sellers have no legal obligation to respond to an offer. Offers significantly below the list price are especially likely to be dismissed without a reply. If the seller doesn't respond by the expiration deadline you set — typically 72 hours — the offer has expired. Your agent can follow up with the listing agent to gauge whether a revised offer would be considered.

Should I offer below asking price on a new-construction home?

New-construction pricing works differently from resale. Builders protect their listed prices to maintain property values across an entire community, but they routinely offer concessions on upgrades, closing costs, interest rate buy-downs and contract terms. A straight price reduction is rare because a single discounted sale can lower appraised values for the builder's other homes.

Your leverage increases with standing inventory and end-of-quarter timing. Buyers may have more success requesting upgrade credits or a rate buy-down rather than a lower base price.

How does paying with cash affect how much below asking I can offer?

Cash removes the financing contingency and the lender-required appraisal, which reduces the seller's risk that a deal might not conclude and can speed up closing significantly. A cash buyer can still hire an appraiser voluntarily for their own protection.

Can I renegotiate the price after a home inspection?

Yes. If the inspection uncovers problems the seller did not disclose or that were not visible during showings, you can request a price reduction, ask for a repair credit at closing or require the seller to complete repairs before the sale closes. The seller can agree, counter or refuse. If your contract includes an inspection contingency, you can walk away and typically recover your earnest money.

Is it better to offer below asking price or ask for seller concessions instead?

Both approaches reduce your out-of-pocket cost, but they work differently. A lower purchase price reduces your loan amount and monthly payment for the life of the mortgage. Seller concessions, such as closing-cost credits or a rate buy-down, keep the recorded price intact but lower your upfront cash or interest rate.

Using seller funds for a rate buy-down typically results in lower monthly payments than an equivalent price reduction. The right choice depends on whether you're more constrained by your monthly budget or your cash on hand at closing. Your agent and lender can model both scenarios side by side.

Related content:

• Buying a home in 10 steps
• How to make your offer for a home stand out from everyone else's